- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Law-making in Parliament: bills, stages and assent
Follow an ordinary bill through first reading, second reading, committee and report stages and third reading, understand joint sittings and the President's assent, and contrast ordinary bills, Money Bills and private members' bills.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe each stage an ordinary bill passes through.
- Explain what happens when the two Houses disagree, and the President's options on a bill.
- Distinguish an ordinary bill from a Money Bill.
- Explain what a private member's bill is.
A law starts life as a bill, a proposal placed before the legislature. The procedure is long on purpose: each stage gives members, and through them the public, a chance to examine it. The textbook stresses that the opposition's scrutiny at these stages is part of what makes the process democratic.
Two kinds of bills
Parliament passes (1) Money Bills and (2) non-Money Bills, also called ordinary or public bills. A bill becomes an Act only after both Houses pass it and the President assents. An ordinary bill may be introduced in either House.
Stages of an ordinary bill
Life of an ordinary bill
- First reading Bill introduced; usually no discussion
- Publication Printed in the Gazette of India
- Second reading Consider at once, select committee, joint committee, or circulate for opinion
- Committee stage Committee studies the bill and reports
- Report stage Bill debated clause by clause and given its final shape
- Third reading Passed by majority vote
- Other House Goes through all the stages again
- President's assent Bill becomes an Act
- First reading (introduction): most bills are introduced by the minister concerned, after experts draft them and the Council of Ministers approves. A member who is not a minister may introduce a private member's bill, giving one month's notice to the Speaker or Chairman. There is generally no discussion; it is a formal stage.
- Publication: the bill is published in the Gazette of India. The presiding officer may allow a bill to be published even before introduction, in which case no motion for leave to introduce it is needed.
- Second reading: usually at least two days later. The House may (1) take the bill into consideration at once, (2) send it to a select committee of the House, (3) send it to a joint committee of both Houses, or (4) circulate it for public opinion, in which case state governments publish it in their gazettes and invite views from local bodies and associations. Taking a bill up straight away is rare.
- Committee stage: for a select committee, the mover proposes the members, and the presiding officer appoints the committee's chairman. The committee studies the bill and reports back.
- Report stage: the textbook calls this the most important stage. The report, the original bill and the committee's report are circulated, and the bill is debated clause by clause and given its final shape.
- Third reading: the bill is passed by a majority vote; this is formal approval.
- In the other House: the bill goes through all the stages again. That House may pass it, reject it, amend it in ways the first House will not accept, or not return it for six months. Any of the last three creates a deadlock.
Deadlock, joint sitting and assent
In a deadlock the President may summon a joint sitting. The Speaker, or in his or her absence the Deputy Speaker, presides, and the deadlock is resolved by majority vote. Once both Houses have passed the bill, it goes to the President, who may assent, withhold assent, or return it for reconsideration. If Parliament passes it again, with or without amendments, the President cannot withhold assent. A Money Bill cannot be returned for reconsideration.
Ordinary Bill and Money Bill
| Point | Ordinary Bill | Money Bill |
|---|---|---|
| Where introduced | Either House | Only the Lok Sabha |
| Who introduces | A minister or a private member | Only a minister |
| President's recommendation | Not needed | Needed before introduction |
| Rajya Sabha's power | Can amend or reject | Cannot amend or reject; returns it with or without recommendations |
| Maximum delay by Rajya Sabha | Six months | 14 days |
| Speaker's certificate | Not needed | Needed when sent to the Rajya Sabha |
| Joint sitting | Possible | Not possible |
| Defeat in the Lok Sabha | May lead to resignation if moved by a minister | Leads to resignation of the government |
| President | Can assent, reject or return | Can assent or reject, not return |
Private members' bills
A private member's bill is moved by any member who is not a minister, from the ruling side or the opposition. Time is set aside for private members' business on Fridays. Such a bill needs a month's notice; it may even be a Constitution Amendment Bill, but never a Money Bill. Its defeat does not affect the government. Very few become law: the textbook records that only fourteen private members' bills have been passed by Parliament, the last in 1970. It also notes a private member's bill on the rights of transgender persons, moved by a member from Tamil Nadu, which the Rajya Sabha passed on 24 April 2015, the first private member's bill that House had passed in 45 years.
Language of Parliament (Article 120): business is conducted in Hindi or English, but the presiding officer may let a member who knows neither speak in his or her mother tongue.
Stages: first reading, second reading, committee stage, report stage, third reading, then the other House and the President's assent. Money Bills: Lok Sabha only, minister only, President's recommendation, Rajya Sabha 14 days.
Worked example 1: what happens next?
A bill passed by the Lok Sabha on 1 March is still not returned by the Rajya Sabha on 15 September. Working: from 1 March to 1 September is six months, so by 15 September more than six months have passed. A deadlock exists, and the President may summon a joint sitting. If the bill were a Money Bill, the Rajya Sabha would have had only 14 days; after that it would be deemed passed by both Houses.
Worked example 2: the President returns a bill
The President returns an ordinary bill for reconsideration. Parliament passes it again without change. Working: once a returned bill is passed again, with or without amendments, the President must assent. The power to return a bill is therefore a power to delay and ask for second thoughts, not a final veto.
Key takeaways: a bill passes through first reading, publication, second reading, committee and report stages and third reading in each House, then needs the President's assent. Deadlocks on ordinary bills can be settled by a joint sitting presided over by the Speaker. A Money Bill starts only in the Lok Sabha on a minister's motion and the President's recommendation, and the Rajya Sabha can hold it only 14 days. Private members' bills are rarely passed.
Check your understanding
-
1. At which stage, according to the textbook, is a bill debated clause by clause and given its final shape?
- First reading
- Publication in the Gazette
- Third reading
- Report stage
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook describes the report stage as the most important stage, where the bill is debated clause by clause with the committee's report. The first reading is formal and the third reading is formal approval.
-
2. Which of these is NOT one of the four courses open at the second reading?
- Sending the bill directly to the President
- Sending it to a select committee
- Circulating it for public opinion
- Taking it into consideration at once
Show answer
Answer: A. At the second reading the House may consider the bill at once, send it to a select committee, send it to a joint committee or circulate it for public opinion. It cannot go to the President until both Houses pass it.
-
3. For how long can the Rajya Sabha hold a Money Bill?
- Six months
- 14 days
- 40 days
- Three months
Show answer
Answer: B. The Rajya Sabha must return a Money Bill within 14 days, with or without recommendations. It can hold an ordinary bill for up to six months.
-
4. A bill returned by the President is passed again by both Houses. What must the President do?
- Return it again
- Refer it to the Supreme Court
- Give assent
- Call a referendum
Show answer
Answer: C. If Parliament passes a returned bill again, with or without amendments, the President cannot withhold assent and must sign it.
-
5. Which statement about private members' bills is correct?
- They can be Money Bills
- Only opposition members can move them
- Their defeat forces the government to resign
- They need a month's notice and can include Constitution Amendment Bills
Show answer
Answer: D. Any non-minister, from the ruling side or the opposition, may move one with a month's notice. It may be a Constitution Amendment Bill but not a Money Bill, and its defeat does not affect the government.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.