Revision notes

Unit 6 Communalism in Nationalist Politics: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

The background: religion, revival and divide and rule

The background as the textbook describes it

  1. Mughal rule Persian the court language; many officials and landlords were Muslims.
  2. British administration A new system of government; English education dominant by the mid-1800s.
  3. Revolt of 1857 suppressed The book says many Muslims lost land, jobs and opportunities.
  4. Withdrawal and resentment Distance from the British; rivalry with Hindus in new professions.
  5. British use of the divide The Muslim middle class seen as a check on the Congress.
Three strands of religion in politics in this lesson
StrandOrganisations or people the book namesWhat it stressed
Hindu revivalismArya Samaj (1875), Annie BesantRevival and pride in ancient Hindu religion as the base of the nation
Muslim consciousnessAligarh movement, Syed Ahmed Khan, WahabisA separate Muslim political voice; purity of Islam
Colonial policyBritish government, Elphinstone's viewKeeping communities apart to prevent unity

Communalism, in the book's sense, means grouping people politically by religion. The book traces it to religious revival, to the changed fortunes of communities under colonial rule, and to the British policy of divide and rule.

— Summary of Unit 6, section 6.1

Key takeaways: the book links the decline of the older ruling class after 1857 to Muslim withdrawal and resentment; Hindu revivalism spoke through the Arya Samaj (1875) and Besant; Muslim consciousness grew through the Aligarh movement, the Wahabis and the language order of the 1870s; and the book sees the British policy of divide and rule as feeding all of this.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Congress, Syed Ahmed Khan and communal politics before 1906

Two Muslim responses to the early Congress

  • Followed Syed Ahmed Khan
    • Feared rule by a Hindu majority
    • Worried about open competition for posts
    • Chose cooperation with the British
    • Described the Congress as a Hindu body
  • Supported the Congress
    • Badruddin Tyabji, Rahmatullah Sayani (Bombay)
    • Nawab Syed Mohammed Bahadur (Madras)
    • A. Rasul (Bengal)
    • Saw common grievances against colonial rule

How communal feeling spread before 1906 (as the book explains)

  • Leaders' choices
    • Syed Ahmed Khan's turn to the British
    • Congress described as a Hindu body
  • Working of new institutions
    • Patronage in municipal boards from the 1880s
    • Rivalry for control of local bodies
  • Religion in mass politics
    • Religious festivals and symbols in agitation
    • Tilak's Ganapati festival
  • Congress response
    • Silence towards communal elements
    • Nationalist Muslims discouraged

The book's view of this period: the Congress leadership was secular, but leaders on all sides used religion in politics, local body rivalries hardened divisions, and the Congress's silence towards communal elements discouraged nationalist Muslims.

— Summary of Unit 6, section 6.1 (d)-(g)

Key takeaways: the Congress (1885) tried to stand above religion; Syed Ahmed Khan chose cooperation with the British, while leaders such as Tyabji, Sayani, Syed Mohammed Bahadur and Rasul backed the Congress; municipal patronage from the 1880s communalised local politics; and the book criticises both the use of religious symbols in agitation and the Congress's weak response.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

The Muslim League, separate electorates and the Hindu Mahasabha

Seats for Muslims under the 1909 Reforms, as given in the textbook
CouncilSeats reserved for Muslims
Imperial Legislative Council8 out of 27 elected non-officials
Madras provincial council4
Bombay provincial council4
Bengal provincial council5

From the deputation to separate electorates

  1. Simla deputation 1 October 1906; 35 members led by the Aga Khan meet Lord Minto.
  2. Muslim League founded Dated 1907 in the textbook; aims include loyalty and Muslim rights.
  3. Minto-Morley Reforms 1909: separate electorates; 8 Muslim seats in the Imperial Council.
  4. Separate identity sealed The book says the Lucknow Pact (1916) confirmed it.

Separate electorate: only Muslims could vote for Muslim candidates. The textbook calls it the main technique of the British for fostering communalism.

— Unit 6, section 6.2

Key takeaways: the Simla deputation (1906) led to the Muslim League; the League's aims combined loyalty to the British with protection of Muslim rights; the 1909 Reforms introduced separate electorates (8 of 27 elected seats in the Imperial Council, by the book's figures); and the Hindu Mahasabha was founded at Haridwar in 1915, mainly urban and north Indian.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The 1920s: Khilafat, Malabar, unity efforts and the Communal Award

Delegates at the Hindu Mahasabha's Varanasi conference, August 1923 (figures from the textbook)
RegionShare of the 968 delegates
United Provinces alone56.7%
UP, Punjab, Delhi and Bihar together86.8%
Madras, Bombay and Bengal together6.6%

The four Delhi proposals of 20 March 1927

  • Sind Separate Sind from the Bombay Presidency.
  • Frontier and Baluchistan Introduce reforms there.
  • Punjab and Bengal Representation according to population.
  • Central Legislature Thirty-three per cent of seats for Muslims.
Offered in return for giving up separate electorates

After 1922 the unity of the Khilafat years broke down; the Delhi proposals (1927) offered a way out, but, as the book tells it, they fell through and the 1928 convention ended hopes of agreement.

— Summary of Unit 6, sections 6.3 (a)-(d)

Key takeaways: Khilafat united communities but also brought religion into mass politics; the book calls the Malabar rebellion basically agrarian with high communal passion; the Mahasabha was strongest in UP and Punjab; the 1927 Delhi proposals and the 1928 convention failed; the Communal Award and the growth of Hindu Rashtra ideas hardened divisions in the 1930s.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

From the 1937 ministries to Direct Action Day

How the demand for Pakistan took shape (dates as in the textbook)

  1. 1930, Allahabad Iqbal speaks of a north-west Indian Muslim state.
  2. Rahmat Ali A Cambridge student argues for the idea forcefully.
  3. 1937, Bombay Sir Wazir Hasan states the two-nation theory.
  4. 22 December 1939 Day of Deliverance after Congress ministries resign.
  5. March 1940, Lahore League resolution for independent Muslim-majority states.
Groups of provinces in the Cabinet Mission Plan, 1946 (as listed in the textbook)
GroupProvincesMajority
ABombay, Madras, United Provinces, Bihar, Orissa, Central ProvincesHindu-majority
BPunjab, Sind, North-West Frontier, BaluchistanMuslim-majority
CBengal and AssamMuslim-majority Bengal with Hindu-majority Assam

1937: Congress wins 7 of 11 provinces. 22 December 1939: Day of Deliverance. March 1940: Lahore resolution. 1946: Cabinet Mission Plan. 16 August 1946: Direct Action Day.

— Key dates of Unit 6, sections 6.4-6.6

Key takeaways: the 1937 results showed, in the book's view, that the Congress was a mass secular party; the war-time resignation of Congress ministries led to the Day of Deliverance; the Lahore resolution of 1940 grew from ideas voiced by Iqbal, Rahmat Ali and Wazir Hasan; the League's success in the 1946 elections, its rejection of the Cabinet Mission Plan and the Calcutta violence after Direct Action Day led, as the book tells it, to partition.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery