- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Feminism: schools of thought and women's empowerment in India
Explain the meaning of feminism and its five schools (liberal, Marxist, radical, eco and post-colonial), and the steps taken by the Indian state to empower and protect women.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define feminism and say when it emerged.
- Compare liberal, Marxist, radical, eco and post-colonial feminism, with their thinkers.
- Describe constitutional and legal measures for women's empowerment in India.
Feminism refers to the movements and ideologies that work for the empowerment of women so that they achieve equality with men. The Tamil Nadu textbook says feminist schools of thought entered modern political theory in the last decades of the nineteenth century. The textbook quotes Cheris Kramarae's well-known line that feminism is the radical notion that women are people. Feminists agree on the goal, equality, but disagree about why women have been subordinated and what must change.
Five schools of feminism
| School | Cause of women's subordination | Remedy | Thinkers named |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liberal | Lack of political and economic rights | Votes and equal rights; the state is seen as gender-neutral. Its greatest success was winning the vote for women in Western democracies | Early movement of the late 19th century |
| Marxist | Private property, controlled by men | Women's liberation together with workers' liberation; communism without private property | Friedrich Engels, *The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State* |
| Radical | Patriarchy deliberately creates gender differences | Revolutionary reordering of society in both personal and public spheres | Simone de Beauvoir, *The Second Sex*; Carol Hanisch |
| Eco | Patriarchy degrades both women and nature | End male domination to protect women and environment | Françoise d'Eaubonne, Rosemary Ruether, Ynestra King, Vandana Shiva |
| Post-colonial | Colonialism and patriarchy together ('double colonisation') | Recognise that women are not one uniform group; attend to class, race, religion and country | Audre Lorde, Gayatri Spivak, Chandra Talpade Mohanty, Ethel Crowley |
Radical feminism and 'the personal is political'
Radical feminists hold that there are no innate differences in ability between men and women; inequality is created by patriarchy, a male-dominated society and culture. Simone de Beauvoir's famous idea is that one is not born a woman but is made one. The slogan 'the personal is political', associated with Carol Hanisch, attacks the liberal division of life into a private sphere (family, supposedly ruled only by love) and a public sphere (politics, ruled by men). Radical feminists argue that power, competition and domination exist inside the family too, so rights and equality must be discussed there as well.
The liberal division of spheres and the radical feminist reply
-
Liberal view
- Private sphere: family, love and affection
- No conflict, so no need for rights there
- Public sphere: politics, a male domain
-
Radical feminist view
- Domination exists in the family too
- Rights and equality apply at home
- The personal is political
Eco and post-colonial feminism
Eco feminism fuses feminism with environmentalism. Within it the textbook distinguishes a radical strand (patriarchy subjugates both women and nature) and a cultural strand (women are closer to nature as food providers and in reproduction, and suffer more from environmental damage because of the work assigned to them). Post-colonial feminism arose in the 1980s in formerly colonised countries of Asia and Africa. It rejects Western feminism's habit of universalising its own experience and of portraying non-Western women as passive victims, and it argues that these women faced racism, slavery and forced migration as well as patriarchy.
The Indian state and women's empowerment
- 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments: one-third of seats in panchayats and urban local bodies reserved for women, which the textbook says has led to their political empowerment.
- Vishaka Guidelines: laid down by the Supreme Court to protect women from sexual harassment at the workplace; followed by the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, which set up Internal and Local Complaints Committees.
- Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005: protection from violence within the home.
- Reservation in legislatures: the textbook describes the long-standing demand for one-third of seats in Parliament and state legislatures. In 2023, after the textbook was printed, Parliament passed a constitutional amendment providing this reservation in the Lok Sabha and state assemblies, to take effect after a fresh census and delimitation.
All feminists seek equality; they differ on the cause of inequality: lack of rights (liberal), private property (Marxist), patriarchy (radical), patriarchy over women and nature (eco), or colonialism plus patriarchy (post-colonial).
Worked example 1: which school?
A made-up writer argues: 'A village woman in a former colony carries burdens of caste, poverty and colonial history that a well-off woman in Europe never faced, so one feminist programme cannot fit both.' Reasoning: the stress on differences among women and on colonialism points to post-colonial feminism. Answer: post-colonial feminism, which the textbook's own exercise calls apt for countries like India.
Worked example 2: applying 'the personal is political'
In a made-up family, the daughter is expected to do all the housework while her brother studies, and no one sees this as a political matter. Liberal view: this is private family life, outside politics. Radical feminist view: the unequal division of work is a form of power and domination, so equality must be demanded at home as well as in public life. This is what 'the personal is political' means.
Key takeaways: feminism seeks women's empowerment and equality. Liberal feminism won the vote; Marxist feminism links subordination with property; radical feminism blames patriarchy and says the personal is political; eco feminism links women and nature; post-colonial feminism adds colonialism and differences among women. India has reserved local body seats and passed laws against workplace harassment and domestic violence.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which school of feminism traces women's subordination to the rise of private property controlled by men?
- Liberal feminism
- Post-colonial feminism
- Marxist feminism
- Eco feminism
Show answer
Answer: C. Marxist feminism, following Engels's The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State, links subordination to private property.
-
2. The slogan 'the personal is political' means that:
- we should discuss the private lives of leaders
- rights and equality for women must be discussed in the family as well as in public life
- personal matters must be kept out of politics
- politicians should be personally honest
Show answer
Answer: B. Radical feminists use it to show that domination exists in the family too, so women's rights and equality apply at home as well.
-
3. Which pair is correctly matched?
- Simone de Beauvoir - The Second Sex
- Vandana Shiva - liberal feminism
- Audre Lorde - Marxist feminism
- Friedrich Engels - eco feminism
Show answer
Answer: A. De Beauvoir wrote The Second Sex. Vandana Shiva is an eco feminist, Audre Lorde is linked with post-colonial feminism, and Engels with Marxist feminism.
-
4. 'Double colonisation' in post-colonial feminism refers to:
- two colonial powers ruling one country
- colonialism and patriarchy together
- the vote and property rights
- eco and radical feminism
Show answer
Answer: B. Post-colonial feminism argues that women in formerly colonised societies suffered both colonialism and patriarchy.
-
5. Which constitutional amendments reserved one-third of seats in panchayats and urban local bodies for women?
- 42nd and 44th
- 1st and 7th
- 61st and 86th
- 73rd and 74th
Show answer
Answer: D. The 73rd (panchayats) and 74th (urban local bodies) Amendments reserve one-third of seats for women.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.