- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Development and underdevelopment: meaning, approaches and growth versus development
Explain what economic development means under the traditional and the welfare-oriented approaches, list the features of an underdeveloped economy and distinguish economic growth from economic development.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the traditional and the new welfare-oriented approaches to development.
- Define underdevelopment and list the features of an underdeveloped country (UDC).
- State at least five differences between economic growth and economic development.
Chapter 11 of the Tamil Nadu textbook opens the last part of the Class 12 course: why some countries are rich and others poor, and how a country can plan its way out of poverty. The book describes development as structural change towards betterment. Before the Second World War, economists paid little attention to the poor countries of the world, many of which were colonies of England and other European powers. After the war, as these countries became independent, economists began building theories of how such countries could grow and develop.
Two approaches to development
1. The traditional approach sees development purely in economic terms. A country develops when its GNP rises and, along the way, the share of agriculture in output and employment falls while the shares of manufacturing and services rise. Industrialisation is the key. The approach assumed that a rise in GNP per capita would trickle down to the poorest people automatically.
2. The new welfare-oriented approach arose in the 1970s, when it became clear that growth alone had not removed poverty in many countries. Development was redefined as the reduction of poverty, inequality and unemployment in a growing economy. The slogan of this phase was 'Redistribution with Growth'. The textbook cites Michael P. Todaro, who described development as a multidimensional process: it involves changes in social structures, popular attitudes and national institutions, together with faster growth, less inequality and the end of absolute poverty (paraphrased).
Two approaches to economic development
-
Traditional approach
- Development measured in economic terms only
- Rising GNP and GNP per capita
- Shift from agriculture to industry and services
- Benefits assumed to trickle down
-
New welfare-oriented approach (1970s)
- Reduction of poverty, inequality and unemployment
- Slogan: Redistribution with Growth
- Multidimensional: social, attitudinal, institutional change
- Todaro's view of development
Underdevelopment and its features
Underdevelopment is the state of an economy in which the living standards of most people are extremely low because per capita income is very low, which in turn comes from low productivity and a fast-growing population. The book notes that 'underdeveloped' is a relative term. The World Bank, in its World Development Report, groups countries into low-income, middle-income and high-income countries by their Gross National Income (GNI) per capita; the textbook prints the dollar limits of each group, which the World Bank revises every year.
- Predominance of the primary sector (agriculture).
- Low per capita income and widespread poverty.
- Wide inequality in the distribution of income and wealth.
- Over-population.
- Low rate of capital formation.
- High rate of unemployment.
- Technological backwardness.
- Dualism: a modern sector existing side by side with a backward one.
Economic growth versus economic development
The two words are often used as if they meant the same thing, but the book separates them on four grounds: the state of development (which countries each word is usually applied to), the nature of change, the scope of change and the extent of change.
| Basis | Economic growth | Economic development |
|---|---|---|
| Usually discussed for | Developed countries | Underdeveloped countries (UDCs) |
| Nature of change | Gradual and steady, in the long run | Discontinuous and spontaneous |
| Scope | More output | More output plus changes in its composition, efficiency (output per unit of input) and allocation of resources |
| Aspects covered | Quantitative: rise in per capita income | Quantitative and qualitative |
| Breadth | Narrow concept | Wider concept |
Development = Growth + Change. Growth is more output; development is more output together with structural change and less poverty, inequality and unemployment.
Worked example 1: growth without development
Made-up data: in Country P, per capita income rises from ₹50,000 to ₹60,000 over ten years. Over the same years the share of the poorest half of the people in total income falls, unemployment rises and the share of agriculture in employment stays unchanged. Step 1, growth? Per capita income rose by 60,000 − 50,000 = ₹10,000, that is (10,000 ÷ 50,000) × 100 = 20 per cent. So there is growth. Step 2, development? Inequality and unemployment rose and the occupational structure did not change. Answer: Country P has growth (a quantitative change) but not development (no qualitative or structural change). This is exactly why the welfare approach rejected the 'trickle down' assumption.
Worked example 2: sorting statements
| Statement | Growth or development? | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Steel output doubles in five years | Growth | More output only |
| Literacy rises and the share of farm workers falls | Development | Qualitative and structural change |
| Output per worker rises because of better technique | Development | Efficiency: output per unit of input |
| Real per capita income rises steadily every year | Growth | Quantitative rise in per capita income |
Key takeaways: the traditional approach equates development with rising GNP and industrialisation; the welfare approach of the 1970s adds the reduction of poverty, inequality and unemployment ('Redistribution with Growth'). Underdevelopment means very low living standards from low per capita income, low productivity and fast population growth. Growth is narrow and quantitative; development is wider, quantitative and qualitative: growth plus change.
Check your understanding
-
1. The slogan 'Redistribution with Growth' belongs to which approach to development?
- The traditional approach
- The industrial approach
- The new welfare-oriented approach
- The trickle-down approach
Show answer
Answer: C. In the 1970s development was redefined as reducing poverty, inequality and unemployment in a growing economy; 'Redistribution with Growth' was the slogan of this new welfare-oriented approach. The traditional approach relied on trickle down instead.
-
2. Which of these is NOT a feature of economic growth as described in the chapter?
- It is usually discussed for developed countries
- It is a wider concept than development
- The change is gradual and steady
- It concerns the quantitative rise in per capita income
Show answer
Answer: B. Growth is the narrow concept; development is the wider one (growth plus change). The other three options are features of growth.
-
3. Which of the following is a feature of an underdeveloped economy?
- Predominance of the primary sector
- A very high rate of capital formation
- Advanced technology in most industries
- Very little unemployment
Show answer
Answer: A. UDCs depend mainly on agriculture (the primary sector) and have low capital formation, technological backwardness and high unemployment, so the other three options describe the opposite of underdevelopment.
-
4. Made-up data: a country's per capita income rises from ₹40,000 to ₹46,000, but poverty and inequality do not fall at all. Which statement is correct?
- There is development but no growth
- There is neither growth nor development
- There is both growth and development
- There is growth of 15 per cent but no development
Show answer
Answer: D. Growth = (46,000 − 40,000) ÷ 40,000 × 100 = 6,000 ÷ 40,000 × 100 = 15 per cent. Since poverty and inequality are unchanged, there is no qualitative change, so this is growth without development.
-
5. According to the chapter, the World Bank classifies countries into low, middle and high income groups on the basis of:
- total population
- Gross National Income per capita
- the share of agriculture in output
- the literacy rate
Show answer
Answer: B. The World Development Report groups countries by GNI per capita. Population, the share of agriculture and literacy are related indicators but are not the basis of this classification.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.