- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Environmentalism: shallow and deep ecology and India's ecological movements
Compare shallow and deep ecology, explain Heywood's social, modernist and deep ecology with eco-socialism, eco-anarchism and eco-feminism, and describe four ecological movements of India.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Compare shallow ecology and deep ecology.
- Explain Andrew Heywood's three kinds of ecology in political theory, including the three trends of social ecology.
- Describe the Bishnoi, Chipko, Appiko and Save Silent Valley movements.
Development driven by modern science and technology has brought ecological crises such as ozone depletion, climate change and acid rain. Environmentalism arose as a protest movement and ideology against this destruction, since we have only one habitable planet. The textbook frames the debate around one question: what is the relationship between human beings and nature?
Shallow ecology and deep ecology
Two views of ecology
-
Shallow ecology
- Anthropocentric: humans at the centre
- Nature has instrumental value: useful to people
- Technological fixes such as renewable energy
- Reduce, reuse, recycle
- Standard of living should keep rising
-
Deep ecology
- Biocentric equality: humans one species among millions
- All life has intrinsic value
- Use nature only for vital needs; protect biodiversity
- Limit population; change economy, technology and politics
- Quality of life over standard of living
The term deep ecology was coined in 1973 by the Norwegian philosopher Arne Naess, who was influenced by Rachel Carson and Mahatma Gandhi. It sees the Earth as three linked parts (human beings, other living forms, and non-living objects and forces) and rejects anthropocentrism. Humans are 'ecological selves' who should reduce their ecological footprint by living simply. It is 'deep' because it asks deeper questions of how and why human life affects the rest of the ecosphere. The textbook names the American philosopher Anthony Weston as a supporter of shallow ecology. A saying often attributed to Gandhi sums up the moral concern: the Earth has enough for everyone's need, but not for anyone's greed.
Ecology in political theory (Andrew Heywood)
Heywood's three kinds of ecology
-
Social ecology (term coined by Murray Bookchin)
- Eco-socialism: capitalism is the enemy of ecology (Rudolf Bahro, From Red to Green)
- Eco-anarchism: authority is the enemy of ecology (Murray Bookchin)
- Eco-feminism: patriarchy is the enemy of ecology (Carolyn Merchant, The Death of Nature)
-
Modernist ecology
- Same as shallow ecology
- Reconciles liberalism with ecology
- Enlightened anthropocentrism
- Inter-generational justice; sustainable development
-
Deep ecology
- A new politics respecting the interconnection of humans, other life and the non-living world
- Eco-socialism: capitalism's materialism, consumerism and unlimited property rights treat nature as a commodity; only socialism can protect the environment.
- Eco-anarchism: the rise of authority (state, religion, even family) led to domination of people over people and of people over nature; a society of voluntary co-operation would protect both.
- Eco-feminism: patriarchy sees both women and nature only in terms of use value; gender- and ecology-sensitive politics is needed.
- Modernist ecology: humans remain at the centre but must weigh long-term interests. We have borrowed the Earth from future generations (inter-generational justice), so development must be sustainable: 'getting richer slower' rather than 'getting richer faster'.
Ecological movements in India
| Movement | Where and when | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Bishnoi (Khejarli) movement | Khejarli village, Rajasthan, 18th century | The Bishnoi sect, founded by Guru Jambheshwar and named after his 29 principles, protected trees in the Thar desert. When soldiers of the Maharaja of Jodhpur came to fell the trees, Amrita Devi hugged a tree and was killed; 363 people gave their lives. The Maharaja recalled the army, apologised and declared the area protected |
| Chipko movement | Alaknanda valley, then in Uttar Pradesh (now Uttarakhand), 1973 | 'Chipko' means to hug. Villagers, especially women, hugged trees to stop contractors felling them. Organised by Chandi Prasad Bhatt's Dasholi Gram Swarajya Mandal and joined by Sundarlal Bahuguna; it spread across the Himalaya and led to a ban on felling in 1980. The textbook calls it a fusion of feminism, environmentalism and Gandhism |
| Appiko movement | Uttara Kannada district, Karnataka, Western Ghats | 'Appiko' means to embrace in Kannada; inspired by Chipko. Aims: conserve the remaining forests, reforest bare land, and spread ideas of rational use. According to the textbook, forest cover in the district fell from 81 per cent in 1950 to 24 per cent in 1980 |
| Save Silent Valley movement | Palakkad district, Kerala, 1970s-1980s | Protest by the Kerala Sastra Sahitya Parishad and others against a hydro-electric project on the Kunthipuzha river that threatened the valley's evergreen forest and wildlife such as the lion-tailed macaque. The project was dropped, the valley became a national park in 1984 and later the core of the Nilgiri Biosphere Reserve |
Shallow ecology asks how nature can serve people better; deep ecology asks why people think nature exists only to serve them.
Worked example 1: shallow or deep?
Two made-up proposals for a polluted river: (i) build a treatment plant so the city can keep drawing water and factories can keep running; (ii) cut the city's demand, restore the riverbank forest and protect the river's fish for their own sake. Reasoning: (i) treats the river as a resource and seeks a technological fix, which is shallow ecology. (ii) gives the river's life intrinsic value and asks people to change how they live, which is deep ecology.
Worked example 2: matching ideas to trends
Match each claim to a trend of social ecology: (a) 'The profit motive turns forests into commodities.' (b) 'The same domination that made rulers and subjects made humans masters of nature.' (c) 'Women and nature are both treated only as useful objects.' Answer: (a) eco-socialism, since the enemy is capitalism; (b) eco-anarchism, since the enemy is authority; (c) eco-feminism, since the enemy is patriarchy.
Key takeaways: shallow (modernist) ecology keeps humans at the centre and seeks technological and sustainable solutions; deep ecology, from Arne Naess, asserts biocentric equality and deep change. Heywood adds social ecology with its eco-socialist, eco-anarchist and eco-feminist trends. India's Bishnoi, Chipko, Appiko and Silent Valley movements show non-violent popular action to protect nature.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who coined the term 'deep ecology' in 1973?
- Murray Bookchin
- Rachel Carson
- Andrew Heywood
- Arne Naess
Show answer
Answer: D. The Norwegian philosopher Arne Naess coined the term deep ecology in 1973; he was influenced by Rachel Carson and Gandhi.
-
2. 'Reduce, reuse and recycle' is a strategy associated with:
- Shallow ecology
- Deep ecology
- Eco-anarchism
- Eco-socialism
Show answer
Answer: A. Shallow ecology looks for practical and technological solutions such as the three Rs, without questioning human centrality.
-
3. Inter-generational justice and sustainable development are characteristic of:
- Eco-anarchism
- Modernist ecology
- Radical feminism
- Anarchism
Show answer
Answer: B. Modernist ecology holds that we have borrowed the Earth from future generations and must develop sustainably, 'getting richer slower'.
-
4. The Chipko movement of 1973 began in:
- the Thar desert of Rajasthan
- the Western Ghats of Karnataka
- the Alaknanda valley in the Himalaya
- the Palakkad district of Kerala
Show answer
Answer: C. Chipko began in the Alaknanda valley, then in Uttar Pradesh and now in Uttarakhand. Rajasthan is linked with the Bishnoi, Karnataka with Appiko and Palakkad with Silent Valley.
-
5. In the Bishnoi Khejarli episode, according to the textbook, how many people gave their lives to protect the trees?
- 29
- 1973
- 81
- 363
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says 363 people sacrificed their lives. 29 is the number of the sect's principles; 1973 is the year of Chipko; 81 per cent was Uttara Kannada's forest cover in 1950.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.