• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Centre-State relations: legislative, executive and financial

Explain the territorial and subject distribution of legislative power, the exceptions that let Parliament legislate on State subjects, executive relations and delegation, the distribution of tax and non-tax revenue, grants-in-aid and the Finance Commission.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the territorial and subject-wise distribution of legislative powers.
  • List the situations in which Parliament can legislate on State List subjects.
  • Describe executive relations, directions and delegation of functions.
  • Explain the distribution of tax and non-tax revenue and the role of the Finance Commission.

Centre-State relations revolve around the distribution of powers, which has three parts: legislative, executive and financial. India's scheme broadly follows the Government of India Act, 1935.

Legislative relations

Territorial distribution. Parliament may make laws for the whole territory of India, and its laws can even have extra-territorial effect, applying to Indian citizens and their property anywhere in the world. A state legislature makes laws only for its own territory.

Subject distribution. The Seventh Schedule has three lists. The textbook's counts and examples are:

ListCount (as the textbook gives)Examples
List I: Union List100 subjectsDefence, foreign affairs, banking, currency
List II: State List59 itemsPublic order, police, public health, local government, agriculture, fisheries
List III: Concurrent List52 itemsCriminal law and procedure, civil procedure, marriage, education, forests

The textbook also lists 'forests' among State List examples; forests were moved to the Concurrent List by the 42nd Amendment (1976), so they appear above in List III. In a clash on a Concurrent subject, the law of Parliament prevails, and residuary subjects belong to the Union.

When Parliament can legislate on State subjects

  • National emergency: while it lasts, Parliament can make laws on State List subjects, so as to meet war, external aggression or armed rebellion effectively.
  • Agreement between states: if two or more states request it, Parliament can make a common law on a State subject for those states.
  • International agreements: Parliament can legislate on a State subject to implement a treaty or agreement.
  • President's rule (Article 356): the President may declare that Parliament will make laws on State subjects for that state.
  • Rajya Sabha resolution (Article 249): in the national interest, as studied in Lesson 2.

Executive relations

  • Executive power broadly follows legislative power: the Union acts on Union List subjects across India; each state acts on State List subjects in its territory.
  • On Concurrent List subjects, executive power is ordinarily with the states, but the Union may issue directions to state governments, both in normal times and during emergencies.
  • Mutual delegation: the Union may entrust its functions to a state with the state's consent, and a state may entrust its functions to the Union with the Union's consent. Parliament may also, by law, entrust Union functions to a state even without the state's consent.

Financial relations

Finance is fundamental to a working federation. The Constitution divides tax revenue and non-tax revenue. The textbook describes five ways of sharing taxes:

CategoryTextbook's example
Levied by the Union onlyCorporation tax, customs duty
Levied by the states onlySales tax
Levied by the Union, collected and kept by the statesStamp duties on bills of exchange; certain excise duties
Levied and collected by the Union, assigned to the states where leviedTaxes on sale of advertisements in newspapers
Levied and collected by the Union, shared with the states in a set proportionTax on income other than agricultural income

Two later changes matter. Since the 80th Amendment (2000), most taxes levied by the Union go into a divisible pool shared with the states. Since 2017, the Goods and Services Tax (101st Amendment, 2016) has replaced sales tax on most goods and several older indirect taxes, and is shared between the Union and the states. Some of the textbook's examples therefore no longer apply.

Non-tax revenue: the Union earns from its undertakings, such as railways, posts and telegraphs and broadcasting; the states from forests, irrigation, electricity, road transport and their own enterprises. Under Article 275 the Union gives grants-in-aid to states in need, for example for the welfare and development of tribal people in states such as Assam.

The Finance Commission (Article 280)

  • Constituted by the President every five years.
  • Composition: a chairman with experience in public affairs and four other members, chosen for experience in financial administration, special knowledge of economics, or of public accounts and government finance, and one qualified to be a High Court judge.
  • Recommends: (1) distribution of the net proceeds of taxes between the Centre and the states; (2) principles for grants-in-aid; (3) measures to augment a state's Consolidated Fund to supplement the resources of panchayats and (4) of municipalities; (5) any other matter the President refers.

Three dimensions of Centre-State relations

  • Legislative
    • Territorial and subject distribution
    • Three lists, residuary to Centre
    • Exceptions: emergency, consent, treaties
  • Executive
    • Follows legislative power
    • Union directions
    • Mutual delegation
  • Financial
    • Tax and non-tax revenue
    • Grants-in-aid (Article 275)
    • Finance Commission (Article 280)

Parliament can enter the State List during a national emergency, at the request of two or more states, to implement treaties, under President's rule, and on a Rajya Sabha resolution (Article 249).

Worked example 1: may Parliament legislate?

(a) Tamil Nadu and Kerala jointly request a common law on a State subject. (b) India signs a treaty on wildlife trade needing action on a State subject. (c) In normal times, without any request, Parliament wants to pass a law on village police. Working: (a) yes, by agreement of the states, the law applies to those states; (b) yes, to implement an international agreement; (c) no, police is a State subject and none of the exceptions applies.

Worked example 2: dividing the divisible pool

Suppose, purely as an illustration, the Union collects ₹1,000 crore in taxes that go into the divisible pool, and a Finance Commission recommends that the states' share be 40 percent. Working: states' share = 40/100 × 1,000 = ₹400 crore; the Union keeps 1,000 − 400 = ₹600 crore. The Commission also recommends how the ₹400 crore is divided among individual states. (These figures are made up for practice.)

Key takeaways: Parliament legislates for all of India, even extra-territorially, and the states for their own territory; the three lists divide subjects, with the Union prevailing in conflicts and holding residuary power. Parliament may enter the State List in emergencies, on states' request, for treaties, under Article 356 and under Article 249. Executive power follows legislative power, with Union directions and mutual delegation. Revenue is shared in several ways (now through a divisible pool and GST), with grants under Article 275 and a Finance Commission every five years under Article 280.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What does the 'extra-territorial' jurisdiction of Parliament mean?

    1. Parliament can make laws for other countries
    2. State laws apply outside India
    3. Laws of Parliament can govern Indian citizens and their property anywhere in the world
    4. Parliament cannot legislate for union territories
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Parliament's laws can apply to Indian citizens and their property outside India. State legislatures have no jurisdiction beyond their territory.

  2. 2. Which is NOT a situation in which Parliament can legislate on a State List subject?

    1. During a national emergency
    2. When a single Union minister requests it
    3. When two or more states request it
    4. To implement an international agreement
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Parliament may legislate on a State subject during a national emergency, at the request of two or more states, to implement a treaty, under President's rule, or on a Rajya Sabha resolution under Article 249. A minister's request is not a ground.

  3. 3. Which Article provides for the Finance Commission?

    1. Article 280
    2. Article 275
    3. Article 148
    4. Article 263
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 280 provides for the Finance Commission, constituted every five years. Article 275 deals with grants-in-aid, 148 with the CAG and 263 with the Inter-State Council.

  4. 4. How many members does the Finance Commission have besides its chairman?

    1. Two
    2. Three
    3. Six
    4. Four
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Finance Commission has a chairman and four other members, including one qualified to be a High Court judge.

  5. 5. Under which Article does the Union give grants-in-aid to states in need, such as for tribal welfare?

    1. Article 249
    2. Article 312
    3. Article 275
    4. Article 356
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 275 provides for grants-in-aid to states in need of assistance, including for the welfare of Scheduled Tribes.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery