• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Public expenditure, public revenue and the canons of taxation

Classify public expenditure by benefit and by function, explain why government spending has grown, distinguish tax from non-tax revenue, and state Adam Smith's four canons of taxation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define public expenditure and classify it (Cohn and Plehn; Adam Smith).
  • Explain the causes of the growth of public expenditure.
  • Define tax, list its characteristics and name the sources of non-tax revenue.
  • State and apply the four canons of taxation.

A welfare state spends on many things, and every rupee spent must first be raised. This lesson looks at both sides: what governments spend on and why the total keeps rising, and where their revenue comes from.

Public expenditure

Public expenditure is spending by public authorities (central, state and local governments) to satisfy the collective social wants of the people.

Classification of public expenditure
BasisClasses
By benefit (Cohn and Plehn)(a) benefits the whole society, e.g. defence, education, public health; (b) special benefit to some plus common benefit to all, e.g. administration of justice; (c) direct benefit to a group and indirect benefit to all, e.g. social security, pensions, unemployment relief; (d) special benefit to some, e.g. a subsidy to one industry
By function (Adam Smith)(a) protection: defence, police, courts; (b) commercial: transport and communication for trade; (c) development: infrastructure and industry

Why public expenditure keeps growing

  • Population growth: India's population grew from 36.1 crore (1951 Census) to 121 crore (2011 Census), needing more health, education and law and order; a young population needs schools, an ageing one pensions and health care.
  • Defence: modernisation of defence equipment.
  • Subsidies: on food, fertilisers, exports, priority-sector interest, education and more.
  • Debt servicing: interest and repayment on past borrowing.
  • Development projects: irrigation, steel, power, telecommunications.
  • Urbanisation: more spending on law and order, education and civic amenities in cities.
  • Industrialisation: basic and heavy industries need huge capital and long gestation.
  • Grants-in-aid to states and union territories, for example for natural disasters.

Public revenue

Public revenue is the income of the government from all sources. Dalton distinguished a wide sense, public receipts (all receipts, including loans), from a narrow sense, public revenue (only the ordinary revenue resources). Public revenue is of two kinds: tax revenue and non-tax revenue.

A tax is a compulsory payment to the government without reference to any specific benefit to the payer (Anatol Murad); Dalton adds that it is not imposed as a penalty for an offence. Its characteristics: it is compulsory (refusal is punishable); there is no quid pro quo (no direct return); it involves a sacrifice by the taxpayer; and it is not a fine. Examples: income tax, corporate tax, taxes on sales, surcharges and cesses.

Non-tax revenue

  • Fees
    • Charged for a service, e.g. passports, driving licences
  • Fines
    • Penalties for breaking the law, e.g. traffic offences
  • Earnings of public enterprises
    • Profits and dividends
  • Special assessment (betterment levy)
    • On owners whose property gains value from a public project
  • Gifts, grants and aid
    • Centre to states, states to local bodies; foreign aid
  • Escheats
    • Property of a person who dies without heirs or a will passes to the state

Worked example 1: betterment levy (made-up figures)

A new road raises the value of a plot from ₹20 lakh to ₹26 lakh. Suppose the municipality charges a betterment levy of one-third of the gain. Step 1: gain = 26 − 20 = ₹6 lakh. Step 2: levy = 6 ÷ 3 = ₹2 lakh. Step 3: the owner still keeps 6 − 2 = ₹4 lakh of the gain. The levy is a special charge on those who benefit from a public project, which is why it is non-tax revenue rather than a general tax.

Canons of taxation

Canons are the qualities a good tax should have. They apply to a single tax; a good tax system combines taxes with different canons. Adam Smith gave four:

Adam Smith's canons
CanonMeaning
AbilityPeople pay according to their ability: the rich pay more than the middle class or the poor
CertaintyThe rate, amount and time of payment must be clear, not arbitrary
ConvenienceThe method and time of collection should suit the taxpayer
EconomyThe cost of collecting should be small compared with the yield

Worked example 2: testing the canon of economy (made-up figures)

Tax A yields ₹500 crore and costs ₹10 crore to collect; Tax B yields ₹40 crore and costs ₹8 crore. Cost per ₹100 collected: A = 10 ÷ 500 × 100 = ₹2; B = 8 ÷ 40 × 100 = ₹20. Tax B spends ten times as much per rupee collected, so by Smith's canon of economy it is the 'bad' tax.

Tax: a compulsory payment with no quid pro quo, not a penalty. Fee: a payment for a specific service. Fine: a penalty for breaking the law.

Key takeaways: public expenditure satisfies collective wants; Cohn and Plehn classify it by benefit and Adam Smith by function. It grows with population, defence, subsidies, debt, development, urbanisation, industrialisation and grants. Revenue is tax (compulsory, no quid pro quo) or non-tax (fees, fines, enterprise profits, betterment levy, grants, escheats). Smith's canons are ability, certainty, convenience and economy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A payment made to obtain a passport is a:

    1. tax
    2. fine
    3. escheat
    4. fee
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A fee is charged for a specific service rendered by a public authority, such as issuing a passport. A tax has no quid pro quo; a fine is a penalty.

  2. 2. 'No quid pro quo' as a feature of a tax means that:

    1. the taxpayer cannot claim a specific benefit in return
    2. the tax is voluntary
    3. the tax is a penalty
    4. the tax must be paid in gold
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A taxpayer cannot demand a particular service in exchange for the tax paid.

  3. 3. The state's claim to the property of a person who dies without legal heirs or a will is called:

    1. betterment levy
    2. capital levy
    3. escheat
    4. grant
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Escheat is the state's claim to such property, a source of non-tax revenue.

  4. 4. Spending on defence, police and courts falls under which of Adam Smith's functional classes?

    1. Commercial functions
    2. Special benefit
    3. Development functions
    4. Protection functions
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Protection functions cover security from external invasion and internal disorder: defence, police and courts.

  5. 5. A tax whose collection cost is very high compared with its yield violates the canon of:

    1. ability
    2. certainty
    3. economy
    4. convenience
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The canon of economy says collection costs should be low; taxes with heavy collection costs are bad taxes.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery