• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Rajya Sabha and how its powers compare with the Lok Sabha

Describe the composition and election of the Rajya Sabha, its permanent character and membership rules, the privileges of members of Parliament, and where the Rajya Sabha is equal, unequal or special compared with the Lok Sabha.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the composition, term and method of election of the Rajya Sabha.
  • Explain why representation in the Rajya Sabha differs from the US Senate.
  • List the privileges of members of Parliament.
  • Classify the Rajya Sabha's powers as equal, unequal or special compared with the Lok Sabha.

Students often ask whether the Rajya Sabha matters if the Lok Sabha controls money and the government. This lesson answers by looking at what the Constitution lets each House do.

Composition and election

  • Maximum strength 250: up to 238 representatives of the states and union territories plus 12 members nominated by the President for their knowledge or experience of literature, science, art and social service. (The present strength, according to the textbook's questions, is 245.)
  • It was first constituted on 3 April 1952.
  • Members from a state are elected by the elected members of that state's Legislative Assembly (MLAs), by proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote.
  • It is a permanent House: it is never dissolved. Members serve six years, and one-third retire every second year, so the House is renewed gradually.
  • The Vice-President of India is its ex-officio Chairman and presides over its proceedings.

The Rajya Sabha protects the rights and interests of the states, like the Senate in the USA, but there is an important difference. In the US Senate every state has equal representation whatever its size. In India, seats depend on population, as fixed in the Fourth Schedule: Uttar Pradesh, the most populous state, elects 31 members; Sikkim elects one; Tamil Nadu elects 18.

Who can be a member?

  • a citizen of India;
  • at least 30 years old;
  • an elector in a parliamentary constituency. Earlier, the Representation of the People Act, 1951 required the elector to be in the state from which he or she sought election; the Representation of the People (Amendment) Act, 2003 removed this residence requirement, so a person registered as an elector anywhere in India may contest.

Privileges of members of Parliament

  • freedom of speech in Parliament: no court case for anything said or any vote given in the House or its committees;
  • no court case over publication of reports, papers, votes or proceedings by the authority of either House;
  • courts may not inquire into the proceedings of Parliament;
  • no court case for a substantially true newspaper report of proceedings, unless made with malice;
  • freedom from arrest in civil cases during a session and for 40 days before and 40 days after it;
  • exemption from legal process and arrest within the precincts of the House (without the presiding officer's permission).

Comparing the two Houses

Rajya Sabha compared with the Lok Sabha

  • Equal powers
    • Ordinary and Constitution Amendment Bills
    • Election and impeachment of the President
    • Election and removal of the Vice-President
    • Approval of ordinances and emergencies
    • Removal of judges, CEC, CAG
  • Unequal (weaker)
    • Money Bill only in Lok Sabha
    • 14 days to return a Money Bill
    • Cannot vote on demands for grants
    • Cannot pass no-confidence motion
    • Speaker presides over joint sitting
  • Special powers
    • Article 249: law on a State List subject
    • Article 312: new All-India Service
    • Removal of Vice-President begins here

A few points need care. Ministers, including the Prime Minister, may belong to either House, but they are responsible only to the Lok Sabha. A Financial Bill that does not deal solely with Article 110 matters can also be introduced only in the Lok Sabha, but after that both Houses have equal power over it. Only the Lok Sabha can pass a resolution to discontinue a national emergency. In a joint sitting the larger Lok Sabha usually prevails, unless the ruling side's combined strength in both Houses is smaller than the opposition's.

The removal of the Vice-President must start in the Rajya Sabha, by a resolution passed by an effective majority of its members, which the Lok Sabha then agrees to by a simple majority.

The value of the Rajya Sabha

The textbook concludes that the Rajya Sabha is not as weak as the British House of Lords nor as strong as the American Senate. Except for money matters and control of the Council of Ministers, its powers are broadly equal to those of the Lok Sabha. Its usefulness lies in three things:

  • it checks hasty, defective or ill-considered laws by giving time for revision and second thought;
  • it brings in eminent experts and professionals who may not face direct elections (the 12 nominated members);
  • it keeps a federal balance, protecting the states' interests against undue interference by the Centre.

Rajya Sabha: at most 250 (238 + 12 nominated), permanent, six-year terms, one-third retire every two years, chaired by the Vice-President. Equal on most bills; weaker on money and ministers; special under Articles 249 and 312.

Worked example 1: classify the power

(a) Passing a Constitution Amendment Bill. (b) Voting on demands for grants. (c) Authorising Parliament to legislate on a State List subject. Working: (a) is an equal power: each House must pass the bill separately. (b) is unequal: only the Lok Sabha votes on demands for grants. (c) is a special power of the Rajya Sabha under Article 249.

Worked example 2: rotation of members

Question: in a made-up year, 240 members of the Rajya Sabha are elected members. About how many seats fall vacant at each biennial election? Working: one-third retire every second year: 240 ÷ 3 = 80. Over three such elections (six years) every elected seat comes up once, which matches the six-year term.

Key takeaways: the Rajya Sabha has at most 250 members (238 elected by MLAs through the single transferable vote, 12 nominated), is never dissolved and renews one-third of its members every two years. Seats follow population, unlike the US Senate. It is equal to the Lok Sabha in most law-making, weaker on money and control of ministers, and has special federal powers under Articles 249 and 312.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who is the ex-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha?

    1. The President
    2. The Vice-President
    3. The Speaker
    4. The Prime Minister
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Vice-President of India is the ex-officio Chairman of the Rajya Sabha and presides over its proceedings.

  2. 2. How many members does Tamil Nadu elect to the Rajya Sabha, according to the textbook?

    1. 31
    2. 39
    3. 12
    4. 18
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Fourth Schedule fixes each state's seats. Tamil Nadu elects 18 members; Uttar Pradesh elects 31 and Sikkim one. 12 is the number of members nominated by the President.

  3. 3. Under which Article can the Rajya Sabha authorise Parliament to make a law on a subject in the State List?

    1. Article 249
    2. Article 312
    3. Article 110
    4. Article 120
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 249 lets the Rajya Sabha, by resolution, authorise Parliament to legislate on a State List subject. Article 312 concerns new All-India Services, Article 110 defines Money Bills and Article 120 deals with languages in Parliament.

  4. 4. For how long are members of Parliament free from arrest in civil cases before and after a session?

    1. 14 days
    2. Six months
    3. 40 days
    4. One year
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Members are free from arrest in civil cases during a session and for 40 days before it begins and 40 days after it ends. The privilege does not cover criminal cases.

  5. 5. Why is representation in the Rajya Sabha different from that in the US Senate?

    1. The Rajya Sabha has no members from states
    2. Rajya Sabha seats are based on population, while every US state has equal seats in the Senate
    3. The Rajya Sabha is directly elected
    4. The Senate is nominated by the President
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In the US Senate every state has equal representation regardless of size. In India the Fourth Schedule allots Rajya Sabha seats by population, so Uttar Pradesh has 31 and Sikkim one.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery