• Practice
  • About 22 min
  • 5 practice questions

Federal finance, the Finance Commission, local finance and fiscal policy

Explain how revenue is shared in India's federal system, the principles of federal finance and the role of the Finance Commission, the revenue sources of local bodies, and the instruments and objectives of fiscal policy.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain federal finance and the three lists of the Seventh Schedule.
  • Give examples of Union and state revenue sources and shared taxes.
  • State the principles of federal finance and the functions of the Finance Commission.
  • Name the revenue sources of local bodies.
  • Explain the instruments and objectives of fiscal policy.

India has three layers of government: the Union, the states and local bodies. Each has duties, and each needs money. Federal finance is the system of assigning revenue sources between the Centre and the states so that each can carry out its functions; local finance is the money of panchayats and municipalities. Fiscal policy then uses the whole budget to steer the economy.

Division of powers

The Seventh Schedule of the Constitution has three lists. According to the textbook, the Union List has 100 subjects of national importance (defence, railways, posts), the State List 61 subjects of local interest (public health, police) and the Concurrent List 52 subjects important to both (electricity, trade unions, economic and social planning).

Some sources from the textbook's lists
Union sources (examples)State sources (examples)
Corporation tax; taxes on non-agricultural incomeLand revenue; taxes on agricultural income
Customs duties, including export dutiesTaxes on land and buildings
Excise on tobacco and other goods made in IndiaExcise on alcoholic liquor and opium made in the state
Currency, foreign exchange, foreign loans, the RBITaxes on vehicles, animals and boats; tolls
Railways; posts and telecommunicationTaxes on professions, trades and employment
Public debt of the UnionStamp duty on documents other than those in the Union List

The textbook also lists taxes levied by the Union but assigned to or collected by the states (Articles 268 and 269) and taxes shared between them (Article 270). Two updates: since the 80th Amendment (2000) most central taxes, including corporation tax, form a single pool shared with the states; and since the 101st Amendment (2016) many earlier indirect taxes on both lists, such as sales tax, entry tax and entertainment tax, have been subsumed in GST.

Principles of federal finance

  1. Independence: each government has its own sources and autonomy.
  2. Equity: each state gets a fair share.
  3. Uniformity: equal contribution by states (hard in practice, as taxable capacity differs).
  4. Adequacy: enough, and elastic, resources for current and future needs.
  5. Fiscal access: room to develop new sources as duties grow.
  6. Integration and co-ordination between layers.
  7. Efficiency: no evasion and no double taxation.
  8. Administrative economy: low collection costs.
  9. Accountability: each government answers to its own legislature.

The Finance Commission

The Finance Commission is a quasi-judicial body under Article 280, first set up in 1951 (its first chairman was K.C. Neogy). It is constituted every five years (normally two years before its period) to reduce vertical imbalance (between the Centre and the states) and horizontal imbalance (among states). Under Article 280(3) it recommends to the President: (1) how the net proceeds of shareable taxes are divided between the Union and the states and among the states; (2) the grants-in-aid to states under Article 275(1) and the principles for them; and (3) any other matter referred in the interest of sound finance, such as debt relief or calamity relief.

Worked example 1: dividing a shared pool (made-up shares)

Suppose a commission recommends that 40% of a ₹10,00,000 crore divisible pool goes to the states. States' share = 0.40 × 10,00,000 = ₹4,00,000 crore; the Union keeps 10,00,000 − 4,00,000 = ₹6,00,000 crore. If one state's share of the states' portion is 7%, it receives 0.07 × 4,00,000 = ₹28,000 crore. (Actual percentages are fixed by each commission and change; these are illustrations.)

Local finance

Local bodyMain sources of revenue (textbook)
Village panchayatProperty tax, taxes on land, profession tax, taxes on animals and vehicles, with state approval and within limits
District board (zila parishad)State grants, land cesses, tolls and fees, property income, grants for centrally sponsored schemes, fairs
MunicipalityProperty tax, taxes on goods (octroi, terminal tax), profession tax, vehicle tax, show tax, state grants
Municipal corporationProperty tax, vehicle and animal tax, profession tax, show tax, advertisement tax, taxes on goods entering the city; more freedom within legal limits

Fiscal policy

Fiscal policy became popular after the Great Depression and Keynes's 'new economics'. Arthur Smithies defined it as the government's use of its expenditure and revenue programmes to produce desirable effects (and avoid undesirable ones) on national income, production and employment. Its instruments are taxation, public expenditure and public borrowing. Raising taxes and cutting spending restrain an inflation; cutting taxes and raising spending fight a depression.

Objectives of fiscal policy

  • Full employment
    • Spending on social overheads and rural employment programmes such as MGNREGS
  • Price stability
    • Cut spending or raise income tax when demand is excessive
  • Economic growth
    • Tax holidays and rebates for new industries; public investment
  • Equitable distribution
    • Progressive taxes; welfare spending such as free education and noon meals
  • External stability
    • Export incentives; duties on non-essential imports
  • Capital formation
    • Tax relief to raise saving; infrastructure spending
  • Regional balance
    • Incentives and industrial estates in backward regions

Worked example 2: choosing the fiscal stance

Made-up situation: output is falling, unemployment is rising and private investment has dried up. Step 1: the problem is too little aggregate demand. Step 2: the fiscal remedy is to raise public expenditure (for example on roads and rural works) and reduce taxes, financed if needed by borrowing. Step 3: if instead prices were rising because of excess demand, the government would cut spending and raise taxes.

Fiscal policy tools: taxation, public expenditure and public debt. In a depression: spend more, tax less. In inflation: spend less, tax more.

Key takeaways: federal finance divides revenue sources between the Union and states using the Seventh Schedule; most central taxes now form a shared pool, and GST has replaced many older indirect taxes. Principles include independence, equity, adequacy and accountability. The Finance Commission (Article 280, every five years) recommends tax sharing and grants. Local bodies rely on property and local taxes plus state grants. Fiscal policy uses taxes, spending and debt for employment, stability, growth, equity, external stability, capital formation and regional balance.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Finance Commission is set up under Article:

    1. 112
    2. 275
    3. 280
    4. 202
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 280 provides for the Finance Commission; Article 275(1) concerns the grants-in-aid it recommends.

  2. 2. The imbalance between the Centre's resources and the states' needs is called:

    1. vertical imbalance
    2. horizontal imbalance
    3. fiscal deficit
    4. revenue deficit
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Vertical imbalance is between the Centre and the states; horizontal imbalance is among the states.

  3. 3. Which tax is a state source in the textbook's lists?

    1. Corporation tax
    2. Customs duty
    3. Taxes on non-agricultural income
    4. Taxes on agricultural income
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Taxes on agricultural income belong to the states; income tax on other income, corporation tax and customs are Union sources.

  4. 4. To fight a depression, fiscal policy would:

    1. raise taxes and cut spending
    2. cut taxes and raise public spending
    3. cut both taxes and spending
    4. repay all public debt at once
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Lower taxes raise disposable income and higher public spending adds to demand, lifting output and employment.

  5. 5. Made-up figures: 41% of a ₹5,00,000 crore pool goes to the states. The states' total share is:

    1. ₹2,95,000 crore
    2. ₹2,05,000 crore
    3. ₹41,000 crore
    4. ₹20,500 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 0.41 × 5,00,000 = ₹2,05,000 crore. The Union keeps the remaining ₹2,95,000 crore.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery