Two approaches to economic development
-
Traditional approach
- Development measured in economic terms only
- Rising GNP and GNP per capita
- Shift from agriculture to industry and services
- Benefits assumed to trickle down
-
New welfare-oriented approach (1970s)
- Reduction of poverty, inequality and unemployment
- Slogan: Redistribution with Growth
- Multidimensional: social, attitudinal, institutional change
- Todaro's view of development
| Basis | Economic growth | Economic development |
|---|---|---|
| Usually discussed for | Developed countries | Underdeveloped countries (UDCs) |
| Nature of change | Gradual and steady, in the long run | Discontinuous and spontaneous |
| Scope | More output | More output plus changes in its composition, efficiency (output per unit of input) and allocation of resources |
| Aspects covered | Quantitative: rise in per capita income | Quantitative and qualitative |
| Breadth | Narrow concept | Wider concept |
Development = Growth + Change. Growth is more output; development is more output together with structural change and less poverty, inequality and unemployment.
| Statement | Growth or development? | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Steel output doubles in five years | Growth | More output only |
| Literacy rises and the share of farm workers falls | Development | Qualitative and structural change |
| Output per worker rises because of better technique | Development | Efficiency: output per unit of input |
| Real per capita income rises steadily every year | Growth | Quantitative rise in per capita income |
Key takeaways: the traditional approach equates development with rising GNP and industrialisation; the welfare approach of the 1970s adds the reduction of poverty, inequality and unemployment ('Redistribution with Growth'). Underdevelopment means very low living standards from low per capita income, low productivity and fast population growth. Growth is narrow and quantitative; development is wider, quantitative and qualitative: growth plus change.