• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Direct and indirect taxes, and the Goods and Services Tax

Distinguish direct from indirect taxes, weigh their merits and demerits, and explain how GST works through CGST, SGST and IGST as a destination-based tax without cascading.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define direct and indirect taxes and compare them on impact, incidence, nature and shifting.
  • List the merits and demerits of each.
  • Explain progressive, proportional and regressive taxes with numbers.
  • Explain GST, its components and why it removes the cascading effect.

Who actually bears a tax? Income tax is paid by the person who earns; the tax in the price of a soap is paid by the shopkeeper to the government but carried by the buyer. This difference between the impact (who pays the government) and the incidence (who finally bears it) separates direct from indirect taxes.

Direct taxes

A direct tax is levied on a person's income or wealth and paid directly to the government; its burden cannot be shifted, so impact and incidence fall on the same person. It is usually progressive, taking more from the rich. In India, direct tax policy is handled by the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) under the Ministry of Finance. Example: income tax.

Direct taxes
MeritsDemerits
Equity: progressive ratesUnpopular and less flexible
Certainty: the payer knows how much and whenMay discourage effort to earn more
Elasticity: revenue rises automatically with incomeInconvenient: accounts, returns, lump-sum payment
Economy: low cost of collectionEncourages evasion and black money

Indirect taxes

An indirect tax is levied on goods and services and reaches the government indirectly: the seller pays it but shifts the burden to the buyer through the price. It falls on rich and poor alike. Examples the textbook gives from before GST: excise duty (on manufacture), sales tax, customs duty (on imports), entertainment tax and service tax.

Indirect taxes
MeritsDemerits
Wide coverage: everyone who buys paysHigher cost of collection (the textbook's view)
Equitable when luxuries are taxed moreLess elastic, since rates are generally proportional
Traders collect it, acting as honorary collectorsRegressive: the same tax takes a larger share of a poor person's income
Checks harmful consumption ('sin taxes' on tobacco and liquor)Uncertain yield: higher tax cuts demand (Dalton: here 2 + 2 may be 3)
Convenient: paid in small amounts with the priceNo civic consciousness: the tax is hidden in the price
Comparison chart
BasisDirect taxIndirect tax
Levied onIncome or wealthPurchase, sale or manufacture of goods and services
NatureProgressiveRegressive
Impact and incidenceOn the same personOn different persons
ShiftingCannot be shiftedCan be shifted
EvasionPossibleHardly possible, since it is in the price
InflationHelps control itPushes prices up

Worked example 1: progressive, proportional, regressive (made-up incomes)

Two people, A earning ₹2,00,000 and B earning ₹10,00,000 a year. Proportional tax at 10%: A pays ₹20,000 and B ₹1,00,000; both pay 10%. Progressive tax at 5% on A and 20% on B: A pays ₹10,000 and B ₹2,00,000; the rate rises with income. A flat indirect tax: each buys the same goods and pays ₹6,000 tax. As a share of income, A pays 6,000 ÷ 2,00,000 × 100 = 3% and B 6,000 ÷ 10,00,000 × 100 = 0.6%. The poorer person bears a higher share, which is why indirect taxes are called regressive.

Goods and Services Tax (GST)

GST is an indirect tax on the supply of goods and services that replaced many earlier indirect taxes with one tax for the whole country. The GST Acts were passed by Parliament in March 2017 and GST came into effect on 1 July 2017. It is a comprehensive, multi-stage, destination-based tax levied on value addition at every stage, with credit for tax already paid on inputs.

Components of GST
ComponentCollected byOn
CGSTCentral GovernmentSales within a state (intra-state)
SGSTState GovernmentSales within a state, alongside CGST
IGSTCentral Government, then shared by destinationSales from one state to another (inter-state)

Destination based: if goods made in Tamil Nadu are sold to a final consumer in Karnataka, the state share of the tax goes to Karnataka, where consumption takes place. The textbook contrasts three taxes: old sales tax was multipoint with cascading; VAT was multipoint without cascading; GST unifies the system without cascading. GST is also technology-driven: registration, returns and refunds are handled online.

Worked example 2: cascading vs input credit (made-up 10% rate)

StageSale price before taxOld tax on full price (cascading)Value addedGST on value added
Manufacturer₹1,000₹100₹1,000₹100
Wholesaler (adds ₹200)₹1,300 (1,000 + 100 tax + 200)₹130₹200₹20
Retailer (adds ₹300)₹1,730 (1,300 + 130 + 300)₹173₹300₹30
Total tax—₹403₹1,500₹150

Old system: each seller is taxed on a price that already includes earlier tax, so tax falls on tax: total ₹100 + 130 + 173 = ₹403. With input credit: each stage pays tax only on its own value added: ₹100 + 20 + 30 = ₹150, which equals 10% of the final value of 1,000 + 200 + 300 = ₹1,500. Removing tax on tax lowers the final price; this is the main advantage the textbook claims for GST.

Direct tax: impact and incidence on the same person; cannot be shifted; progressive. Indirect tax: shifted to the buyer; regressive; hidden in the price.

Key takeaways: direct taxes (income, wealth) cannot be shifted and are progressive, certain, elastic and cheap to collect but unpopular and open to evasion. Indirect taxes reach everyone and can curb harmful goods but are regressive and hidden. GST (1 July 2017) is a destination-based tax on value added at each stage, collected as CGST + SGST within a state and IGST between states, with no cascading.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A tax whose impact and incidence fall on the same person is:

    1. an indirect tax
    2. a direct tax
    3. a customs duty
    4. an excise duty
    Show answer

    Answer: B. With a direct tax the person who pays the government also bears the burden; it cannot be shifted.

  2. 2. Why is an indirect tax called regressive?

    1. The same tax takes a larger share of a poorer person's income
    2. Its rate rises with income
    3. It is paid only by the rich
    4. It cannot be shifted
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Rich and poor pay the same tax on the same goods, which is a bigger fraction of a smaller income.

  3. 3. A good made in Tamil Nadu is sold to a trader in Kerala. Which GST applies?

    1. IGST
    2. SGST of Tamil Nadu
    3. CGST only
    4. No GST
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Inter-state sales attract IGST, collected by the Centre and shared according to the destination of the goods.

  4. 4. Made-up data: a flat indirect tax costs each of two people ₹4,000 a year. One earns ₹1,00,000, the other ₹8,00,000. The tax as a share of the lower income is:

    1. 0.5%
    2. 4%
    3. 8%
    4. 40%
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 4,000 ÷ 1,00,000 × 100 = 4%. For the higher income it is 4,000 ÷ 8,00,000 × 100 = 0.5%, showing the regressive effect.

  5. 5. Dalton's remark that under indirect taxes '2 + 2 may be 3' refers to:

    1. the low cost of collection
    2. certainty of payment
    3. uncertainty of revenue, because higher tax reduces demand
    4. their wide coverage
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Raising an indirect tax raises prices and cuts demand, so doubling the rate need not double the revenue.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Public debt and the government budget

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery