Revision notes

Chapter 11 Economics of Development and Planning: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Development and underdevelopment: meaning, approaches and growth versus development

Two approaches to economic development

  • Traditional approach
    • Development measured in economic terms only
    • Rising GNP and GNP per capita
    • Shift from agriculture to industry and services
    • Benefits assumed to trickle down
  • New welfare-oriented approach (1970s)
    • Reduction of poverty, inequality and unemployment
    • Slogan: Redistribution with Growth
    • Multidimensional: social, attitudinal, institutional change
    • Todaro's view of development
Growth and development compared (as set out in the Tamil Nadu textbook)
BasisEconomic growthEconomic development
Usually discussed forDeveloped countriesUnderdeveloped countries (UDCs)
Nature of changeGradual and steady, in the long runDiscontinuous and spontaneous
ScopeMore outputMore output plus changes in its composition, efficiency (output per unit of input) and allocation of resources
Aspects coveredQuantitative: rise in per capita incomeQuantitative and qualitative
BreadthNarrow conceptWider concept

Development = Growth + Change. Growth is more output; development is more output together with structural change and less poverty, inequality and unemployment.

StatementGrowth or development?Reason
Steel output doubles in five yearsGrowthMore output only
Literacy rises and the share of farm workers fallsDevelopmentQualitative and structural change
Output per worker rises because of better techniqueDevelopmentEfficiency: output per unit of input
Real per capita income rises steadily every yearGrowthQuantitative rise in per capita income

Key takeaways: the traditional approach equates development with rising GNP and industrialisation; the welfare approach of the 1970s adds the reduction of poverty, inequality and unemployment ('Redistribution with Growth'). Underdevelopment means very low living standards from low per capita income, low productivity and fast population growth. Growth is narrow and quantitative; development is wider, quantitative and qualitative: growth plus change.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Measuring development and its economic determinants

GNP = value of final output produced in the country + income earned by its citizens abroad − income earned by non-residents in the country. Per capita income = national income ÷ population.

Economic factors determining development
FactorWhat it meansHow it helps development
1. Natural resourcesLand, minerals, forests, water available to a countryAbundance helps; but Japan, poor in resources, imports them and uses technology, while India with larger resources remains poor
2. Capital formationNet addition to the stock of capital, tangible (plant, machinery) or intangible (health, education, research)Raises labour productivity, output and income; brings advanced techniques; the main key to growth
3. Size of the marketHow much can be soldA large market stimulates production and employment; developed countries widen markets abroad through the WTO
4. Structural changeChange in the occupational structure across primary, secondary and tertiary sectorsAn economy that stays mainly agricultural tends to remain backward
5. Financial systemAn efficient, organised banking system and money marketMakes capital easily available
6. Marketable surplusFarm output above the farm family's own consumption, sold in the marketRaises purchasing power, employment and output in other sectors
7. Foreign tradeBalance of trade and terms of tradeA favourable balance gives large forex reserves and a stable exchange rate
8. Economic systemFree market (laissez faire) or controlled economyFree-market countries often grow faster, though the book adds this is not true of every country

Economic determinants of development

  • Resources and capital
    • Natural resources
    • Capital formation
  • Markets
    • Size of the market
    • Marketable surplus
    • Foreign trade
  • Structure and institutions
    • Structural change
    • Financial system
    • Economic system
The grouping is only a memory aid; the book lists the eight factors in the order of the table.

Key takeaways: development is measured by GNP, GNP per capita, welfare and social indicators; per capita real income must grow faster than population. The economic determinants are natural resources, capital formation, size of the market, structural change, financial system, marketable surplus, foreign trade and the economic system. Capital formation is called the main key to growth.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Non-economic factors and the vicious circle of poverty

Non-economic determinants of development (book's order)
FactorMain idea in the chapter
1. Human resourcesHealth, education and skills make people more productive, so labour is called human capital. Human development and growth feed each other in a circle; the book cites Japan and China as examples of skilled labour forces
2. Technical know-howAdvancing science and technology raise productivity in all sectors; Schumpeter traced development to innovation
3. Political freedomDadabhai Naoroji, in 'Poverty and Un-British Rule in India', argued that the drain of wealth under British rule was a major cause of India's growing poverty
4. Social organisationPeople join development only if they expect its fruits to be shared fairly; when a few groups capture the gains, the book calls it crony capitalism
5. Corruption-free administrationCorruption and tax evasion let crony capitalists exploit national resources and slow progress
6. Desire for developmentIf people accept poverty as fate, there is little scope for development
7. Moral, ethical and social valuesAccording to Douglass C. North, these decide how efficient markets are; without honesty markets cannot work
8. Casino capitalismAccording to Thomas Piketty (as the book puts it), heavy spending of income and time on entertainment, liquor and illegal activities makes productive activity suffer
9. Patrimonial capitalismAlso from Piketty in the book: when assets simply pass from parents to children, the heirs may not work hard, so productivity is low

Supply side of the vicious circle

  1. Low real income
  2. Low saving
  3. Low investment
  4. Deficiency of capital
  5. Low productivity

Then back to step 1: Low real income

Low productivity brings the economy back to low income, and the circle repeats.

Demand side of the vicious circle

  1. Low real income
  2. Low demand
  3. Low inducement to invest
  4. Deficiency of capital
  5. Low productivity

Then back to step 1: Low real income

Both circles meet at the same point: too little capital.

Supply side: raise saving by keeping the marginal rate of saving above the average rate. Demand side: Nurkse's balanced growth, simultaneous investment in many industries that create demand for one another.

Key takeaways: the nine non-economic factors are human resources, technical know-how, political freedom, social organisation, corruption-free administration, desire for development, moral and social values, and the dangers of casino and patrimonial capitalism. The vicious circle of poverty runs from low income to low saving (supply) or low demand (demand), to low investment, too little capital, low productivity and back to low income. A marginal saving rate above the average rate and balanced growth can break it.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Economic planning: meaning, evolution in India and the case for and against

Early plans for India
YearPlan or stepMain idea
1934Sir M. Visvesvaraya, 'Planned Economy for India'First attempt: a ten-year plan
1938National Planning Committee set up by the Congress, chaired by Jawaharlal NehruWork interrupted by political changes and the Second World War
1944Bombay Plan by eight leading industrialists of BombayA fifteen-year investment plan
1944Gandhian Plan by S. N. AgarwalFocus on agriculture and the rural economy
1945People's Plan by M. N. RoyMechanisation of agriculture; production and distribution by the state
1950Sarvodaya Plan by J. P. NarayanInspired by the Gandhian Plan and Vinoba Bhave; agriculture plus small and cottage industries

Road to the First Five Year Plan

  1. 1934 Visvesvaraya plan
  2. 1938 National Planning Committee
  3. 1944-45 Bombay, Gandhian and People's Plans
  4. 1948 Industrial Policy
  5. 1950 Sarvodaya Plan; Planning Commission (15 March)
  6. 1951 First Five Year Plan begins (1 April)

The textbook's conclusion: the real question is not plan or no plan, but which type of plan. The right mix of market mechanism and state action promises faster growth with stability and social justice.

Key takeaways: planning is a means to pre-decided ends set by a central authority. It began in the USSR in 1928. India's early plans ran from Visvesvaraya (1934) to the Sarvodaya Plan (1950); the Planning Commission was set up on 15 March 1950 and the First Plan began on 1 April 1951. Planning is argued for to fix weak markets, unemployment, unbalanced development and poverty, and against for loss of freedom, loss of initiative, high cost and impossible calculations.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Types of planning and NITI Aayog

Types of planning in the Tamil Nadu textbook
PairFirst typeSecond type
Democratic vs totalitarianDemocratic: people consulted at every step; states and private enterprise consulted; Parliament may accept, reject or modify the planTotalitarian: a single plan; the central authority controls consumption, production, exchange and distribution and is supreme
Centralised vs decentralisedCentralised: one central authority fixes objectives, targets and priorities for every sector, 'planning from above'Decentralised: local bodies formulate, adopt, execute and supervise plans without central interference, 'planning from below'
Direction vs inducementDirection: the central authority plans, directs and orders executionInducement: people are encouraged through monetary and fiscal measures such as subsidies, with less loss of liberty
Indicative vs imperativeIndicative: for mixed economies; practised in France since the Monnet Plan of 1947-50; the state outlines targets and coordinates, the private sector is guided, not forcedImperative: the state is all-powerful and enforces the plan; no consumer sovereignty; the book cites Stalin's saying that plans are instructions
Short, medium and long termShort term: one year, 'annual' or 'controlling' plans (operational); medium term: 3 to 7 years, normally 5 (tactical)Long term: 10 to 30 years, 'perspective plans' (strategic), aimed at structural change
Financial vs physicalFinancial: resources allocated in terms of moneyPhysical: resources allocated in terms of men, materials and machinery
Functional vs structuralFunctional: removes difficulties within the existing economic and social structureStructural: changes the socio-economic framework itself; adopted mostly in underdeveloped countries
Comprehensive vs partialComprehensive: covers the major issues of the whole economyPartial: covers only a few important sectors

Planning by time period

  1. Short term Up to 1 year: annual or controlling plan; operational
  2. Medium term 3 to 7 years, normally 5: tactical
  3. Long term 10 to 30 years: perspective plan; strategic, for structural change
Description (illustrative)TypeClue
A government gives a tax break to firms that build solar plantsPlanning by inducementFiscal measure, no order
Village councils draw up and run their own water plansDecentralised planningPlanning from below
A plan lists how many engineers, tonnes of cement and machines each project needsPhysical planningMen, materials and machinery
A 20-year plan to shift workers from farming to industryLong-term (perspective) and structural planningOver 10 years; changes the framework
The state announces targets and discusses them with industry and unions, but forces no oneIndicative planningGuides, does not compel

Seven pillars of effective governance behind NITI Aayog

  • Pro-people Fulfils the aspirations of society and individuals
  • Pro-activity Anticipates and responds to citizens' needs
  • Participation Involvement of citizens
  • Empowering Women in all aspects
  • Inclusion of all SC, ST, OBC, minorities, the poor, villages and farmers
  • Equality Of opportunity for the youth
  • Transparency Making government visible and responsive

NITI Aayog: National Institution for Transforming India; formed 1 January 2015 by a Union Cabinet resolution; replaced the Planning Commission; a policy think-tank chaired by the Prime Minister, with the Vice-Chairman as functional head.

Key takeaways: planning may be democratic or totalitarian, centralised or decentralised, by direction or inducement, indicative (France) or imperative, short, medium or long term, financial or physical, functional or structural, comprehensive or partial. NITI Aayog, formed on 1 January 2015 by Cabinet resolution, replaced the Planning Commission as a policy think-tank chaired by the Prime Minister, built on bottom-up planning and cooperative federalism.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery