• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

The 1920s: Khilafat, Malabar, unity efforts and the Communal Award

Explain how the Khilafat movement, the Malabar rebellion of 1921 and the end of Non-Cooperation affected communal politics, the rise of the Mahasabha in UP and Punjab, the Delhi proposals of 1927, the 1928 convention and the Communal Award.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain how the Khilafat movement and its end changed relations between Hindus and Muslims, and describe the Suddhi and cow-protection campaigns.
  • Describe the Malabar rebellion of 1921 as the book does, and the communal tension in the United Provinces and Punjab.
  • Explain the Delhi proposals of 1927, why unity efforts failed in 1928, and what the book says about the Communal Award, the RSS and the Congress's ban on dual membership.

The early 1920s saw Hindus and Muslims united in the Khilafat and Non-Cooperation movements. The textbook shows how this unity broke down after 1922, and how repeated efforts to rebuild it failed.

Khilafat and the Hindu response

The book explains that before the First World War Britain had promised to protect the interests of the Caliph (the Khalifa, ruler of Turkey) and the holy places of Islam, but after Turkey's defeat it did not keep its word. Indian Muslims started the Khilafat movement to secure the Caliphate. The entry of the ulema (religious scholars) into politics, the book says, led some Hindus to fear an aggressive revival of Islam; it notes that even the Ali brothers were Khilafatists first and Congressmen second.

The power of religious mobilisation shown during Khilafat, according to the book, led Hindu communalists to try to mobilise Hindus the same way. The Suddhi movement (reconversion to Hinduism) was not new, but became more important after Khilafat. To draw Hindus into the boycott of the Prince of Wales's visit in 1921, Swami Shraddhananda tried to revive the Mahasabha through cow-protection propaganda.

The Malabar rebellion, 1921

In Malabar in 1921, Muslim peasants (Mappilas) rose against both the British rulers and Hindu landlords. The textbook calls it basically an agrarian revolt, but says communal passions ran high, so much so that Gandhi saw it as a Hindu-Muslim conflict and wanted Muslim leaders to apologise publicly for what happened. The book adds that the rebellion gave the Hindu Mahasabha another reason for a renewed campaign.

Communal tension in the United Provinces

The suspension of Non-Cooperation (1922) and the abolition of the Caliphate (1924) left Muslims frustrated, and the Khilafat-Congress alliance broke down. As both communities competed for power in the self-governing bodies created by the Act of 1919, there was fresh communal violence. The book gives figures for the Mahasabha's sixth annual conference at Varanasi in August 1923: of 968 delegates, 56.7% came from UP; UP, Punjab, Delhi and Bihar together sent 86.8%; Madras, Bombay and Bengal together sent only 6.6%.

Delegates at the Hindu Mahasabha's Varanasi conference, August 1923 (figures from the textbook)
RegionShare of the 968 delegates
United Provinces alone56.7%
UP, Punjab, Delhi and Bihar together86.8%
Madras, Bombay and Bengal together6.6%

The book adds that tension in UP was also fuelled by rivalry between Swarajists and Liberals. In Allahabad, Motilal Nehru and Madan Mohan Malaviya were opponents; when Motilal Nehru's group won the 1923 municipal elections, the book says Malaviya's group began to exploit religious feeling, citing a report by the District Magistrate, Crosthwaite.

Punjab and the Mahasabha's stand

In Punjab, the book says, communalism had become a powerful movement. In 1924 Lala Lajpat Rai openly suggested dividing Punjab into Hindu and Muslim provinces. The Mahasabha raised the slogan 'Akhand Hindustan' (undivided India) against the League's demand for separate electorates. The textbook calls the Mahasabha's role in the freedom struggle controversial: it did not support British rule, but it did not fully back the national movement either. Because the Congress needed every community's support, the book explains, it could not insist firmly on secularism for fear of losing religious-minded groups. Gandhi held several unity conferences, without success.

The Delhi proposals, 1927, and the 1928 convention

A Conference of Muslims at Delhi on 20 March 1927 offered to give up separate electorates if four proposals were accepted. Motilal Nehru and S. Srinivasa Iyengar (named 'S. Srinvasan' in the book) persuaded the All India Congress Committee to accept them, but the initiative failed. The book says the Congress delayed by appointing two committees, one on whether separating Sind was financially feasible and one on proportional representation. Gandhi remarked that the Hindu-Muslim question had passed out of human hands. At the All Parties Convention in Calcutta (1928), Mahasabha members rejected all amendments; Jinnah, whom Sarojini Naidu had called the ambassador of Hindu-Muslim unity, felt let down, and the book says most Muslims then believed they would get a better deal from the government than from the Congress.

The four Delhi proposals of 20 March 1927

  • Sind Separate Sind from the Bombay Presidency.
  • Frontier and Baluchistan Introduce reforms there.
  • Punjab and Bengal Representation according to population.
  • Central Legislature Thirty-three per cent of seats for Muslims.
Offered in return for giving up separate electorates

The Communal Award and the 1930s

The book says the British were consistent in promoting communalism; even delegates to the second Round Table Conference were chosen by their communal positions. After the Round Table Conferences failed, Prime Minister Ramsay MacDonald announced the Communal Award (in 1932; the book gives no year), which the book says further worsened the political climate. It also notes that the RSS, founded in 1925, was growing (the book gives its volunteers as 1,00,000), and that K.B. Hedgewar, V.D. Savarkar and M.S. Golwalkar developed the idea of a Hindu Rashtra; the book quotes Savarkar's claim that Hindus were a nation by themselves. The Congress barred its members from joining the Mahasabha or the RSS in 1934, but only in December 1938 did its Working Committee make Mahasabha membership a disqualification. The book also quotes Gandhi's answer to sectarian nationalism: religion and nationality are not the same thing, and Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims, Parsis and Christians are fellow countrymen.

Worked example 1: separating causes

Question: Give two reasons the book offers for fresh communal violence after 1922. Step 1: political reason - Hindus and Muslims competed for power in bodies created by the Act of 1919. Step 2: religious-emotional reason - frustration among Muslims after Non-Cooperation was suspended (1922) and the Caliphate was abolished (1924). A third, local reason for UP is the Swarajist-Liberal rivalry.

Worked example 2: checking a percentage

Using the book's figures: 56.7% of 968 delegates is 0.567 × 968 = 548.856, about 549 delegates from UP. And 6.6% of 968 is 0.066 × 968 = 63.888, about 64 delegates from Madras, Bombay and Bengal together. The contrast shows how north Indian the Mahasabha was.

After 1922 the unity of the Khilafat years broke down; the Delhi proposals (1927) offered a way out, but, as the book tells it, they fell through and the 1928 convention ended hopes of agreement.

— Summary of Unit 6, sections 6.3 (a)-(d)

Key takeaways: Khilafat united communities but also brought religion into mass politics; the book calls the Malabar rebellion basically agrarian with high communal passion; the Mahasabha was strongest in UP and Punjab; the 1927 Delhi proposals and the 1928 convention failed; the Communal Award and the growth of Hindu Rashtra ideas hardened divisions in the 1930s.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. How does the textbook describe the basic character of the Malabar rebellion of 1921?

    1. A planned religious war
    2. A mutiny of soldiers
    3. A revolt by landlords against peasants
    4. Basically an agrarian revolt in which communal passions ran high
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book says it was basically an agrarian revolt of Muslim peasants against British rulers and Hindu landlords, though communal feeling ran high and Gandhi saw it as a Hindu-Muslim conflict.

  2. 2. Which two events, according to the book, left Muslims frustrated in the early 1920s?

    1. The Lucknow Pact and the Minto-Morley Reforms
    2. Suspension of Non-Cooperation (1922) and abolition of the Caliphate (1924)
    3. The Simla deputation and the Swadeshi movement
    4. The Communal Award and the 1937 elections
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The book names the suspension of Non-Cooperation in 1922 and the abolition of the Caliphate in 1924. After these the Khilafat-Congress alliance broke down.

  3. 3. Which was NOT one of the Delhi proposals of 20 March 1927?

    1. Separation of Sind from Bombay
    2. Thirty-three per cent of seats for Muslims in the Central Legislature
    3. Partition of Punjab into Hindu and Muslim provinces
    4. Representation by population in Punjab and Bengal
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The four proposals were Sind's separation, reforms in the Frontier and Baluchistan, representation by population in Punjab and Bengal, and 33% of central seats. Partition of Punjab was Lajpat Rai's suggestion of 1924.

  4. 4. Who, according to the book, openly advocated the partition of Punjab into Hindu and Muslim provinces in 1924?

    1. Lala Lajpat Rai
    2. Madan Mohan Malaviya
    3. Motilal Nehru
    4. Swami Shraddhananda
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The book states that Lala Lajpat Rai advocated it in 1924, showing how deeply communalism had set in in Punjab.

  5. 5. In which year did the Congress Working Committee make membership of the Hindu Mahasabha a disqualification for Congress membership, as the book states?

    1. 1925
    2. 1934
    3. 1928
    4. 1938
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Congress forbade members from joining the Mahasabha or RSS in 1934, but only in December 1938 did the Working Committee declare Mahasabha membership a disqualification. 1925 is the founding year of the RSS.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery