Revision notes

Unit 9 Political Ideologies - Part II: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Anarchism: a society without rulers

Three views of the state compared
IdeologyView of the stateWhat should happen to it
Negative liberalismA necessary evilKeep it, but limit it to law and order
MarxismAn instrument of class exploitationIt will wither away after socialism is established
AnarchismAn unnecessary evilDestroy it immediately and replace it with voluntary associations

Kinds of anarchism named in the textbook

  • Philosophical anarchism
  • Socialist anarchism
  • Revolutionary anarchism
  • Libertarian anarchism
    • Wants the state reduced to the minimum rather than abolished

Anarchism: not a society without rules, but a society without rulers, based on voluntary co-operation, self-determination and self-ownership.

— Key idea

Key takeaways: anarchism, from anarchos (without authority), sees the state as an unnecessary evil and wants voluntary associations instead. It rests on co-operation, self-determination and self-ownership, opposes state, property, religion and sometimes family, and wants the state destroyed at once, unlike Marxism. Critics call it naive about human nature.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Feminism: schools of thought and women's empowerment in India

The schools of feminism described in the textbook
SchoolCause of women's subordinationRemedyThinkers named
LiberalLack of political and economic rightsVotes and equal rights; the state is seen as gender-neutral. Its greatest success was winning the vote for women in Western democraciesEarly movement of the late 19th century
MarxistPrivate property, controlled by menWomen's liberation together with workers' liberation; communism without private propertyFriedrich Engels, *The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State*
RadicalPatriarchy deliberately creates gender differencesRevolutionary reordering of society in both personal and public spheresSimone de Beauvoir, *The Second Sex*; Carol Hanisch
EcoPatriarchy degrades both women and natureEnd male domination to protect women and environmentFrançoise d'Eaubonne, Rosemary Ruether, Ynestra King, Vandana Shiva
Post-colonialColonialism and patriarchy together ('double colonisation')Recognise that women are not one uniform group; attend to class, race, religion and countryAudre Lorde, Gayatri Spivak, Chandra Talpade Mohanty, Ethel Crowley

The liberal division of spheres and the radical feminist reply

  • Liberal view
    • Private sphere: family, love and affection
    • No conflict, so no need for rights there
    • Public sphere: politics, a male domain
  • Radical feminist view
    • Domination exists in the family too
    • Rights and equality apply at home
    • The personal is political

All feminists seek equality; they differ on the cause of inequality: lack of rights (liberal), private property (Marxist), patriarchy (radical), patriarchy over women and nature (eco), or colonialism plus patriarchy (post-colonial).

— Summary to remember

Key takeaways: feminism seeks women's empowerment and equality. Liberal feminism won the vote; Marxist feminism links subordination with property; radical feminism blames patriarchy and says the personal is political; eco feminism links women and nature; post-colonial feminism adds colonialism and differences among women. India has reserved local body seats and passed laws against workplace harassment and domestic violence.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Communitarianism: the individual as a member of a community

Two pictures of the self

  • Libertarian: unencumbered self
    • Individual comes first
    • Free of social ties
    • Chooses ends independently
    • Rights prior to the common good
  • Communitarian: situated self
    • Community comes first
    • Rooted in culture and tradition
    • Ends shaped by the community
    • Common good prior to individual rights

Putnam's argument

  1. Shared activities People meet regularly in clubs and games
  2. Social capital grows Networks, trust, skills
  3. Activities decline Time shifts to screens and gadgets
  4. Social capital erodes Less interaction and public engagement
  5. Democracy weakens Political apathy rises

Communitarianism: the individual is a situated self, the common good comes before individual rights, rights go with responsibilities, and justice differs from community to community.

— Summary to remember

Key takeaways: communitarianism, shaped by Sandel's critique of Rawls in the 1980s, sees people as situated selves formed by community. It wants a positive, democratic state serving the common good, positive rights tied to responsibilities and a particular, not universal, idea of justice. Putnam showed how social capital supports democracy; libertarians warn of collectivism.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Postmodernism: many truths, particularism and identity politics

Modernity and postmodernism

  • Modernity
    • Rationality
    • Universalism: one truth for all
    • Reductionism: one factor explains all
    • Systemic change
  • Postmodernism
    • Many perspectives
    • Plural truths
    • Many factors shape life
    • Particularism: specific groups

Postmodernism: no single truth, no single cause, no single meaning; attention to particular groups and their identities.

— Summary to remember

Key takeaways: postmodernism, associated with Nietzsche, Lyotard, Foucault and Derrida, rejects modernity's rationality, universalism and reductionism. It holds that truth is plural, texts need deconstruction, particular groups matter more than universal theories, and it is linked with identity politics. Critics such as Alan Kirby say its moment has passed.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Environmentalism: shallow and deep ecology and India's ecological movements

Two views of ecology

  • Shallow ecology
    • Anthropocentric: humans at the centre
    • Nature has instrumental value: useful to people
    • Technological fixes such as renewable energy
    • Reduce, reuse, recycle
    • Standard of living should keep rising
  • Deep ecology
    • Biocentric equality: humans one species among millions
    • All life has intrinsic value
    • Use nature only for vital needs; protect biodiversity
    • Limit population; change economy, technology and politics
    • Quality of life over standard of living

Heywood's three kinds of ecology

  • Social ecology (term coined by Murray Bookchin)
    • Eco-socialism: capitalism is the enemy of ecology (Rudolf Bahro, From Red to Green)
    • Eco-anarchism: authority is the enemy of ecology (Murray Bookchin)
    • Eco-feminism: patriarchy is the enemy of ecology (Carolyn Merchant, The Death of Nature)
  • Modernist ecology
    • Same as shallow ecology
    • Reconciles liberalism with ecology
    • Enlightened anthropocentrism
    • Inter-generational justice; sustainable development
  • Deep ecology
    • A new politics respecting the interconnection of humans, other life and the non-living world
Four movements described in the textbook
MovementWhere and whenWhat happened
Bishnoi (Khejarli) movementKhejarli village, Rajasthan, 18th centuryThe Bishnoi sect, founded by Guru Jambheshwar and named after his 29 principles, protected trees in the Thar desert. When soldiers of the Maharaja of Jodhpur came to fell the trees, Amrita Devi hugged a tree and was killed; 363 people gave their lives. The Maharaja recalled the army, apologised and declared the area protected
Chipko movementAlaknanda valley, then in Uttar Pradesh (now Uttarakhand), 1973'Chipko' means to hug. Villagers, especially women, hugged trees to stop contractors felling them. Organised by Chandi Prasad Bhatt's Dasholi Gram Swarajya Mandal and joined by Sundarlal Bahuguna; it spread across the Himalaya and led to a ban on felling in 1980. The textbook calls it a fusion of feminism, environmentalism and Gandhism
Appiko movementUttara Kannada district, Karnataka, Western Ghats'Appiko' means to embrace in Kannada; inspired by Chipko. Aims: conserve the remaining forests, reforest bare land, and spread ideas of rational use. According to the textbook, forest cover in the district fell from 81 per cent in 1950 to 24 per cent in 1980
Save Silent Valley movementPalakkad district, Kerala, 1970s-1980sProtest by the Kerala Sastra Sahitya Parishad and others against a hydro-electric project on the Kunthipuzha river that threatened the valley's evergreen forest and wildlife such as the lion-tailed macaque. The project was dropped, the valley became a national park in 1984 and later the core of the Nilgiri Biosphere Reserve

Shallow ecology asks how nature can serve people better; deep ecology asks why people think nature exists only to serve them.

— Key contrast, in our own words

Key takeaways: shallow (modernist) ecology keeps humans at the centre and seeks technological and sustainable solutions; deep ecology, from Arne Naess, asserts biocentric equality and deep change. Heywood adds social ecology with its eco-socialist, eco-anarchist and eco-feminist trends. India's Bishnoi, Chipko, Appiko and Silent Valley movements show non-violent popular action to protect nature.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery