• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Types of planning and NITI Aayog

Compare the eight pairs of planning types in the chapter and describe NITI Aayog: when and how it was formed, its structure, its functions and the seven pillars of governance it is based on.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish the eight pairs of planning types the book describes.
  • Classify a described plan by its type.
  • Explain how NITI Aayog was formed and list its main functions and seven pillars.

Planning differs from country to country in ideology and in how it is carried out. The book's summary puts it simply: planning is totalitarian and highly centralised in socialist countries, democratic and indicative in countries like France. This lesson sorts out the types and then meets India's present planning body, NITI Aayog.

Eight pairs of planning types

Types of planning in the Tamil Nadu textbook
PairFirst typeSecond type
Democratic vs totalitarianDemocratic: people consulted at every step; states and private enterprise consulted; Parliament may accept, reject or modify the planTotalitarian: a single plan; the central authority controls consumption, production, exchange and distribution and is supreme
Centralised vs decentralisedCentralised: one central authority fixes objectives, targets and priorities for every sector, 'planning from above'Decentralised: local bodies formulate, adopt, execute and supervise plans without central interference, 'planning from below'
Direction vs inducementDirection: the central authority plans, directs and orders executionInducement: people are encouraged through monetary and fiscal measures such as subsidies, with less loss of liberty
Indicative vs imperativeIndicative: for mixed economies; practised in France since the Monnet Plan of 1947-50; the state outlines targets and coordinates, the private sector is guided, not forcedImperative: the state is all-powerful and enforces the plan; no consumer sovereignty; the book cites Stalin's saying that plans are instructions
Short, medium and long termShort term: one year, 'annual' or 'controlling' plans (operational); medium term: 3 to 7 years, normally 5 (tactical)Long term: 10 to 30 years, 'perspective plans' (strategic), aimed at structural change
Financial vs physicalFinancial: resources allocated in terms of moneyPhysical: resources allocated in terms of men, materials and machinery
Functional vs structuralFunctional: removes difficulties within the existing economic and social structureStructural: changes the socio-economic framework itself; adopted mostly in underdeveloped countries
Comprehensive vs partialComprehensive: covers the major issues of the whole economyPartial: covers only a few important sectors

Planning by time period

  1. Short term Up to 1 year: annual or controlling plan; operational
  2. Medium term 3 to 7 years, normally 5: tactical
  3. Long term 10 to 30 years: perspective plan; strategic, for structural change

Worked example 1: classifying plans

Description (illustrative)TypeClue
A government gives a tax break to firms that build solar plantsPlanning by inducementFiscal measure, no order
Village councils draw up and run their own water plansDecentralised planningPlanning from below
A plan lists how many engineers, tonnes of cement and machines each project needsPhysical planningMen, materials and machinery
A 20-year plan to shift workers from farming to industryLong-term (perspective) and structural planningOver 10 years; changes the framework
The state announces targets and discusses them with industry and unions, but forces no oneIndicative planningGuides, does not compel

NITI Aayog

NITI Aayog stands for National Institution for Transforming India. It was formed on 1 January 2015 through a Union Cabinet resolution and replaced the Planning Commission, which the government had announced in August 2014 it would wind up. NITI Aayog is a policy think-tank of the Government of India. The Prime Minister is its Chairperson, Union Ministers are ex-officio members, and the Vice-Chairman is its functional head.

  1. Cooperative and competitive federalism: active participation of the States in national policy.
  2. Shared national agenda: a shared vision of development priorities with the States.
  3. Decentralised planning: restructuring planning into a bottom-up model.
  4. Vision and scenario planning: medium and long-term strategic frameworks for India's future.
  5. Network of expertise: bringing outside ideas and experts into government policy.
  6. Harmonisation: coordinating actions across layers of government on cross-cutting issues.
  7. Conflict resolution: a platform for consensus on inter-sectoral, inter-departmental, inter-state and centre-state issues.
  8. Coordinating interface with the world: a nodal point for global expertise and resources.
  9. Internal consultancy: advice to Central and State governments on policies and programmes.
  10. Capacity building: technology upgrading and managerial and technical know-how across government.
  11. Monitoring and evaluation: watching implementation of policies and programmes and evaluating their impact.

Seven pillars of effective governance behind NITI Aayog

  • Pro-people Fulfils the aspirations of society and individuals
  • Pro-activity Anticipates and responds to citizens' needs
  • Participation Involvement of citizens
  • Empowering Women in all aspects
  • Inclusion of all SC, ST, OBC, minorities, the poor, villages and farmers
  • Equality Of opportunity for the youth
  • Transparency Making government visible and responsive

According to the textbook, initiatives such as the Atal Innovation Mission were conceptualised in NITI Aayog, and it set up a development monitoring and evaluation office that collects data on ministries' performance and ranks States by performance to encourage competitive federalism. The book adds that its success can be judged only after a substantial period.

NITI Aayog: National Institution for Transforming India; formed 1 January 2015 by a Union Cabinet resolution; replaced the Planning Commission; a policy think-tank chaired by the Prime Minister, with the Vice-Chairman as functional head.

Worked example 2: matching a task to a function

Illustrative: two States disagree over sharing a river project, and the Centre asks NITI Aayog to bring them to an agreement. Step 1: the issue is between States and involves the Centre. Step 2: the function that provides a platform for consensus on inter-state and centre-state issues is conflict resolution. Answer: conflict resolution. If instead a State asked for advice on designing a health programme, that would be internal consultancy.

Key takeaways: planning may be democratic or totalitarian, centralised or decentralised, by direction or inducement, indicative (France) or imperative, short, medium or long term, financial or physical, functional or structural, comprehensive or partial. NITI Aayog, formed on 1 January 2015 by Cabinet resolution, replaced the Planning Commission as a policy think-tank chaired by the Prime Minister, built on bottom-up planning and cooperative federalism.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which country is the textbook's example of indicative planning?

    1. Russia
    2. France
    3. China
    4. Germany
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Indicative planning, where the state guides rather than compels the private sector, has been practised in France since the Monnet Plan of 1947-50. Russia and China are given as examples of imperative planning.

  2. 2. A long-term plan is also called a:

    1. controlling plan
    2. annual plan
    3. tactical plan
    4. perspective plan
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Long-term plans of 10 to 30 years are perspective plans aimed at structural change. Controlling and annual plans are short-term; tactical refers to medium-term planning.

  3. 3. A government wants more fertiliser produced and gives firms a subsidy instead of ordering them. This is:

    1. planning by inducement
    2. planning by direction
    3. imperative planning
    4. totalitarian planning
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Encouraging firms through monetary and fiscal measures such as subsidies is planning by inducement. Direction, imperative and totalitarian planning all rely on orders from the central authority.

  4. 4. NITI Aayog was formed through:

    1. a Presidential ordinance
    2. an Act of Parliament
    3. a Union Cabinet resolution
    4. an amendment to the Constitution
    Show answer

    Answer: C. NITI Aayog was set up on 1 January 2015 by a resolution of the Union Cabinet; it is not a statutory or constitutional body.

  5. 5. Restructuring planning into a bottom-up model is the NITI Aayog function called:

    1. harmonisation
    2. capacity building
    3. monitoring and evaluation
    4. decentralised planning
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Decentralised planning is the function of rebuilding the planning process from the bottom up, unlike the earlier top-down approach. The other options are separate functions.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery