- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Anarchism: a society without rulers
Explain the meaning and origin of anarchism, its view of the state as an unnecessary evil, its principles of self-determination and self-ownership, how it differs from Marxism, its kinds and its criticism.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Give the origin of the word anarchism and name its main thinkers.
- Explain why anarchism calls the state an unnecessary evil and what it wants in its place.
- Compare anarchism with negative liberalism and Marxism, list its kinds and state its criticisms.
In everyday speech 'anarchy' means chaos. The Tamil Nadu textbook shows that the ideology of anarchism means something quite different: not a society without rules, but a society without rulers. Unit 9 opens with it before moving to feminism, communitarianism, postmodernism and environmentalism.
Meaning and thinkers
Anarchism advocates self-governed societies built on the natural co-operative instincts of human beings. The word comes from the Greek anarchos, 'without authority'. It seeks to free people from the state, property and religion and to replace them with voluntary associations. Its thinkers include Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, one of the earliest, famous for calling property theft; Mikhail Bakunin, who argued that wherever there is a state one class dominates another, so all states must go; the Russian thinker Peter Kropotkin, for whom authority and freedom cannot exist together; and the writer Leo Tolstoy. In the twenty-first century Gerard Casey has argued that all states, not only repressive ones, are criminal organisations.
Core ideas
- The state is an unnecessary evil: it suppresses rights and liberties and hinders moral development, and performs no useful function, so it should be abolished at once.
- Order without the state: humans are naturally co-operative; the artificial state suppresses this instinct. In its place, voluntary associations in which everyone takes part willingly.
- Self-determination: each person decides his or her own life.
- Self-ownership: each person fully owns himself or herself, the most basic form of property.
- Opposition to other institutions: family and religion are also criticised as sources of exploitation; some anarchists see property as tyranny and a source of crime.
| Ideology | View of the state | What should happen to it |
|---|---|---|
| Negative liberalism | A necessary evil | Keep it, but limit it to law and order |
| Marxism | An instrument of class exploitation | It will wither away after socialism is established |
| Anarchism | An unnecessary evil | Destroy it immediately and replace it with voluntary associations |
Kinds of anarchism
Kinds of anarchism named in the textbook
- Philosophical anarchism
- Socialist anarchism
- Revolutionary anarchism
-
Libertarian anarchism
- Wants the state reduced to the minimum rather than abolished
Not every kind demands abolition: libertarian anarchism would restrict the state as far as possible. Most anarchist philosophers, however, do call for abolition.
Criticism
Critics say anarchism is too optimistic about human nature. Not everyone is co-operative, and people are emotional as well as rational, so a co-operative person may become selfish. Without a state, problems such as terrorism, cybercrime and pollution could grow out of control, and extremist groups might even gain access to nuclear weapons.
Anarchism: not a society without rules, but a society without rulers, based on voluntary co-operation, self-determination and self-ownership.
Worked example 1: whose view?
Statement: 'The state must be abolished, but only after a period in which workers use it to end private ownership of production.' Step 1: abolition of the state is shared by anarchism and Marxism. Step 2: anarchism wants immediate abolition; the delay and the use of the state by workers belong to Marxism's dictatorship of the proletariat. Answer: Marxism, not anarchism.
Worked example 2: anarchy in practice
A made-up residents' group in a town cleans its lake, shares tools and settles disputes through a meeting everyone may attend, with no elected head and no paid officials. Reasoning: voluntary association, participation by all and no rulers match the anarchist ideal. Evaluation: a critic would ask how such a group would deal with a member who refuses to co-operate, or with dangers beyond the town, which is the textbook's main objection.
Key takeaways: anarchism, from anarchos (without authority), sees the state as an unnecessary evil and wants voluntary associations instead. It rests on co-operation, self-determination and self-ownership, opposes state, property, religion and sometimes family, and wants the state destroyed at once, unlike Marxism. Critics call it naive about human nature.
Check your understanding
-
1. The word 'anarchism' comes from the Greek 'anarchos', meaning:
- rule of many
- without authority
- love of order
- rule of law
Show answer
Answer: B. Anarchos means without authority; anarchism seeks a society without rulers.
-
2. Which thinker famously described property as theft?
- Peter Kropotkin
- Leo Tolstoy
- Mikhail Bakunin
- Pierre-Joseph Proudhon
Show answer
Answer: D. Proudhon, one of the earliest anarchist thinkers, described property (profit) as theft.
-
3. How does anarchism differ from negative liberalism in its view of the state?
- Anarchism calls the state an unnecessary evil; negative liberalism calls it a necessary evil
- Both call the state a positive good
- Anarchism wants a larger state
- Negative liberalism wants the state abolished
Show answer
Answer: A. Negative liberalism keeps the state as a necessary evil for law and order; anarchism rejects it as unnecessary and wants it destroyed.
-
4. Which kind of anarchism wants the state restricted to the minimum rather than abolished?
- Revolutionary anarchism
- Socialist anarchism
- Libertarian anarchism
- Philosophical anarchism
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says libertarian anarchism wants the state reduced to the minimum possible extent, although most anarchists call for abolition.
-
5. The main criticism of anarchism given in the textbook is that it:
- gives too much power to the state
- is too optimistic about human nature and ignores its selfish side
- supports private property too strongly
- depends on religion
Show answer
Answer: B. Critics say anarchism's assumption that all people are naturally co-operative is naive; without a state, crime and violence could spiral out of control.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.