- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The Muslim League, separate electorates and the Hindu Mahasabha
Describe the Simla deputation of 1906, the founding and aims of the All India Muslim League, separate electorates under the Minto-Morley Reforms of 1909, and the founding of the All India Hindu Mahasabha in 1915.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the Simla deputation of 1 October 1906 and its demands.
- State the objectives of the All India Muslim League as the book lists them.
- Explain separate electorates under the Minto-Morley Reforms of 1909, and the founding and early character of the All India Hindu Mahasabha.
Sections 6.2 and 6.3 of the textbook describe how communal politics took organised form. Political parties based on religion appeared, and the British wrote separate representation by religion into the constitution.
The Simla deputation, 1906
On 1 October 1906 a delegation of 35 Muslim nobles, aristocrats, lawyers and other elite members, mostly linked to the Aligarh movement, met the Viceroy Lord Minto at Simla under the leadership of the Aga Khan. They asked for representation of Muslims in government jobs in proportion to their numbers, for Muslim judges in the High Courts and for Muslim members in the Viceroy's council. The book says the deputation won no firm promise, but it acted as a catalyst for founding the All India Muslim League (AIML) to protect Muslim interests.
The All India Muslim League
The textbook dates the League to 1907 (most histories give its founding session as December 1906 at Dacca; check the date your teacher wants). Big zamindars, former Nawabs and retired officials were active in it. The League supported the partition of Bengal, demanded separate electorates for Muslims and pressed for safeguards in government service. The book calls it the first centrally organised political party only for Muslims, and lists its objectives.
- To promote among Indian Muslims loyalty to the British Government and to remove any misunderstanding about the government's intentions.
- To protect and advance the political rights and interests of Indian Muslims and to represent their needs respectfully to the government.
- To prevent the growth among Muslims of hostility towards other communities, without harming the first two aims.
At first, the book says, the League was an elitist body of urban Muslims, but British support helped it become accepted as the representative body of Indian Muslims. Within three years it had secured separate electorates, giving Muslims a separate constitutional identity. The book adds that the Lucknow Pact (1916) put an official seal on that separate political identity.
Separate electorates and the Minto-Morley Reforms, 1909
Under a separate (communal) electorate, only Muslim voters could vote for Muslim candidates. According to the textbook, the Minto-Morley Reforms of 1909 gave Muslims eight seats in the Imperial Legislative Council out of the 27 elected non-official members, and reserved seats in provincial councils: Madras 4, Bombay 4 and Bengal 5.
| Council | Seats reserved for Muslims |
|---|---|
| Imperial Legislative Council | 8 out of 27 elected non-officials |
| Madras provincial council | 4 |
| Bombay provincial council | 4 |
| Bengal provincial council | 5 |
The book calls separate electorates the main technique by which the British fostered communalism. As evidence of motive it cites a British officer's letter to Lady Minto praising the decision for keeping 62 million people from joining the 'seditious opposition'. In the book's judgement, writing divide and rule into a formal constitutional arrangement made the estrangement between Hindus and Muslims complete.
From the deputation to separate electorates
- Simla deputation 1 October 1906; 35 members led by the Aga Khan meet Lord Minto.
- Muslim League founded Dated 1907 in the textbook; aims include loyalty and Muslim rights.
- Minto-Morley Reforms 1909: separate electorates; 8 Muslim seats in the Imperial Council.
- Separate identity sealed The book says the Lucknow Pact (1916) confirmed it.
The All India Hindu Mahasabha, 1915
After the League's formation and the 1909 Act, a move to start a Hindu organisation grew. Following resolutions of the fifth Punjab Hindu Conference at Ambala and the sixth at Ferozepur, the first all-India conference of Hindus met at Haridwar in 1915, and the All India Hindu Mahasabha was formed there with its headquarters at Dehra Dun. Provincial Sabhas followed in the United Provinces (headquarters Allahabad), Bombay and Bihar; the book says those in Bombay and Bihar were not active and there was little response in Madras and Bengal.
The Mahasabha was mainly urban, strongest in the trading cities of north India such as Allahabad, Kanpur, Benares, Lucknow and Lahore. In the United Provinces and Bihar it was largely created by educated middle-class leaders who were also Congress activists. The book notes that the Khilafat movement gave a pause to separatist politics, and the Mahasabha ceased to function between 1920 and 1922.
Worked example 1: explaining a separate electorate
Imagine a made-up constituency with Muslim seats and general seats. Under a separate electorate, the Muslim seat is filled only by votes of Muslim electors, so a candidate needs to appeal only to voters of one religion. Step 1: describe the rule (only Muslims vote for Muslim candidates). Step 2: give the effect the book stresses - politicians had no need to win support across communities, which encouraged communal appeals. Step 3: add the book's figures for 1909 if the question asks for the reforms.
Worked example 2: ordering events
Put in order: Hindu Mahasabha at Haridwar; Simla deputation; Minto-Morley Reforms; Lucknow Pact. Step 1: Simla deputation, 1906. Step 2: Minto-Morley Reforms, 1909. Step 3: Hindu Mahasabha, 1915. Step 4: Lucknow Pact, 1916. Correct order: deputation, reforms, Mahasabha, Lucknow Pact.
Separate electorate: only Muslims could vote for Muslim candidates. The textbook calls it the main technique of the British for fostering communalism.
Key takeaways: the Simla deputation (1906) led to the Muslim League; the League's aims combined loyalty to the British with protection of Muslim rights; the 1909 Reforms introduced separate electorates (8 of 27 elected seats in the Imperial Council, by the book's figures); and the Hindu Mahasabha was founded at Haridwar in 1915, mainly urban and north Indian.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who led the Muslim deputation that met Lord Minto at Simla on 1 October 1906?
- Syed Ahmed Khan
- Muhammad Ali Jinnah
- Syed Ameer Ali
- The Aga Khan
Show answer
Answer: D. The book says the 35-member delegation was led by the Aga Khan. Syed Ahmed Khan had died in 1898, and Jinnah was then a Congressman.
-
2. Which of these was one of the Muslim League's original objectives, as the book lists them?
- Immediate independence from Britain
- Promoting loyalty among Muslims to the British Government
- Abolishing the partition of Bengal
- Joining the Congress
Show answer
Answer: B. The first objective was to promote loyalty to the British Government. The League supported, not opposed, the partition of Bengal.
-
3. Under the Minto-Morley Reforms, how many seats for Muslims does the book say there were in the Imperial Legislative Council?
- Five
- Twenty-seven
- Eight
- Four
Show answer
Answer: C. The book gives eight seats for Muslims out of the 27 non-official elected members. Four and five are provincial figures (Madras and Bombay 4 each, Bengal 5).
-
4. Where was the All India Hindu Mahasabha started in 1915, and where was its headquarters?
- Started at Haridwar; headquarters at Dehra Dun
- Started at Allahabad; headquarters at Lahore
- Started at Ambala; headquarters at Ferozepur
- Started at Varanasi; headquarters at Kanpur
Show answer
Answer: A. The first all-India conference of Hindus met at Haridwar in 1915 and set up the Mahasabha with headquarters at Dehra Dun. Ambala and Ferozepur hosted the earlier Punjab Hindu Conferences.
-
5. Assertion (A): The textbook calls separate electorates the main British technique for spreading communalism. Reason (R): Under them, voters were split by religion and voted only for candidates of their own community.
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are false
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
Show answer
Answer: C. Both are true and linked: because only Muslims voted for Muslim candidates, politics was organised by religion, which is why the book sees the system as fostering communalism.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.