• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Communitarianism: the individual as a member of a community

Explain the emergence and thinkers of communitarianism and its views on the individual, the state, rights and justice, with Putnam's idea of social capital and the libertarian criticism.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe how and against what communitarianism emerged, and name its thinkers.
  • Explain the 'situated self' and the communitarian views of the state, rights and justice.
  • Explain Putnam's idea of social capital and the criticism of communitarianism.

Are we first individuals who later choose to join society, or are we formed by our communities from the start? Communitarianism answers the second way. The textbook describes it as balancing the rights and responsibilities of the individual with those of the community.

Emergence and thinkers

The word 'communitarian' was coined in the 1840s by the British socialist Goodwyn Barmby, but the doctrine took shape only in the 1980s, when Michael Sandel wrote Liberalism and the Limits of Justice, criticising John Rawls's individual-centred theory of justice. Other thinkers the textbook names are Alasdair MacIntyre, Michael Walzer, Charles Taylor, Amitai Etzioni and Will Kymlicka. Communitarianism rose against two ideologies: libertarianism, for over-emphasising the individual, and Marxism, for reducing everything to class. Its main target was libertarianism, then the dominant philosophy in the West.

The importance of community

People are not born in a vacuum. They inherit a community and culture that shape their beliefs, behaviour, skills and attitudes, and they build their lives on these shared capacities. So the individual is not an 'unencumbered self' standing alone but a 'situated self', rooted in a community. The textbook's own illustration is language: a child raised in Tamil Nadu grows up speaking Tamil fluently, not Japanese, and a child in Japan the reverse.

Two pictures of the self

  • Libertarian: unencumbered self
    • Individual comes first
    • Free of social ties
    • Chooses ends independently
    • Rights prior to the common good
  • Communitarian: situated self
    • Community comes first
    • Rooted in culture and tradition
    • Ends shaped by the community
    • Common good prior to individual rights

State, rights and justice

  • The state: a positive instrument of the common good, which every community develops. It should protect traditions that sustain the common good, act against individual goods that conflict with it, and be democratically elected, responsible and responsive to the community.
  • Rights: closely linked with responsibilities. The common good has priority over individual rights. Communitarians propose positive rights for community members, such as state-subsidised education and housing, a safe environment and universal health care. Responsive communitarians seek a synthesis of rights and responsibilities.
  • Justice: communitarians reject the universalism of Rawls and libertarian thinkers, who hold that one theory of justice, based on reason, applies everywhere. They hold a particularistic view: each community develops its own idea of justice.

Social capital

Robert D. Putnam studied bowling in America. In earlier days many Americans bowled together and built networks, knowledge and skills, which he called social capital. As television and the internet took up people's time, these interactions declined, social capital eroded, and with less public engagement the quality of democracy suffered.

Putnam's argument

  1. Shared activities People meet regularly in clubs and games
  2. Social capital grows Networks, trust, skills
  3. Activities decline Time shifts to screens and gadgets
  4. Social capital erodes Less interaction and public engagement
  5. Democracy weakens Political apathy rises

Criticism: libertarians argue that putting the community above the individual can prepare the way for collectivism and authoritarianism.

Communitarianism: the individual is a situated self, the common good comes before individual rights, rights go with responsibilities, and justice differs from community to community.

— Summary to remember

Worked example 1: universal or particular justice?

Two made-up villages divide a shared well's water differently: one gives equal shares to every household, the other gives more to households with farm animals. A visitor insists only one rule can be just everywhere. Communitarian reply: each community develops its own idea of justice from its way of life, so both arrangements may be just for their communities. This is the particularistic view of justice, against universalism.

Worked example 2: is it a positive right?

Which of these would communitarians call positive rights? (i) state-subsidised housing; (ii) freedom from arrest without a reason; (iii) universal health care. Reasoning: positive rights are things the state provides for community members; (ii) is a protection against the state rather than a provision by it. Answer: (i) and (iii).

Key takeaways: communitarianism, shaped by Sandel's critique of Rawls in the 1980s, sees people as situated selves formed by community. It wants a positive, democratic state serving the common good, positive rights tied to responsibilities and a particular, not universal, idea of justice. Putnam showed how social capital supports democracy; libertarians warn of collectivism.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Communitarianism emerged as a doctrine in the 1980s mainly through which book?

    1. Michael Sandel's Liberalism and the Limits of Justice
    2. John Rawls's A Theory of Justice
    3. Robert Nozick's Anarchy, State and Utopia
    4. Karl Marx's Das Kapital
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says communitarianism emerged when Michael Sandel wrote Liberalism and the Limits of Justice, criticising Rawls.

  2. 2. According to communitarianism, the individual is best described as:

    1. an unencumbered self
    2. an atomistic entity
    3. a situated self embedded in the community
    4. a purely selfish being
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Communitarians reject the unencumbered, atomistic self and see each person as rooted in a community and culture.

  3. 3. Which kind of rights does communitarianism propagate?

    1. Natural rights only
    2. Positive rights such as subsidised education, housing and health care
    3. Unlimited property rights
    4. No rights at all
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Communitarians propose positive rights for members of the community, such as subsidised education and housing, a safe environment and universal health care.

  4. 4. On justice, communitarians hold that:

    1. one theory of justice applies to all societies
    2. justice is decided by the market
    3. justice is the will of the strongest
    4. each community develops its own idea of justice
    Show answer

    Answer: D. They reject the universalism of Rawls and others and hold a particularistic view: justice differs from community to community.

  5. 5. Robert Putnam's study of bowling in America showed that:

    1. television strengthened democracy
    2. declining shared activities eroded social capital and weakened democracy
    3. bowling caused political violence
    4. community life had no link with democracy
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Putnam found that as people stopped bowling together and spent time on gadgets, social capital eroded and public engagement and democracy suffered.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery