• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

State legislature, Governor, Chief Minister and legislative committees

Describe the structure of state legislatures, the Governor's appointment, the Chief Minister's powers, the state council of ministers and cabinet, the Speaker and Deputy Speaker, and the main kinds of parliamentary committees.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Distinguish unicameral and bicameral state legislatures.
  • State how the Governor and the Chief Minister are appointed, and the Chief Minister's main functions.
  • Explain the collective responsibility of the state council of ministers.
  • Describe the Speaker's role and classify the committees of the legislature.

The state is the second tier of India's federal structure. Its government works much like the Union government, with a constitutional head (the Governor), a real executive (the Chief Minister and council of ministers) and an elected legislature. Tamil Nadu has a unicameral legislature: a Legislative Assembly only.

Structure of the state legislature

Part VI of the Constitution (Articles 152 to 237) deals with the states. A state legislature with only a Legislative Assembly is unicameral; one with a Legislative Assembly and a Legislative Council is bicameral. The state legislature's powers and functions are much like those of Parliament, within the state's sphere.

The Governor

  • The Governor is the constitutional head of the state. The executive power of the state is vested in the Governor, and all executive action is taken in the Governor's name.
  • Appointed by the President, for five years, but holds office during the pleasure of the President, and continues until a successor takes over.
  • Qualifications: a citizen of India, at least 35 years old, and not holding any office of profit.
  • The same person may be appointed more than once, and may be Governor of two or more states.

The Chief Minister

Under Article 164(1) the Governor appoints the Chief Minister, normally the leader of the majority party or coalition in the Assembly. The Chief Minister heads the cabinet and the council of ministers and is, in practice, the real executive head of the state. The main powers are:

  • ministry-making: recommends who will be ministers and their rank (cabinet minister, minister of state, deputy minister), allocates and changes portfolios, and may recommend removal of a minister;
  • presides over cabinet meetings and makes major policy decisions;
  • is the sole channel of communication between the council of ministers and the Governor, conveying all cabinet decisions on administration and legislation;
  • scrutinises papers, bills and resolutions to be placed before the legislature;
  • major appointments, made in theory by the Governor, are in practice made on the Chief Minister's advice.

Council of ministers and cabinet

Article 163(1) provides a council of ministers headed by the Chief Minister to aid and advise the Governor, except where the Constitution requires the Governor to act in his or her discretion. Other ministers are appointed by the Governor on the Chief Minister's advice. In law, ministers hold office during the Governor's pleasure; in practice, during the Chief Minister's, because the Governor acts on that advice. Ministers are individually responsible to the Chief Minister and collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly: they must speak with one voice.

The council has three ranks: cabinet ministers, ministers of state and deputy ministers. The cabinet, made up of the cabinet ministers and headed by the Chief Minister, takes decisions on behalf of the whole council, and every minister is bound by them.

How the state government is formed

  1. Assembly election Members elected from constituencies
  2. Majority leader Leader of the majority party or coalition
  3. Governor appoints Chief Minister Article 164(1)
  4. Ministers appointed By the Governor on the Chief Minister's advice
  5. Collective responsibility Council stays in office while it has the Assembly's confidence

Speaker and Deputy Speaker of the Assembly

  • The Speaker, elected by the MLAs, is the presiding officer. He or she conducts business in an orderly way, maintains decorum, allows members to ask questions and speak, interprets the Constitution, rules and precedents within the House, may adjourn or suspend sittings and suspend members who break the rules, and appoints the chairmen of all committees.
  • The Speaker must be neutral and impartial, and votes only to break a tie. Decisions on members' conduct and procedure are final and are not subject to judicial intervention in such matters.
  • The Deputy Speaker, also elected by the members, presides when the Speaker is absent. If both are absent, a member from the panel of presiding members takes the chair.

Committees of the legislature

Much detailed work is done in committees. They are of two kinds: standing committees, permanent and working continuously, and ad hoc committees, temporary and dissolved once their task is done (inquiry committees and advisory committees). The textbook groups standing committees into six categories:

CategoryExamples
Financial committeesPublic Accounts Committee, Estimates Committee, Committee on Public Undertakings
Departmental standing committees24 committees covering ministries and departments
Committees to inquirePetitions, Privileges, Ethics
Committees to scrutinise and controlGovernment Assurances, Subordinate Legislation, Papers Laid on the Table, Welfare of SCs and STs, Empowerment of Women, Joint Committee on Offices of Profit
Day-to-day businessBusiness Advisory, Private Members' Bills and Resolutions, Rules, Absence of Members
House-keeping (service)General Purposes, House, Library, Joint Committee on Salaries and Allowances
  • Estimates Committee: examines the estimates and suggests economies, alternative policies and administrative reforms; may tour to study schemes being carried out.
  • Public Accounts Committee: scrutinises the Appropriation Accounts and the reports of the Comptroller and Auditor-General, checking that money was spent on the purposes for which it was granted.
  • Committee on Public Undertakings: examines the accounts, audit reports, autonomy and efficiency of public undertakings and whether they are run on sound business principles.

The Governor is the constitutional head; the Chief Minister is the real executive. Ministers are collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly.

Worked example 1: who really decides?

A newspaper reports that 'the Governor has appointed a new Vice-Chancellor and allotted the finance portfolio to a minister'. Analysis: both acts are done in the Governor's name, because executive power is vested in the Governor. But under Article 163 the Governor acts on the aid and advice of the council of ministers, so in practice the Chief Minister chose the minister's portfolio and advised on the appointment (subject to any discretion the law gives the Governor).

Worked example 2: which committee?

(a) The CAG reports that money granted for school buildings was spent on vehicles. (b) A state-owned transport corporation is making heavy losses. (c) A member complains that a newspaper misreported his speech maliciously. Working: (a) goes to the Public Accounts Committee; (b) to the Committee on Public Undertakings; (c) is a question of privilege for the Committee of Privileges.

Key takeaways: state legislatures are unicameral or bicameral. The Governor, appointed by the President for five years during pleasure, is the constitutional head; the Chief Minister, appointed under Article 164(1), is the real executive and heads a council that aids and advises the Governor (Article 163(1)) and is collectively responsible to the Assembly. The Speaker presides impartially, with the Deputy Speaker and a panel as stand-ins. Standing and ad hoc committees, especially the financial committees, scrutinise government in detail.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who appoints the Governor of a state?

    1. The Chief Minister
    2. The Prime Minister
    3. The President
    4. The Chief Justice of the High Court
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Governor is appointed by the President and holds office during the President's pleasure, normally for five years.

  2. 2. Under which Article is there a council of ministers headed by the Chief Minister to aid and advise the Governor?

    1. Article 163(1)
    2. Article 164(1)
    3. Article 79
    4. Article 368
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 163(1) provides the council of ministers to aid and advise the Governor. Article 164(1) is about the Governor appointing the Chief Minister.

  3. 3. To whom is the state council of ministers collectively responsible?

    1. The Governor
    2. The President
    3. The High Court
    4. The Legislative Assembly
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The council of ministers is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly; ministers are individually responsible to the Chief Minister.

  4. 4. Which committee scrutinises the Appropriation Accounts and the reports of the Comptroller and Auditor-General?

    1. The Estimates Committee
    2. The Public Accounts Committee
    3. The Business Advisory Committee
    4. The Library Committee
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Public Accounts Committee examines the Appropriation Accounts and the CAG's reports to check that money was spent as granted.

  5. 5. Which statement about ad hoc committees is correct?

    1. They are permanent and elected every year
    2. They handle only Money Bills
    3. They are temporary and cease when their task is complete
    4. They are chaired by the Governor
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Ad hoc committees are temporary: inquiry and advisory committees set up for a task and dissolved when it is done. Standing committees are the permanent ones.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Legislature

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery