- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Congress, Syed Ahmed Khan and communal politics before 1906
Explain the secular stand of the early Congress, why Syed Ahmed Khan turned to cooperation with the British, how local body elections and religious symbols in politics sharpened divisions, and how the book judges the Congress response.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe how the early Congress leadership tried to keep religion out of its resolutions.
- Explain why Syed Ahmed Khan moved from supporting the Congress to cooperating with the British, and name Muslim leaders who supported the Congress.
- Explain how municipal politics and the use of religious symbols in the early 1900s deepened communal feeling, and what the book calls the Congress's 'weak-kneed' policy.
This lesson continues section 6.1 of the textbook. It shows that communalism did not grow only from outside pressure: choices made by Indian leaders and the working of new elected bodies also mattered.
The early Congress and religion
The textbook notes that many Congressmen were also active in Hindu bodies such as the Arya Samaj, but that the Congress leadership was secular. When some members tried, at the third session of the Congress, to pass a resolution making cow killing a penal offence, the leadership refused to take it up. The Congress then adopted a rule: if delegates of a community objected to a resolution affecting that community, it would not be considered, even if those delegates were a minority. The book presents the founding of the Congress in 1885 as an attempt to narrow the Hindu-Muslim divide and to place the grievances of all communities before the British.
Syed Ahmed Khan and Muslim leaders
Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, founder of the Aligarh movement, at first supported the Congress. The book says he later came to believe that in a country governed by Hindus, Muslims would be helpless because they were a minority. Representative institutions and open competition for government posts made him and his followers anxious, so they chose close cooperation with the government. In the book's judgement, he hoped this would secure for Muslims a larger share than numbers or merit alone would bring.
Not all Muslim leaders agreed. The textbook names supporters of the Congress: Badruddin Tyabji and Rahmatullah Sayani in Bombay (Mumbai), Nawab Syed Mohammed Bahadur in Madras (Chennai) and A. Rasul in Bengal. But, the book says, most Muslims in north India followed Syed Ahmed Khan and supported the British. Syed Ahmed Khan and Syed Ameer Ali, whom the book describes as the first Indian to find a place in the Privy Council in London, presented the Congress as a body of Hindus only. The book notes that only two of the seventy-two delegates at the first Congress session were Muslims.
Two Muslim responses to the early Congress
-
Followed Syed Ahmed Khan
- Feared rule by a Hindu majority
- Worried about open competition for posts
- Chose cooperation with the British
- Described the Congress as a Hindu body
-
Supported the Congress
- Badruddin Tyabji, Rahmatullah Sayani (Bombay)
- Nawab Syed Mohammed Bahadur (Madras)
- A. Rasul (Bengal)
- Saw common grievances against colonial rule
Communalism in local body elections
The book points out an unintended result of democratic politics. From the 1880s, municipal and local bodies gave councillors wide powers of patronage, which could be used to build a political base. When one community took control of a municipal board from the other, local politics became communal. Lal Chand, spokesman of the Punjab Hindu Sabha and later an Arya Samaj leader, described municipal committees where members sat in two rows by religion, so that they saw themselves first as Hindus or Muslims rather than as councillors.
The 'weak-kneed' policy of the Congress
During the Swadeshi movement in Bengal (1905-06), Muslims who supported Swadeshi were abused as 'Congress touts' by communal elements. The book judges that the Congress's silence, and its unwillingness to confront such elements directly, encouraged communal politics and discouraged nationalist Muslims. The book also quotes Jawaharlal Nehru, who held that Hindu and Muslim communalism came from quarrels within the middle class and were far removed from the thinking of ordinary people.
In the first decade of the twentieth century, the book says, political radicalism went together with religious conservatism. Tilak, Aurobindo Ghosh and Lala Lajpat Rai stirred anti-colonial feeling using religious symbols, festivals and platforms; the book singles out Tilak's use of the Ganapati festival to mobilise Hindus as the most aggravating factor. At the same time Lal Chand accused the Congress of appeasing Muslims. So the Congress was criticised from both sides.
How communal feeling spread before 1906 (as the book explains)
-
Leaders' choices
- Syed Ahmed Khan's turn to the British
- Congress described as a Hindu body
-
Working of new institutions
- Patronage in municipal boards from the 1880s
- Rivalry for control of local bodies
-
Religion in mass politics
- Religious festivals and symbols in agitation
- Tilak's Ganapati festival
-
Congress response
- Silence towards communal elements
- Nationalist Muslims discouraged
Worked example 1: explaining a change of view
Question: Why did Syed Ahmed Khan support the British? Step 1: note his first position - support for the Congress. Step 2: note what changed his mind, as the book says - fear that Muslims, as a minority, would be helpless under Hindu rule, and worry about elections and open competitive examinations. Step 3: give his aim - through cooperation with the government, to win a larger share for his community. This three-step answer fits a short-answer question.
Worked example 2: a statement check
Statement: 'The early Congress leadership adopted a resolution making cow killing a penal offence.' Step 1: recall the book - some members proposed it at the third session. Step 2: recall the outcome - the leadership refused to consider it and later adopted a rule protecting minority objections. Step 3: so the statement is wrong; the leadership kept religion out of its resolutions.
The book's view of this period: the Congress leadership was secular, but leaders on all sides used religion in politics, local body rivalries hardened divisions, and the Congress's silence towards communal elements discouraged nationalist Muslims.
Key takeaways: the Congress (1885) tried to stand above religion; Syed Ahmed Khan chose cooperation with the British, while leaders such as Tyabji, Sayani, Syed Mohammed Bahadur and Rasul backed the Congress; municipal patronage from the 1880s communalised local politics; and the book criticises both the use of religious symbols in agitation and the Congress's weak response.
Check your understanding
-
1. At which session of the Congress, according to the book, did some members try to make cow killing a penal offence?
- The first session
- The second session
- The third session
- The fifth session
Show answer
Answer: C. The book places the attempt at the third session and says the leadership refused to entertain it.
-
2. How many of the seventy-two delegates at the first Congress session were Muslims, as the textbook states?
- Two
- Twelve
- Seven
- None
Show answer
Answer: A. The book notes that only two of the 72 delegates were Muslims, a fact used by critics to present the Congress as a Hindu body.
-
3. Who, according to the book, was the first Indian to find a place in the Privy Council in London?
- Badruddin Tyabji
- Syed Ameer Ali
- Rahmatullah Sayani
- Sir Syed Ahmed Khan
Show answer
Answer: B. The book describes Syed Ameer Ali as the first Indian in the London Privy Council. He, like Syed Ahmed Khan, presented the Congress as representing Hindus only.
-
4. Which festival does the book say Tilak used to mobilise Hindus, calling it the most aggravating factor of the period?
- Diwali
- Durga Puja
- Holi
- The Ganapati festival
Show answer
Answer: D. The book names Tilak's use of the Ganapati festival. Radical leaders used religious symbols and festivals to rouse anti-colonial feeling, which, in the book's view, deepened communal division.
-
5. Why, according to the book, did local body elections from the 1880s promote communal politics?
- Councillors' powers of patronage made control of boards a prize fought over by community
- Only Muslims could vote in them
- They were abolished by the British
- They used separate electorates from the start
Show answer
Answer: A. Municipal councillors gained wide patronage, useful for building a political base. Struggles between Hindus and Muslims to control boards communalised local politics. Separate electorates came later, in 1909.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.