- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Non-economic factors and the vicious circle of poverty
Explain the nine non-economic determinants of development, trace the vicious circle of poverty on its supply and demand sides, and show how it can be broken through saving and balanced growth.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List and explain the non-economic factors that affect development, with the thinkers the book links to them.
- Draw the vicious circle of poverty on the supply side and on the demand side.
- Explain how a marginal rate of saving above the average rate, and Nurkse's balanced growth, break the circle.
Money and machines are not the whole story. The book quotes Ragnar Nurkse's view that development has much to do with human endowments, social attitudes, political conditions and historical accidents, and that capital is necessary but not sufficient for progress (paraphrased). This lesson covers those non-economic factors and then the trap that keeps poor countries poor.
Non-economic factors
| Factor | Main idea in the chapter |
|---|---|
| 1. Human resources | Health, education and skills make people more productive, so labour is called human capital. Human development and growth feed each other in a circle; the book cites Japan and China as examples of skilled labour forces |
| 2. Technical know-how | Advancing science and technology raise productivity in all sectors; Schumpeter traced development to innovation |
| 3. Political freedom | Dadabhai Naoroji, in 'Poverty and Un-British Rule in India', argued that the drain of wealth under British rule was a major cause of India's growing poverty |
| 4. Social organisation | People join development only if they expect its fruits to be shared fairly; when a few groups capture the gains, the book calls it crony capitalism |
| 5. Corruption-free administration | Corruption and tax evasion let crony capitalists exploit national resources and slow progress |
| 6. Desire for development | If people accept poverty as fate, there is little scope for development |
| 7. Moral, ethical and social values | According to Douglass C. North, these decide how efficient markets are; without honesty markets cannot work |
| 8. Casino capitalism | According to Thomas Piketty (as the book puts it), heavy spending of income and time on entertainment, liquor and illegal activities makes productive activity suffer |
| 9. Patrimonial capitalism | Also from Piketty in the book: when assets simply pass from parents to children, the heirs may not work hard, so productivity is low |
The vicious circle of poverty
A vicious circle of poverty is a set of circular relationships that keep a less developed country at a low level of development. Nurkse's illustration runs roughly like this: a poor person cannot eat enough, so his health is weak, so his capacity to work is low, so he stays poor and cannot eat enough. Applied to a whole country, the idea is summed up in Nurkse's famous line, 'a country is poor because it is poor'. The circle works on both the supply side and the demand side.
Supply side of the vicious circle
- Low real income
- Low saving
- Low investment
- Deficiency of capital
- Low productivity
Then back to step 1: Low real income
Demand side of the vicious circle
- Low real income
- Low demand
- Low inducement to invest
- Deficiency of capital
- Low productivity
Then back to step 1: Low real income
Breaking the circle
Supply side: the circle is fed by low saving and investment. The book says capital formation can be raised without cutting present consumption if the marginal rate of saving is greater than the average rate of saving, that is, if people save a larger share of each extra rupee of income than they save on average.
Demand side: Nurkse proposed balanced growth: invest in many industries at the same time. Workers in each industry then become buyers of the others' products, so the industries create demand for one another, and the market is no longer too small to justify investment.
Supply side: raise saving by keeping the marginal rate of saving above the average rate. Demand side: Nurkse's balanced growth, simultaneous investment in many industries that create demand for one another.
Worked example 1: saving more without consuming less
Made-up data: a country's income is ₹1,000 crore and it saves ₹100 crore, so the average rate of saving is 100 ÷ 1,000 = 10 per cent and consumption is ₹900 crore. Next year income rises to ₹1,200 crore and the country saves 30 per cent of the extra income. Step 1: extra income = 1,200 − 1,000 = ₹200 crore. Step 2: extra saving = 30% of 200 = ₹60 crore, so total saving = 100 + 60 = ₹160 crore. Step 3: consumption = 1,200 − 160 = ₹1,040 crore, higher than ₹900 crore. Step 4: new average rate of saving = 160 ÷ 1,200 ≈ 13.3 per cent. Answer: because the marginal rate (30%) exceeds the average rate (10%), the saving rate climbs while consumption still rises.
Worked example 2: why one factory alone may fail
Illustrative: suppose a shoe factory opens in a poor town where incomes are low. Its workers buy only a few pairs, and other people cannot afford new shoes, so the factory cannot sell its output and the investment fails (the demand-side circle). Now suppose a shoe factory, a textile mill, a food-processing unit and a bicycle unit open together. Workers of each unit spend their wages on the products of the others. Answer: demand is created all round, which is Nurkse's balanced growth breaking the demand side of the circle.
Key takeaways: the nine non-economic factors are human resources, technical know-how, political freedom, social organisation, corruption-free administration, desire for development, moral and social values, and the dangers of casino and patrimonial capitalism. The vicious circle of poverty runs from low income to low saving (supply) or low demand (demand), to low investment, too little capital, low productivity and back to low income. A marginal saving rate above the average rate and balanced growth can break it.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the following is a non-economic determinant of development?
- Capital formation
- Human resources
- Foreign trade
- Marketable surplus
Show answer
Answer: B. The book lists human resources first among the non-economic factors. Capital formation, foreign trade and marketable surplus are economic factors.
-
2. The supply side of the vicious circle of poverty runs:
- low income → low saving → low investment → deficiency of capital → low productivity → low income
- low income → high saving → high investment → low productivity
- low demand → high income → low saving → low capital
- high productivity → low income → high demand → high saving
Show answer
Answer: A. On the supply side low real income means low saving, hence low investment and too little capital, so productivity and income stay low. The other chains contain links that contradict the circle.
-
3. Made-up data: income rises from ₹500 crore to ₹600 crore. Saving was ₹50 crore and 25 per cent of the extra income is saved. The new average rate of saving is about:
- 10 per cent
- 25 per cent
- 15 per cent
- 12.5 per cent
Show answer
Answer: D. Extra income = 100 crore; extra saving = 25% of 100 = 25 crore; total saving = 50 + 25 = 75 crore. Average rate = 75 ÷ 600 = 0.125 = 12.5 per cent, up from 50 ÷ 500 = 10 per cent because the marginal rate (25%) exceeds the average rate.
-
4. To break the vicious circle on the demand side, Nurkse suggested:
- cutting consumption sharply
- investing in a single leading industry
- balanced growth through simultaneous investment in many industries
- closing the economy to foreign trade
Show answer
Answer: C. Balanced growth means investing in many industries at once so that their workers buy one another's products and create mutual demand. A single industry would face the small-market problem.
-
5. The book links the 'drain of wealth' explanation of India's poverty under British rule to:
- Thomas Piketty
- Joseph Schumpeter
- Douglass C. North
- Dadabhai Naoroji
Show answer
Answer: D. Under political freedom, the book cites Dadabhai Naoroji's 'Poverty and Un-British Rule in India'. Piketty is linked to casino and patrimonial capitalism, Schumpeter to innovation and North to moral values and markets.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.