• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Socialism: utopian, democratic, Fabian, evolutionary, guild and Indian

Explain the main kinds of socialism described in the textbook, India's socialistic pattern of society, and the differences between communism and socialism.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define socialism and distinguish utopian from scientific socialism.
  • Explain democratic, Fabian, evolutionary and guild socialism, with their thinkers.
  • Describe socialism in India and compare communism with socialism.

Socialism, the textbook says, supports public ownership of property and natural resources, in contrast to liberalism's private ownership. Socialism and communism are sometimes used as if they meant the same thing, but Marx himself drew a line: he called his own theory scientific socialism and the earlier kinds utopian.

Utopian socialism

  • Robert Owen (an industrialist in Britain): started the co-operative movement and experimental communities, involved workers in managing his factories and showed that co-operation could raise profits.
  • Saint-Simon (France): argued that an efficient economy needs the welfare of workers to be considered.
  • Charles Fourier (France): proposed reorganising society into producers' associations called phalanges.

All three appealed to the reason and conscience of capitalists. Marx called this utopian because, in his view, it understood capitalism only superficially and offered wishful schemes.

Democratic socialism

It combines socialism with democracy. Unlike Marxism, it sees the state not as an instrument of exploitation but as an instrument of social welfare owned by all classes; socialism can be built only through the state, which should not wither away. Change should be evolutionary and peaceful (gradualism, or 'ballot-box socialism'), classes should live in harmony, and private property should be limited, not abolished.

Fabian, evolutionary and guild socialism

Three varieties compared
VarietyOrigin and thinkersMain ideas
Fabian socialismFabian Society, Britain, from 1884; named after the Roman general Fabius (wait, then strike hard at the right moment); Sidney Webb, Sydney Olivier, H. G. Wells, George Bernard ShawCapitalism is exploitative; a democratic state based on decentralised power and led by experts; limited right to property; change by persuasion, not revolution. The textbook notes that Jawaharlal Nehru was inspired by it in England
Evolutionary socialismFerdinand Lassalle in German Social Democracy; the Gotha Programme (1875); Eduard Bernstein's book *Evolutionary Socialism*Capitalism should change gradually; non-economic as well as economic factors explain human life. Marxists attacked it as 'revisionism'
Guild socialismBritain, first two decades of the twentieth century; G. D. H. Cole and the National Guilds LeagueRevives the medieval guild of craftsmen: each profession has its own organisation, joined in councils at district, state and national levels; the state keeps common functions such as education and health; peaceful change. Criticised as impractical because a state reduced to a guild could not keep order or defend itself

Socialism in India

India adopted the socialistic pattern of society in the mid-1950s, aiming to provide basic necessities to all regardless of caste, creed, religion, race or gender, and to remove poverty, inequality and illiteracy. The Planning Commission was set up in 1950 and Five-Year Plans began in 1951. India chose a mixed economy, with the public sector at the 'commanding heights'. The 42nd Amendment (1976) added the word 'socialist' to the Preamble; the 44th Amendment (1978) removed the right to property from the Fundamental Rights and made it a legal right in Part XII (Article 300A); and the Directive Principles in Part IV include socialist aims such as the right to work and preventing concentration of wealth. The textbook says India followed socialism from independence until the 1991 reforms.

Communism and socialism compared

Communism and (democratic) socialism

  • Communism
    • Revolution is the midwife of change
    • State is an instrument of exploitation; abolish it
    • Class struggle drives history
    • Abolish private property
    • Economy alone drives history (historical materialism)
  • Socialism
    • Evolutionary change lasts longer
    • Keep the state; make it democratic and welfare-oriented
    • Violent class struggle is unnecessary
    • Limit private property for social welfare
    • Culture, politics and religion matter too

Both communism and democratic socialism aim to end the exploitation of workers and promote equality; they differ on the means (revolution or gradual reform) and on the state (abolish it or democratise it).

— Key comparison

Worked example 1: name the variety

A made-up proposal says: 'Teachers, doctors, weavers and engineers will each form their own association; these will send members to district and national councils that run most public affairs.' Reasoning: organisation by profession, inspired by medieval craft associations, with councils at several levels, is the mark of guild socialism. Answer: guild socialism (G. D. H. Cole).

Worked example 2: finding socialism in the Constitution

List three places where the textbook finds socialist aims in the Indian Constitution. Answer: (1) the word 'socialist' in the Preamble, added by the 42nd Amendment; (2) the change of property from a Fundamental Right to a legal right by the 44th Amendment; (3) Directive Principles in Part IV, such as the right to work and avoiding concentration of wealth.

Key takeaways: Marx contrasted his scientific socialism with the utopian socialism of Owen, Saint-Simon and Fourier. Democratic, Fabian, evolutionary and guild socialism all reject revolution, keep the state and limit rather than abolish property. India followed a socialistic pattern of society with planning and a mixed economy until 1991.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Marx described the ideas of Owen, Saint-Simon and Fourier as:

    1. Scientific socialism
    2. Fabian socialism
    3. Utopian socialism
    4. Guild socialism
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Marx called them utopian because, in his view, they understood capitalism only superficially and appealed to capitalists' conscience; he called his own theory scientific socialism.

  2. 2. Fabian socialism takes its name from:

    1. a Roman general
    2. a Russian revolutionary
    3. an English king
    4. a German philosopher
    Show answer

    Answer: A. It is named after the Roman general Fabius, famous for waiting and striking hard at the right moment, reflecting its gradual approach.

  3. 3. Match correctly: Robert Owen, Eduard Bernstein, G. D. H. Cole, George Bernard Shaw.

    1. Fabian; guild; utopian; evolutionary
    2. Utopian; evolutionary; guild; Fabian
    3. Evolutionary; utopian; Fabian; guild
    4. Guild; Fabian; evolutionary; utopian
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Owen was a utopian socialist, Bernstein wrote Evolutionary Socialism, Cole led guild socialism, and Shaw was a leading Fabian.

  4. 4. Which Constitutional Amendment added the word 'socialist' to the Preamble?

    1. 44th
    2. 1st
    3. 73rd
    4. 42nd
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The 42nd Amendment added 'socialist' to the Preamble. The 44th Amendment removed the right to property from the Fundamental Rights.

  5. 5. Which of these is a view of democratic socialism, not of communism?

    1. The state should be abolished
    2. The state is an instrument of social welfare and should be made more democratic
    3. Revolution is the midwife of change
    4. Private property must be abolished
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Democratic socialism keeps the state as an instrument of welfare. The other three are communist positions in the textbook's comparison.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery