• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

From the 1937 ministries to Direct Action Day

Explain the 1937 election results, the resignation of Congress ministries and the Day of Deliverance (1939), the Lahore resolution and the two-nation theory, the 1946 elections, the Cabinet Mission Plan and Direct Action Day.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the results of the 1937 elections as the book gives them and the book's view of the Congress as a mass secular party.
  • Explain the Day of Deliverance (22 December 1939), the Lahore resolution of 1940 and the origins of the Pakistan idea and two-nation theory.
  • Describe the Cabinet Mission Plan of 1946, Direct Action Day (16 August 1946) and how the book links them to partition.

Sections 6.4 to 6.6 of the textbook carry the story from the first Congress governments in the provinces to the decision to partition India. This lesson follows that sequence.

The first Congress ministries, 1937

The book presents Gandhi as the embodiment of the Congress's nationalism: he rejected the narrow nationalism it sees in the Arya Samaj and the Aligarh movement and worked for a political identity above religion. In the 1937 elections (held under the Government of India Act, 1935), the Congress won in seven of the eleven provinces and was the largest party in three others. The Muslim League did poorly, winning, according to the book, only 4.8 per cent of Muslim votes. The book concludes that the Congress had become a mass secular party, yet the government called it a Hindu body and treated the League as the true voice of Muslims, on a par with the Congress.

War and the Day of Deliverance, 1939

When the Second World War began in 1939, the Viceroy Linlithgow declared India at war without consulting Indian leaders. The Congress resented this, and its Working Committee asked all Congress ministries to resign; provincial governors then suspended the legislatures and took over administration. The Muslim League celebrated the end of Congress rule as a 'Day of Deliverance' on 22 December 1939, passing resolutions about alleged wrongs to Muslims under Congress rule. The book adds that nationalist Muslims who protested were denounced.

The Lahore resolution and the two-nation theory

In this atmosphere the League, meeting at Lahore, demanded a separate state for Muslims in March 1940. The textbook gives the resolution's date as 23 March 1940 in one place and as 26 March in another; the session is generally dated 22-24 March, with the resolution moved on 23 March and adopted on 24 March. Its key principle was that geographically contiguous areas where Muslims were in a majority should be grouped into independent states, and the League asked the British to divide the country into an Indian Union and Pakistan before leaving.

The book traces the idea back ten years. At the League's Allahabad session of 1930, the poet-scholar Muhammad Iqbal spoke of a consolidated Muslim state in north-west India; Rahmat Ali, a student at Cambridge, then argued for it forcefully. The two-nation theory, the book says, was first stated by Sir Wazir Hasan in his presidential address at the League's Bombay session of 1937, where he said Hindus and Muslims should be considered two nations. The book notes that at that stage neither Jinnah nor Nawab Zafrullah Khan thought a separate Muslim state practicable.

How the demand for Pakistan took shape (dates as in the textbook)

  1. 1930, Allahabad Iqbal speaks of a north-west Indian Muslim state.
  2. Rahmat Ali A Cambridge student argues for the idea forcefully.
  3. 1937, Bombay Sir Wazir Hasan states the two-nation theory.
  4. 22 December 1939 Day of Deliverance after Congress ministries resign.
  5. March 1940, Lahore League resolution for independent Muslim-majority states.

The 1940s: elections and the Cabinet Mission

The book says Hindu and Muslim communalism fed on each other in the early 1940s. The League openly boycotted the Quit India movement (1942). In the 1946 elections, the League won all 30 seats reserved for Muslims in the Central Legislative Assembly and most reserved provincial seats; the Congress won most general seats but could no longer effectively claim to speak for the whole population.

In 1946 a three-member Cabinet Mission led by the Secretary of State Pethick-Lawrence came to break the deadlock and transfer power to a single Indian administration; the book says Cripps mainly drafted the plan. It proposed a three-tier federation: a central government in Delhi limited to foreign affairs, communications, defence and the finances these needed; three groups of provinces with autonomy in all other matters; and the provinces themselves, which could opt out of their group if a majority of their people wished. Princely states were to be joined later to neighbouring provinces.

Groups of provinces in the Cabinet Mission Plan, 1946 (as listed in the textbook)
GroupProvincesMajority
ABombay, Madras, United Provinces, Bihar, Orissa, Central ProvincesHindu-majority
BPunjab, Sind, North-West Frontier, BaluchistanMuslim-majority
CBengal and AssamMuslim-majority Bengal with Hindu-majority Assam

Direct Action Day and the road to partition

Both Jinnah and the Congress leaders at first accepted the Cabinet Mission's proposal. But, the book says, after weeks of negotiation the League on 29 July 1946 rejected the plan and called on Muslims to observe 'Direct Action Day' on 16 August 1946. Rioting and killing in Calcutta went on for four days, and the book records thousands of deaths. Gandhi, who had resisted any division of the country, then had to agree to the creation of Pakistan, and Mountbatten, who succeeded Wavell, came as Viceroy to carry out partition and the transfer of power. In its summary, the textbook blames Jinnah's refusal to settle on the basis of the Cabinet Mission Plan and his call for Direct Action for a near civil-war situation in Calcutta, ending in partition. Its exercises also ask students to consider how Hindu, Muslim and Indian nationalism together contributed to the partition.

Worked example 1: a sequence question

Arrange: Cabinet Mission Plan; Day of Deliverance; Lahore resolution; Direct Action Day. Step 1: Day of Deliverance, 22 December 1939. Step 2: Lahore resolution, March 1940. Step 3: Cabinet Mission Plan, 1946 (before the League rejected it on 29 July). Step 4: Direct Action Day, 16 August 1946.

Worked example 2: placing a province

Question: In which group of the Cabinet Mission Plan was Assam, and why was this a problem? Step 1: Assam was in Group C with Bengal. Step 2: Assam was Hindu-majority while Bengal was Muslim-majority, so the larger Bengal could dominate the group. Step 3: the provision that a province could opt out was meant to answer such worries, as the book explains.

1937: Congress wins 7 of 11 provinces. 22 December 1939: Day of Deliverance. March 1940: Lahore resolution. 1946: Cabinet Mission Plan. 16 August 1946: Direct Action Day.

— Key dates of Unit 6, sections 6.4-6.6

Key takeaways: the 1937 results showed, in the book's view, that the Congress was a mass secular party; the war-time resignation of Congress ministries led to the Day of Deliverance; the Lahore resolution of 1940 grew from ideas voiced by Iqbal, Rahmat Ali and Wazir Hasan; the League's success in the 1946 elections, its rejection of the Cabinet Mission Plan and the Calcutta violence after Direct Action Day led, as the book tells it, to partition.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the 1937 elections, according to the textbook, the Congress won in:

    1. seven of the eleven provinces
    2. all eleven provinces
    3. five of the eleven provinces
    4. eight of the twelve provinces
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The book says the Congress won in seven of the eleven provinces and was the largest party in three others, while the League won only 4.8 per cent of Muslim votes.

  2. 2. Why did the Congress ministries resign in 1939?

    1. They lost a vote in the legislatures
    2. The Muslim League demanded it
    3. The Viceroy declared India at war without consulting Indian leaders
    4. Gandhi began the Quit India movement
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Linlithgow announced that India was at war without consultation. The Congress resented it and its Working Committee asked its ministries to resign. Quit India came later, in 1942.

  3. 3. Who, according to the book, first stated the two-nation theory, at the League's Bombay session of 1937?

    1. Muhammad Iqbal
    2. Rahmat Ali
    3. Muhammad Ali Jinnah
    4. Sir Wazir Hasan
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book credits Sir Wazir Hasan's presidential address at Bombay in 1937. Iqbal spoke of a north-west Muslim state at Allahabad in 1930, and Rahmat Ali promoted the idea afterwards.

  4. 4. Which subjects were to be handled by the central government under the Cabinet Mission Plan?

    1. Education, health and police
    2. Foreign affairs, communications and defence, with the finances they needed
    3. All subjects except religion
    4. Only defence
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The plan limited the centre to foreign affairs, communications and defence and the finances required for these; groups of provinces were to be autonomous in everything else.

  5. 5. On what date did the Muslim League observe Direct Action Day?

    1. 22 December 1939
    2. 29 July 1946
    3. 16 August 1946
    4. 23 March 1940
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The League rejected the Cabinet Mission Plan on 29 July 1946 and called for Direct Action Day on 16 August 1946, followed by four days of violence in Calcutta.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery