• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Distribution of legislative powers and amending the Constitution

Explain the Union, State and Concurrent Lists of the Seventh Schedule, and the three ways the Constitution is amended under Article 368: by simple majority, by special majority, and by special majority with ratification by half the states.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the three lists of the Seventh Schedule with examples.
  • State who prevails in a conflict and who holds residuary power.
  • Describe the procedure of Article 368 and the meaning of special majority.
  • Classify provisions by the type of amendment they need.

India is a federation, so the power to make laws is divided between Parliament and the state legislatures. And because the Constitution must change with the times without losing its basic structure, it also lays down how it can be amended. This lesson covers both.

The Seventh Schedule: three lists

The Seventh Schedule divides legislative subjects three ways:

  • Union List: Parliament alone may make laws on these.
  • State List: the state legislature alone (in normal times) may make laws on these.
  • Concurrent List: both Parliament and the states may make laws. If a Union law and a state law conflict, the Union law prevails.

Subjects that appear in none of the lists are residuary powers, and these belong to the Centre.

Examples of subjects in the three lists, as given in the textbook
Union ListState ListConcurrent List
DefenceAgricultureEducation
Atomic energyPoliceTransfer of property other than agricultural land
Foreign affairsPrisonsForests
War and peaceLocal governmentTrade unions
BankingPublic healthAdulteration
RailwaysLandAdoption and succession
Post and telegraphLiquor-
Airways and portsTrade and commerce within the state-
Foreign tradeLivestock and animal husbandry-
Currency and coinageState public services-

Amending the Constitution: Article 368

Article 368 gives Parliament the power to amend the Constitution by way of addition, variation or repeal of any provision, following the procedure the Article lays down, but without changing its basic structure. The procedure:

  1. An amendment begins with a bill in either House of Parliament (not in a state legislature).
  2. Each House must pass it separately by a special majority: a majority of the total membership of the House and a majority of not less than two-thirds of the members present and voting.
  3. There is no joint sitting if the Houses disagree.
  4. If the bill affects the federal provisions, it must also be ratified by the legislatures of half of the states by a simple majority. No time limit is set for the states.
  5. The President must give assent; he or she can neither withhold assent nor return the bill. The bill then becomes a Constitutional Amendment Act.

'Total membership' counts every seat, whether or not some are vacant or members are absent.

Three types of amendment

TypeMajority neededExamples from the textbook
Simple majority of ParliamentAs for an ordinary lawAdmission or formation of states and changes in their areas, boundaries or names; creating or abolishing state Legislative Councils; Second Schedule emoluments; quorum, salaries, rules and privileges of Parliament; number of Supreme Court judges and more jurisdiction for it; use of English and official languages; citizenship; elections and delimitation; union territories; Fifth and Sixth Schedules
Special majority of ParliamentMajority of total membership and two-thirds of those present and voting, in each HouseFundamental Rights, Directive Principles, and every provision not in the other two groups
Special majority plus ratification by half the statesAs above, plus a simple majority in half the state legislaturesElection of the President and its manner; extent of Union and state executive power; Supreme Court and High Courts; distribution of legislative powers; any list in the Seventh Schedule; representation of states in Parliament; Article 368 itself

A point of precision: the textbook lists simple-majority changes under Article 368, but the Constitution itself provides that such changes are made by ordinary laws and are not treated as amendments under Article 368. They are usually still counted as one of the three ways of changing the Constitution.

Ways of amending the Constitution

  • Simple majority
    • Ordinary law-making
    • New states, names, boundaries
    • Quorum, salaries of MPs
  • Special majority
    • Each House separately
    • Fundamental Rights
    • Directive Principles
  • Special majority + half the states
    • Federal provisions
    • Election of President
    • Seventh Schedule lists

Special majority = more than half of the total membership AND at least two-thirds of those present and voting, in each House separately. Federal provisions also need half the states.

Worked example 1: does the amendment pass?

A made-up House has 540 seats. On an amendment bill, 450 members are present and voting: 320 vote yes and 130 vote no. Working: (1) majority of total membership: more than 540 ÷ 2 = 270, so at least 271 yes votes are needed; 320 ≥ 271, satisfied. (2) two-thirds of those present and voting: 2/3 × 450 = 300; 320 ≥ 300, satisfied. Both conditions hold, so the bill passes in this House.

Worked example 2: a narrow failure

Same House of 540 seats. Now 420 are present and voting: 275 yes, 145 no. Working: (1) 275 ≥ 271, so the total-membership test is passed. (2) 2/3 × 420 = 280; 275 is less than 280, so the two-thirds test fails. The bill is defeated, even though most members present supported it.

Worked example 3: which procedure?

(a) Renaming a state. (b) Changing the Right to Freedom. (c) Moving a subject from the State List to the Union List. Working: (a) needs only a simple majority. (b) is a Fundamental Right, so a special majority. (c) changes the Seventh Schedule, a federal provision, so a special majority plus ratification by half the states.

Key takeaways: the Seventh Schedule divides subjects into the Union, State and Concurrent Lists; Union law prevails in a Concurrent List conflict, and residuary power lies with the Centre. Under Article 368, an amendment bill starts in Parliament, needs a special majority in each House separately with no joint sitting, needs half the states for federal matters, and the President must assent. Some provisions change by simple majority; most need a special majority.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which subject is in the Concurrent List?

    1. Defence
    2. Police
    3. Education
    4. Railways
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Education is in the Concurrent List, so both Parliament and the states can make laws on it. Defence and railways are Union List subjects; police is a State List subject.

  2. 2. In a conflict between a Union law and a state law on a Concurrent List subject, which prevails?

    1. The Union law
    2. The state law
    3. Whichever was passed later
    4. Neither, until the Supreme Court decides
    Show answer

    Answer: A. On Concurrent List subjects, the Union law prevails in a conflict. Residuary powers also lie with the Centre.

  3. 3. Which provision needs a special majority of Parliament AND ratification by half the states?

    1. Renaming a state
    2. Fundamental Rights
    3. The quorum of Parliament
    4. Representation of states in Parliament
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Representation of states in Parliament is a federal provision, so it also needs ratification by half the states. Renaming a state and the quorum need only a simple majority; Fundamental Rights need a special majority of Parliament alone.

  4. 4. A House has 500 seats. 300 members are present and voting on an amendment; 210 vote yes. Is the special majority met?

    1. No, because 210 is less than 251
    2. Yes, because 210 is at least 200 and at least 251
    3. Yes, because 210 is more than half of 300
    4. No, because only 300 members voted
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Two-thirds of 300 is 200, and 210 meets that. But a majority of the total membership of 500 needs at least 251 yes votes, and 210 is less than 251. One condition fails, so the special majority is not met.

  5. 5. What can the President do with a duly passed Constitution Amendment Bill?

    1. Return it for reconsideration
    2. Hold it for six months
    3. Must give assent
    4. Refer it to the states
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The President must assent to a duly passed Constitution Amendment Bill and can neither withhold assent nor return it. Ratification by the states, where needed, happens before it reaches the President.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery