- Practice
- About 25 min
- 5 practice questions
Speed of light, refractive index, Snell's law and apparent depth
Explain Fizeau's toothed-wheel method, define refractive index and optical path, apply Snell's law and the rules of relative refractive index, and derive the apparent depth d′ = d/n.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe Fizeau's toothed-wheel method and derive v = 2dNω/π.
- Define refractive index n = c/v and optical path d′ = nd.
- State the laws of refraction in ratio and product form and find the angle of deviation.
- Use the principle of reversibility, the inverse rule and the chain rule for relative refractive index.
- Derive the apparent depth d′ = d/n and explain atmospheric refraction and twinkling of stars.
Light travels fastest in vacuum: c = 3 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹. In any material it is slower, and that change of speed at a boundary is what bends light. This lesson starts with how the speed of light was first measured on the Earth and then builds the laws of refraction.
Fizeau's method
Apparatus. Light from a source S falls on a partially silvered glass plate set at 45°, which turns it towards a toothed wheel having N teeth and N gaps (cuts) of equal width. Light passing through a gap travels a long distance d (Fizeau used about 8 km) to a mirror, reflects, and comes back to the wheel. If the wheel is still, the returning light passes through the same gap and the observer behind the glass plate sees it.
Working. The wheel's angular speed is raised from zero until, at ω, the light disappears for the first time: in the time t the light takes to go and return, the wheel has turned so that the next tooth now blocks the gap. Derivation. Speed v = 2d/t. The wheel has 2N equal parts (N teeth plus N gaps) in 2π radian, so the angle from a gap to the next tooth is θ = 2π/2N = π/N. Since ω = θ/t, t = π/(Nω). Substituting: v = 2dNω/π. If ω is doubled, the returning light reaches the next gap and is seen again; it vanishes again at 3ω, and so on. Fizeau's result was close to the modern value; later refined experiments gave the speed in air as about 2.99792 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹, practically equal to c.
Path of light in Fizeau's experiment
- Source Light falls on a half-silvered plate at 45°.
- Gap in the wheel Light passes through one cut of the rotating wheel.
- Distant mirror Travels distance d and is reflected back (total 2d).
- Next tooth At angular speed ω the returning light meets a tooth and is blocked.
- Observer Sees the light vanish; v = 2dNω/π.
Refractive index and optical path
Foucault and Michelson placed water, glass and evacuated tubes in the light path and found light always slower in a medium than in vacuum. The refractive index of a medium is n = (speed of light in vacuum)/(speed of light in the medium) = c/v. It has no unit. For vacuum n = 1, for every other medium n > 1, and the higher n is, the slower light travels; n is also called the optical density (not to be confused with mass density). According to the textbook, typical values are air 1.0003, ice 1.31, pure water 1.33, glass about 1.52 and diamond 2.42.
Optical path. In the time t that light takes to cross a thickness d of a medium (t = d/v), it would cover a longer distance d′ in vacuum (t = d′/c). Equating the times, d′/c = d/v, so d′ = (c/v)d, that is d′ = nd. Optical path is always larger than the geometric thickness.
Worked example 1: speeds, times and optical path
(a) Speed of light in diamond (n = 2.42): v = c/n = 3 × 10⁸/2.42 = 1.24 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹. (b) Light crosses a 30 cm layer of water (n = 1.33). Speed v = 3 × 10⁸/1.33 = 2.26 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹. Time t = d/v = 0.30/(2.26 × 10⁸) = 1.33 × 10⁻⁹ s. Optical path d′ = nd = 1.33 × 30 = 39.9 cm, so in the same time light would go about 9.9 cm further in vacuum. (c) In a Fizeau set-up (made-up data) with N = 500, d = 9.00 km and first darkness at ω = 105 rad s⁻¹: v = 2 × 9000 × 500 × 105/π = 9.45 × 10⁸/3.142 = 3.01 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹.
Refraction and Snell's law
Refraction is the passage of light from one medium into another across a boundary. The laws are: (i) the incident ray, refracted ray and normal are coplanar; (ii) sin i/sin r = n₂/n₁ (ratio form), or n₁ sin i = n₂ sin r (product form), where n₁ is the index of the medium of incidence. This is Snell's law. At normal incidence i = 0 and the ray goes straight through.
Angle of deviation by refraction. Going from a rarer to a denser medium (n₁ < n₂) the ray bends towards the normal and d = i − r. Going from denser to rarer it bends away from the normal and d = r − i. At every refracting surface some light is also reflected (simultaneous reflection and refraction), so the refracted beam is weaker than the incident one; specially coated glass (the 'two-way' or half-silvered mirror) uses this. The principle of reversibility: if a ray's direction is reversed, it retraces exactly the same path, in reflection and in refraction.
Relative refractive index. The ratio n₂/n₁ is the refractive index of medium 2 with respect to medium 1, written n₂₁. Two rules follow. Inverse rule: n₁₂ = 1/n₂₁. Chain rule: n₃₂ = n₃₁ × n₁₂, since (n₃/n₁)(n₁/n₂) = n₃/n₂.
Worked example 2: Snell's law and relative index
(a) A ray in air meets glass (n = 1.5) at i = 45°. sin r = sin 45°/1.5 = 0.7071/1.5 = 0.4714, so r = 28.1°. It bends towards the normal; deviation d = i − r = 45° − 28.1° = 16.9°. (b) For water (1.33) and glass (1.5): refractive index of glass with respect to water n_gw = 1.5/1.33 = 1.13; by the inverse rule, of water with respect to glass n_wg = 1/1.13 = 0.887. (c) Chain rule check: n_gw = n_ga × n_aw = 1.5 × (1/1.33) = 1.13. ✓
Apparent depth
The bottom of a tank of water looks raised. Light from a point O on the bottom goes from water (n₁) into air (n₂, with n₁ > n₂) at B on the surface and bends away from the normal; extended back, the refracted ray meets the vertical through O at I, the image. Let D be the point on the surface directly above O, the angle of incidence be i and of refraction r. Viewing near the normal makes both angles small, so in n₁ sin i = n₂ sin r we may write tan for sin: n₁ tan i = n₂ tan r. From the triangles, tan i = DB/DO and tan r = DB/DI. Hence n₁ DB/DO = n₂ DB/DI; cancelling DB, with DO = real depth d and DI = apparent depth d′: n₁/d = n₂/d′, so d′ = (n₂/n₁)d. Seen from air (n₂ = 1, n₁ = n): d′ = d/n. The bottom seems raised by d − d′ = d(1 − 1/n). For several layers seen from above, add the apparent thickness of each: d′ = d₁/n₁ + d₂/n₂ + ...
n = c/v; d′ = nd (optical path); n₁ sin i = n₂ sin r; n₁₂ = 1/n₂₁; n₃₂ = n₃₁ × n₁₂; apparent depth d′ = d/n, raise = d(1 − 1/n); v = 2dNω/π.
Worked example 3: a pond and a layered tank
(a) A pond 2.0 m deep (n = 4/3) is viewed from above. Apparent depth d′ = 2.0/(4/3) = 1.5 m; the bottom seems raised by 0.5 m. Wading into a pond that 'looks' shallow is therefore risky. (b) A tank holds 6.0 cm of glass-like liquid (n = 1.5) floating on 8.0 cm of water (n = 4/3). Apparent depth of the bottom = 6.0/1.5 + 8.0/(4/3) = 4.0 + 6.0 = 10.0 cm, though the real depth is 14.0 cm.
Atmospheric refraction
The atmosphere is made of layers whose refractive index changes with height, so starlight and sunlight bend gradually as they pass through it. The Sun is seen a little before it actually crosses the horizon at sunrise and a little after it crosses at sunset; the textbook gives the apparent shift as about half a degree, about 2 minutes of time. The same bending flattens the Sun into an oval near the horizon. Stars do not really twinkle: moving layers of air with changing refractive index make their apparent position and brightness flicker.
Key takeaways
- Fizeau: v = 2dNω/π, using the first disappearance of light at angular speed ω.
- n = c/v > 1 for every medium; optical path d′ = nd.
- Snell's law n₁ sin i = n₂ sin r; deviation i − r (into denser) or r − i (into rarer).
- Relative index n₂₁ = n₂/n₁; inverse rule and chain rule follow.
- Apparent depth d′ = d/n for viewing from air near the normal; layers add as d/n terms.
Check your understanding
-
1. The speed of light in a medium is 2.0 × 10⁸ m s⁻¹. Its refractive index is:
- 0.67
- 1.5
- 2.0
- 6.0
Show answer
Answer: B. n = c/v = (3 × 10⁸)/(2.0 × 10⁸) = 1.5.
-
2. In Fizeau's method the angle through which the wheel turns between a gap and the next tooth, for a wheel with N teeth and N equal gaps, is:
- 2π/N
- π/2N
- N/π
- π/N
Show answer
Answer: D. The circle (2π rad) is divided into 2N equal parts, so one part is 2π/2N = π/N. This gives t = π/(Nω) and v = 2dNω/π.
-
3. The refractive index of glass with respect to water is 9/8 and that of water with respect to air is 4/3. The refractive index of glass with respect to air is:
- 1.5
- 1.19
- 0.84
- 2.46
Show answer
Answer: A. Chain rule: n_ga = n_gw × n_wa = (9/8) × (4/3) = 36/24 = 1.5.
-
4. A coin lies at the bottom of a beaker containing 12 cm of liquid of refractive index 1.6. Seen from above, the coin appears raised by:
- 7.5 cm
- 19.2 cm
- 4.5 cm
- 12 cm
Show answer
Answer: C. Apparent depth d′ = d/n = 12/1.6 = 7.5 cm, so the raise = 12 − 7.5 = 4.5 cm. Or d(1 − 1/n) = 12 × (1 − 0.625) = 4.5 cm.
-
5. A slab of glass (n = 1.5) is 4.0 cm thick. Its optical path is:
- 2.7 cm
- 4.0 cm
- 5.5 cm
- 6.0 cm
Show answer
Answer: D. Optical path d′ = nd = 1.5 × 4.0 = 6.0 cm: in the time light crosses the slab it would travel 6.0 cm in vacuum.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.