Revision notes

Chapter 9 Fiscal Economics: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Public finance: meaning, scope and the role of the modern state

Scope of public finance

  • Public revenue
    • Tax and non-tax sources
    • Principles, rates, impact, incidence and shifting of taxes
  • Public expenditure
    • Principles, effects and control of spending
  • Public debt
    • Internal and external loans
    • Burden, effects and redemption
  • Financial administration
    • Preparing, passing, executing and auditing the budget
  • Fiscal policy
    • Taxes, subsidies, debt and spending as policy tools
Public vs private finance (textbook's points)
SimilaritiesDifferences
Both rest on rationality: maximum welfare at least costGovernment adjusts income to expenditure; a household adjusts expenditure to income
Both must limit borrowing; a government also cannot live beyond its means for everGovernment can borrow at home and abroad and from its own citizens; a person cannot borrow from himself
Both have limited resources and try to use them bestOnly the government can print currency
Both depend on efficient, honest administrationPublic finance plans for the long term (schools, hospitals); private decisions are usually shorter term
—Public aim: social benefit; private aim: personal benefit or profit
—Government can use its authority (coercion) to raise revenue and make large deliberate changes to it
Decision (made up)Public or private financeClue
A family postpones buying a car because its income fellPrivateSpending adjusted to income
A state decides to build ten hospitals and then plans taxes and loans to pay for themPublicIncome adjusted to the needed spending
A company issues shares to expand its factory for profitPrivateProfit motive
The Union issues bonds bought by its own citizensPublicGovernment can borrow from its own people

Public finance: the study of the revenue and expenditure of public authorities and of the adjustment of one to the other.

Key takeaways: public finance (fiscal economics) studies how the state raises and spends resources. Its scope covers public revenue, public expenditure, public debt, financial administration and fiscal policy. Public and private finance share rationality and limits but differ in how income and spending are adjusted, borrowing, currency, time horizon, objective and power. The modern welfare state defends, judges, regulates, provides welfare and infrastructure, manages the economy, pursues social justice and controls monopoly.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Public expenditure, public revenue and the canons of taxation

Classification of public expenditure
BasisClasses
By benefit (Cohn and Plehn)(a) benefits the whole society, e.g. defence, education, public health; (b) special benefit to some plus common benefit to all, e.g. administration of justice; (c) direct benefit to a group and indirect benefit to all, e.g. social security, pensions, unemployment relief; (d) special benefit to some, e.g. a subsidy to one industry
By function (Adam Smith)(a) protection: defence, police, courts; (b) commercial: transport and communication for trade; (c) development: infrastructure and industry

Non-tax revenue

  • Fees
    • Charged for a service, e.g. passports, driving licences
  • Fines
    • Penalties for breaking the law, e.g. traffic offences
  • Earnings of public enterprises
    • Profits and dividends
  • Special assessment (betterment levy)
    • On owners whose property gains value from a public project
  • Gifts, grants and aid
    • Centre to states, states to local bodies; foreign aid
  • Escheats
    • Property of a person who dies without heirs or a will passes to the state
Adam Smith's canons
CanonMeaning
AbilityPeople pay according to their ability: the rich pay more than the middle class or the poor
CertaintyThe rate, amount and time of payment must be clear, not arbitrary
ConvenienceThe method and time of collection should suit the taxpayer
EconomyThe cost of collecting should be small compared with the yield

Tax: a compulsory payment with no quid pro quo, not a penalty. Fee: a payment for a specific service. Fine: a penalty for breaking the law.

Key takeaways: public expenditure satisfies collective wants; Cohn and Plehn classify it by benefit and Adam Smith by function. It grows with population, defence, subsidies, debt, development, urbanisation, industrialisation and grants. Revenue is tax (compulsory, no quid pro quo) or non-tax (fees, fines, enterprise profits, betterment levy, grants, escheats). Smith's canons are ability, certainty, convenience and economy.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Direct and indirect taxes, and the Goods and Services Tax

Direct taxes
MeritsDemerits
Equity: progressive ratesUnpopular and less flexible
Certainty: the payer knows how much and whenMay discourage effort to earn more
Elasticity: revenue rises automatically with incomeInconvenient: accounts, returns, lump-sum payment
Economy: low cost of collectionEncourages evasion and black money
Indirect taxes
MeritsDemerits
Wide coverage: everyone who buys paysHigher cost of collection (the textbook's view)
Equitable when luxuries are taxed moreLess elastic, since rates are generally proportional
Traders collect it, acting as honorary collectorsRegressive: the same tax takes a larger share of a poor person's income
Checks harmful consumption ('sin taxes' on tobacco and liquor)Uncertain yield: higher tax cuts demand (Dalton: here 2 + 2 may be 3)
Convenient: paid in small amounts with the priceNo civic consciousness: the tax is hidden in the price
Comparison chart
BasisDirect taxIndirect tax
Levied onIncome or wealthPurchase, sale or manufacture of goods and services
NatureProgressiveRegressive
Impact and incidenceOn the same personOn different persons
ShiftingCannot be shiftedCan be shifted
EvasionPossibleHardly possible, since it is in the price
InflationHelps control itPushes prices up
Components of GST
ComponentCollected byOn
CGSTCentral GovernmentSales within a state (intra-state)
SGSTState GovernmentSales within a state, alongside CGST
IGSTCentral Government, then shared by destinationSales from one state to another (inter-state)
StageSale price before taxOld tax on full price (cascading)Value addedGST on value added
Manufacturer₹1,000₹100₹1,000₹100
Wholesaler (adds ₹200)₹1,300 (1,000 + 100 tax + 200)₹130₹200₹20
Retailer (adds ₹300)₹1,730 (1,300 + 130 + 300)₹173₹300₹30
Total tax—₹403₹1,500₹150

Direct tax: impact and incidence on the same person; cannot be shifted; progressive. Indirect tax: shifted to the buyer; regressive; hidden in the price.

Key takeaways: direct taxes (income, wealth) cannot be shifted and are progressive, certain, elastic and cheap to collect but unpopular and open to evasion. Indirect taxes reach everyone and can curb harmful goods but are regressive and hidden. GST (1 July 2017) is a destination-based tax on value added at each stage, collected as CGST + SGST within a state and IGST between states, with no cascading.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Public debt and the government budget

Redemption of public debt
Method of redemptionHow it works
Sinking fundA fixed sum is set aside every year so that the fund can repay the debt at maturity (the textbook credits Walpole in England with introducing it)
ConversionA high-interest loan is replaced by a low-interest one; Dalton held that this eases the burden
Budgetary surplusA surplus of revenue over spending repays debt (rarely possible)
Terminal annuityDebt repaid in equal annual instalments
RepudiationGovernment refuses to repay; destroys its credit, so normally avoided
Reduction in rate of interestCompulsory cut in interest during a financial crisis
Capital levyA progressive levy on capital assets above a limit, used for war debts; the most controversial method
Types of budget
TypeMeaning
Revenue budgetRevenue receipts (tax and non-tax) and revenue expenditure
Capital budgetCapital receipts (loans, recovery of loans, disinvestment) and capital expenditure (assets such as railways, roads, irrigation)
Supplementary budgetExtra provision for wars, floods, tsunamis and other unforeseen events
Vote-on-account (Article 116)Parliament's permission to draw from the Consolidated Fund for essential spending until the full budget is passed, usually for about two months, e.g. in an election year
Zero-base budgetEvery item justified afresh as if new; the textbook dates India's first use to 1987-88
Performance (outcome) budgetBased on results: what was done and how much; first recommended in the USA by the Hoover Commission (1949)
Balanced / surplus / deficitRevenue = expenditure / revenue > expenditure / revenue < expenditure

Budget procedure in India

  1. Estimates from ministries Departments send their income and spending estimates
  2. Finance Ministry prepares Budget built on targets, strategy and estimates
  3. Cabinet approval Finance Minister places it before the cabinet
  4. Presented to Parliament Lok Sabha first, since money bills start there
  5. Finance and Appropriation Bills passed Taxes approved; spending authorised
  6. Execution and control Departments spend; Public Accounts and Estimates Committees keep watch

Revenue deficit = revenue expenditure − revenue receipts. Fiscal deficit = total expenditure − (revenue receipts + non-debt capital receipts) = the government's borrowing. Primary deficit = fiscal deficit − interest payments.

ItemAmount
Revenue receipts1,500
Revenue expenditure (includes interest 250)1,900
Capital expenditure600
Recovery of loans and disinvestment (non-debt capital receipts)100
Borrowing and other liabilities900

Key takeaways: public debt is internal or external and grows with war, welfare, development, unemployment, inflation control and depression. It is redeemed by sinking fund, conversion, surplus, annuity, (rarely) repudiation, interest cuts or capital levy. The budget (Articles 112 and 202) may be revenue or capital, supplementary, vote-on-account, zero-base or performance, and balanced, surplus or deficit. Revenue, fiscal and primary deficits measure different gaps.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Federal finance, the Finance Commission, local finance and fiscal policy

Some sources from the textbook's lists
Union sources (examples)State sources (examples)
Corporation tax; taxes on non-agricultural incomeLand revenue; taxes on agricultural income
Customs duties, including export dutiesTaxes on land and buildings
Excise on tobacco and other goods made in IndiaExcise on alcoholic liquor and opium made in the state
Currency, foreign exchange, foreign loans, the RBITaxes on vehicles, animals and boats; tolls
Railways; posts and telecommunicationTaxes on professions, trades and employment
Public debt of the UnionStamp duty on documents other than those in the Union List
Local bodyMain sources of revenue (textbook)
Village panchayatProperty tax, taxes on land, profession tax, taxes on animals and vehicles, with state approval and within limits
District board (zila parishad)State grants, land cesses, tolls and fees, property income, grants for centrally sponsored schemes, fairs
MunicipalityProperty tax, taxes on goods (octroi, terminal tax), profession tax, vehicle tax, show tax, state grants
Municipal corporationProperty tax, vehicle and animal tax, profession tax, show tax, advertisement tax, taxes on goods entering the city; more freedom within legal limits

Objectives of fiscal policy

  • Full employment
    • Spending on social overheads and rural employment programmes such as MGNREGS
  • Price stability
    • Cut spending or raise income tax when demand is excessive
  • Economic growth
    • Tax holidays and rebates for new industries; public investment
  • Equitable distribution
    • Progressive taxes; welfare spending such as free education and noon meals
  • External stability
    • Export incentives; duties on non-essential imports
  • Capital formation
    • Tax relief to raise saving; infrastructure spending
  • Regional balance
    • Incentives and industrial estates in backward regions

Fiscal policy tools: taxation, public expenditure and public debt. In a depression: spend more, tax less. In inflation: spend less, tax more.

Key takeaways: federal finance divides revenue sources between the Union and states using the Seventh Schedule; most central taxes now form a shared pool, and GST has replaced many older indirect taxes. Principles include independence, equity, adequacy and accountability. The Finance Commission (Article 280, every five years) recommends tax sharing and grants. Local bodies rely on property and local taxes plus state grants. Fiscal policy uses taxes, spending and debt for employment, stability, growth, equity, external stability, capital formation and regional balance.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery