• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Economic planning: meaning, evolution in India and the case for and against

Define economic planning, trace how planning began in the world and in India, and weigh the arguments for planning in underdeveloped countries against the arguments against it.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define planning and give the definitions of Robbins and Dalton in your own words.
  • Arrange the early Indian plans in order and state when the Planning Commission and the First Five Year Plan began.
  • Explain four arguments for planning and four arguments against it.

The second part of the chapter turns from development to planning. Planning is a technique, a means to an end: the end is a set of pre-decided aims laid down by a central planning authority. Those aims may be economic, social, political or even military. The book quotes two classic definitions, given here in our words: Robbins saw planning as collective control or suppression of private production and exchange; Dalton saw it, in the widest sense, as deliberate direction of economic activity towards chosen ends by those in charge of large resources.

How planning spread

The textbook traces modern planning to ideas rooted in Marxist socialism. The Soviet Union began economic planning in 1928, which helped it become an industrial power. The Great Depression of the 1930s strengthened the case for planning, and the Second World War required careful planning of resources for the war and the post-war economy.

Evolution of planning in India

Early plans for India
YearPlan or stepMain idea
1934Sir M. Visvesvaraya, 'Planned Economy for India'First attempt: a ten-year plan
1938National Planning Committee set up by the Congress, chaired by Jawaharlal NehruWork interrupted by political changes and the Second World War
1944Bombay Plan by eight leading industrialists of BombayA fifteen-year investment plan
1944Gandhian Plan by S. N. AgarwalFocus on agriculture and the rural economy
1945People's Plan by M. N. RoyMechanisation of agriculture; production and distribution by the state
1950Sarvodaya Plan by J. P. NarayanInspired by the Gandhian Plan and Vinoba Bhave; agriculture plus small and cottage industries

After independence, the Industrial Policy declaration of 1948 suggested a national planning body and a mixed economy. The Constitution came into force on 26 January 1950; the Planning Commission was set up on 15 March 1950 with Jawaharlal Nehru as its first Chairman; and the plan era began on 1 April 1951 with the First Five Year Plan (1951-56).

Road to the First Five Year Plan

  1. 1934 Visvesvaraya plan
  2. 1938 National Planning Committee
  3. 1944-45 Bombay, Gandhian and People's Plans
  4. 1948 Industrial Policy
  5. 1950 Sarvodaya Plan; Planning Commission (15 March)
  6. 1951 First Five Year Plan begins (1 April)

The case for planning

  1. To strengthen the market mechanism: in underdeveloped countries markets work imperfectly; much of the economy is non-monetised and product, factor, money and capital markets are poorly organised.
  2. To remove unemployment: capital is scarce and labour abundant, so open and disguised unemployment need a planned answer.
  3. To achieve balanced development: agriculture and industry depend on each other (agriculture releases labour and supplies raw materials); infrastructure such as canals, roads, railways and power needs huge investment with a long gestation period and low returns, which only the state can supply; and money and capital markets must be built up.
  4. To remove poverty and inequality: planning is presented as the path for raising national and per capita income and employment. The book quotes Arthur Lewis on planning being even more necessary in backward countries.

The case against planning

  1. Loss of freedom: freedom of consumption, of occupation, to produce and to fix prices is lost when a central authority decides. Friedrich Hayek argued in 'The Road to Serfdom' that central planning ends personal freedom and leads to stagnation. The book balances this: private freedom can also be misused, putting profit above welfare.
  2. Elimination of initiative: without private ownership and profit, and with equal reward regardless of effort, nobody takes risks; bureaucracy and red tape cause delay. The book notes that even Russia and China now give incentives to private enterprise.
  3. High cost of management: an army of staff is needed for data and administration; the book quotes Lewis's remark that the better we try to plan, the more planners we need. Poor data and faulty estimates waste resources.
  4. Difficulty in advance calculations: a planned economy has no automatic price mechanism to balance demand and supply, and precise advance calculation is impossible. The book adds that surpluses and shortages also occur in market economies, including the US.

The textbook's conclusion: the real question is not plan or no plan, but which type of plan. The right mix of market mechanism and state action promises faster growth with stability and social justice.

Worked example 1: arranging plans in order

Put these in chronological order: People's Plan, Visvesvaraya's plan, Sarvodaya Plan, National Planning Committee. Step 1, attach years: People's Plan 1945; Visvesvaraya 1934; Sarvodaya 1950; National Planning Committee 1938. Step 2, sort: 1934 → 1938 → 1945 → 1950. Answer: Visvesvaraya's plan, National Planning Committee, People's Plan, Sarvodaya Plan.

Worked example 2: counting plan years

The First Five Year Plan ran from 1 April 1951. Step 1: five years from 1 April 1951 ends on 31 March 1956, written 1951-56. Step 2: if each later plan also lasted five years with no break, the Second Plan would cover 1956-61 and the Third 1961-66. Check: 1951 + 5 = 1956 and 1956 + 5 = 1961. (The book does not list the later plans; this is only practice in reading plan periods.)

Key takeaways: planning is a means to pre-decided ends set by a central authority. It began in the USSR in 1928. India's early plans ran from Visvesvaraya (1934) to the Sarvodaya Plan (1950); the Planning Commission was set up on 15 March 1950 and the First Plan began on 1 April 1951. Planning is argued for to fix weak markets, unemployment, unbalanced development and poverty, and against for loss of freedom, loss of initiative, high cost and impossible calculations.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which plan focused on agriculture and the rural economy?

    1. Bombay Plan
    2. People's Plan
    3. Visvesvaraya's plan
    4. Gandhian Plan
    Show answer

    Answer: D. S. N. Agarwal's Gandhian Plan (1944) focused on agriculture and the rural economy. The Bombay Plan was an industrialists' investment plan, the People's Plan stressed state-run mechanised agriculture and Visvesvaraya's was a ten-year plan.

  2. 2. The Sarvodaya Plan was advocated by:

    1. J. P. Narayan
    2. M. N. Roy
    3. S. N. Agarwal
    4. Jawaharlal Nehru
    Show answer

    Answer: A. J. P. Narayan put forward the Sarvodaya Plan in 1950, inspired by the Gandhian Plan and Vinoba Bhave. M. N. Roy gave the People's Plan and S. N. Agarwal the Gandhian Plan.

  3. 3. Who argued in 'The Road to Serfdom' that central planning leads to loss of personal freedom?

    1. Arthur Lewis
    2. Ragnar Nurkse
    3. Friedrich Hayek
    4. Hugh Dalton
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Friedrich Hayek wrote 'The Road to Serfdom'. Lewis argued for planning in backward countries, Nurkse wrote on the vicious circle and Dalton gave a definition of planning.

  4. 4. Which of these is an argument FOR planning in underdeveloped countries?

    1. It removes the freedom to choose an occupation
    2. Infrastructure needs huge, long-gestation investment that only the state can provide
    3. It needs an army of planners
    4. It makes advance calculation of demand impossible
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The need for infrastructure with a long gestation period and low return is part of the case for balanced development through planning. The other three are arguments against planning.

  5. 5. Arrange in order: (i) Planning Commission set up, (ii) Constitution comes into force, (iii) First Five Year Plan begins, (iv) Industrial Policy declaration.

    1. (iv), (ii), (i), (iii)
    2. (ii), (iv), (i), (iii)
    3. (iv), (i), (ii), (iii)
    4. (i), (ii), (iv), (iii)
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Industrial Policy 1948; Constitution 26 January 1950; Planning Commission 15 March 1950; First Plan 1 April 1951. So the order is (iv), (ii), (i), (iii).

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Types of planning and NITI Aayog

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery