• Practice
  • About 22 min
  • 5 practice questions

Public debt and the government budget

Explain internal and external public debt, why it grows and how it is redeemed, describe the types of budget and the budget procedure in India, and calculate revenue, budget, fiscal and primary deficits.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define public debt and distinguish internal from external debt.
  • Explain causes of public debt and seven methods of redemption.
  • Describe types of budget and the budgetary procedure in India.
  • Calculate revenue, fiscal and primary deficits.

In the 18th and 19th centuries governments did little; since the 20th century their duties have grown enormously, and taxes alone rarely cover them. Governments therefore borrow. Each year they also present a budget that shows how much they expect to raise, spend and borrow.

Public debt

Philip E. Taylor described public debt as the Treasury's promises to pay holders a principal sum and, usually, interest, borrowed to finance a current deficit. Internal debt is borrowed from citizens and institutions inside the country (individuals buying bonds, banks, institutions such as LIC, and the central bank); it is only a transfer of wealth within the country. External debt is borrowed from abroad: other governments and international bodies such as the IMF, World Bank, IDA and ADB.

  • Causes of growth: war and defence preparation; welfare obligations; economic development and deficit budgets; fighting unemployment; controlling inflation (borrowing withdraws excess money); and compensatory spending during depression.
Redemption of public debt
Method of redemptionHow it works
Sinking fundA fixed sum is set aside every year so that the fund can repay the debt at maturity (the textbook credits Walpole in England with introducing it)
ConversionA high-interest loan is replaced by a low-interest one; Dalton held that this eases the burden
Budgetary surplusA surplus of revenue over spending repays debt (rarely possible)
Terminal annuityDebt repaid in equal annual instalments
RepudiationGovernment refuses to repay; destroys its credit, so normally avoided
Reduction in rate of interestCompulsory cut in interest during a financial crisis
Capital levyA progressive levy on capital assets above a limit, used for war debts; the most controversial method

Worked example 1: a sinking fund (made-up, no interest earned on the fund)

A government must repay ₹600 crore in 5 years. Step 1: equal yearly saving = 600 ÷ 5 = ₹120 crore a year. Step 2: check: 120 × 5 = 600. In practice the fund also earns interest, so the yearly amount can be a little less.

The budget

'Budget' comes from the French bougette, a small leather bag. It is the annual financial statement of the government's estimated income and expenditure for the coming financial year. In India the Union Government presents the Annual Financial Statement to Parliament under Article 112, and each state to its legislature under Article 202.

Types of budget
TypeMeaning
Revenue budgetRevenue receipts (tax and non-tax) and revenue expenditure
Capital budgetCapital receipts (loans, recovery of loans, disinvestment) and capital expenditure (assets such as railways, roads, irrigation)
Supplementary budgetExtra provision for wars, floods, tsunamis and other unforeseen events
Vote-on-account (Article 116)Parliament's permission to draw from the Consolidated Fund for essential spending until the full budget is passed, usually for about two months, e.g. in an election year
Zero-base budgetEvery item justified afresh as if new; the textbook dates India's first use to 1987-88
Performance (outcome) budgetBased on results: what was done and how much; first recommended in the USA by the Hoover Commission (1949)
Balanced / surplus / deficitRevenue = expenditure / revenue > expenditure / revenue < expenditure

The textbook also splits spending into plan and non-plan expenditure; the Union budget stopped using that split from 2017-18 and now classifies spending as revenue and capital.

Budget procedure in India

  1. Estimates from ministries Departments send their income and spending estimates
  2. Finance Ministry prepares Budget built on targets, strategy and estimates
  3. Cabinet approval Finance Minister places it before the cabinet
  4. Presented to Parliament Lok Sabha first, since money bills start there
  5. Finance and Appropriation Bills passed Taxes approved; spending authorised
  6. Execution and control Departments spend; Public Accounts and Estimates Committees keep watch

Government accounts are kept in three parts: the Consolidated Fund, the Contingency Fund and the Public Account.

Budget deficits

Revenue deficit = revenue expenditure − revenue receipts. Fiscal deficit = total expenditure − (revenue receipts + non-debt capital receipts) = the government's borrowing. Primary deficit = fiscal deficit − interest payments.

Worked example 2: computing the deficits (made-up figures, ₹ crore)

ItemAmount
Revenue receipts1,500
Revenue expenditure (includes interest 250)1,900
Capital expenditure600
Recovery of loans and disinvestment (non-debt capital receipts)100
Borrowing and other liabilities900

Revenue deficit = 1,900 − 1,500 = 400. Total expenditure = 1,900 + 600 = 2,500. Fiscal deficit = 2,500 − (1,500 + 100) = 900, which matches the borrowing of 900. Primary deficit = 900 − 250 = 650: the borrowing needed for this year's spending, leaving out interest on past debt. Check: receipts 1,500 + 100 + 900 = 2,500 = total expenditure. (The Tamil Nadu textbook writes the fiscal deficit as 'budget deficit minus borrowing'; the standard definition used here is that the fiscal deficit equals total borrowing, i.e. budget deficit plus borrowing and other liabilities.)

Key takeaways: public debt is internal or external and grows with war, welfare, development, unemployment, inflation control and depression. It is redeemed by sinking fund, conversion, surplus, annuity, (rarely) repudiation, interest cuts or capital levy. The budget (Articles 112 and 202) may be revenue or capital, supplementary, vote-on-account, zero-base or performance, and balanced, surplus or deficit. Revenue, fiscal and primary deficits measure different gaps.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Repaying a debt by setting aside a fixed sum every year in a separate fund is called:

    1. conversion
    2. capital levy
    3. repudiation
    4. sinking fund
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A sinking fund accumulates fixed annual amounts to repay the debt when it matures.

  2. 2. Made-up figures: revenue expenditure ₹800 crore, revenue receipts ₹650 crore. The revenue deficit is:

    1. ₹1,450 crore
    2. ₹150 crore
    3. ₹650 crore
    4. ₹800 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Revenue deficit = revenue expenditure − revenue receipts = 800 − 650 = ₹150 crore.

  3. 3. Fiscal deficit ₹500 crore, interest payments ₹180 crore. The primary deficit is:

    1. ₹180 crore
    2. ₹680 crore
    3. ₹320 crore
    4. ₹500 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Primary deficit = fiscal deficit − interest = 500 − 180 = ₹320 crore.

  4. 4. The Union Budget is presented to Parliament under Article:

    1. 202
    2. 116
    3. 280
    4. 112
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 112 (Annual Financial Statement of the Union); Article 202 is for states; Article 116 provides for vote-on-account; Article 280 for the Finance Commission.

  5. 5. A budget in which every item of spending must be justified afresh as if it were new is a:

    1. zero-base budget
    2. performance budget
    3. supplementary budget
    4. vote-on-account
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Zero-base budgeting evaluates each item from zero; a performance budget is based on outcomes.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery