- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Unitary features: why India is called quasi-federal
Explain the non-federal features of the Indian Constitution: one constitution and citizenship, partial flexibility, Parliament's power over state boundaries, the Rajya Sabha's structure, a strong Centre, emergencies, integrated judiciary, single election machinery and unified audit.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the unitary features of the Indian Constitution with examples.
- Explain Articles 3 and 4 and the meaning of 'Territory of India'.
- Evaluate why India is called quasi-federal.
India has the features of a federation, but it also differs sharply from the classical federation of the United States. Many scholars therefore call India quasi-federal: federal in form, with a strong unitary bias. This lesson lists the features that give India a strong Centre.
Unitary or non-federal features
- Single constitution: one Constitution serves both the Centre and the states. In the USA, by contrast, each state has its own constitution as well as the national one.
- Single citizenship: there is only Indian citizenship, whereas Americans have both national and state citizenship.
- Partial flexibility: some provisions can be changed by a simple majority of Parliament.
- No right of states to existence: under Articles 3 and 4, Parliament can create new states, change boundaries or names, or abolish states by an ordinary law passed by a simple majority. The bill is introduced on the President's recommendation in either House. So India is described as an indestructible Union of destructible states.
- Rajya Sabha not based on equality: seats follow population: Uttar Pradesh has 31, smaller states such as Nagaland only one (Tamil Nadu has 18), unlike the US Senate's two seats for each state. Under Article 249 the Rajya Sabha can even let Parliament legislate on a State List subject in the national interest.
- Imbalanced distribution of powers: the Union List has more subjects, the Union law prevails in the Concurrent List, residuary powers lie with the Centre (in the USA they lie with the states), and the most lucrative sources of revenue belong to the Union, making states financially dependent.
- Emergency powers: Articles 352 to 360 in Part XVIII provide for national emergency (Article 352), emergency in a state (Article 356) and financial emergency (Article 360), during which the system can become virtually unitary.
- Integrated judiciary: one hierarchy of courts under the Supreme Court, unlike the separate federal and state courts of the USA.
- Single election machinery: the Election Commission conducts elections to both Parliament and the state legislatures; the Chief Electoral Officer of each state works under it. (The State Election Commissions conduct only local body elections under the 73rd and 74th Amendments.)
- Unified audit: the Comptroller and Auditor-General (Article 148) audits the accounts of both the Union and the states.
- All India Services (such as the IAS) are recruited by the Centre and serve in the states, as Lesson 5 discusses.
Union of States and Territory of India
Article 1 calls India a Union of States. The textbook distinguishes this from the Territory of India, which is wider. The Union of States means the states (the textbook counts 28) with the Central Government. The Territory of India includes (1) the states, (2) the union territories (eight, in the textbook's count), and (3) any territory acquired by India, such as Pondicherry or Daman and Diu in the period after they joined India and before they were made union territories.
India and the classical US federation
-
USA
- Separate state constitutions
- Dual citizenship
- Equal Senate seats
- Residuary powers with states
- Dual courts
-
India
- One Constitution
- Single citizenship
- Seats by population
- Residuary powers with the Centre
- Integrated judiciary
India: federal in form, unitary in spirit. Strong Centre through residuary powers, emergencies, Articles 3-4, Article 249, single citizenship, integrated courts and unified election and audit machinery.
Worked example 1: sort the features
Sort into federal or unitary: (a) two sets of governments with powers in written lists; (b) Parliament can rename a state by ordinary law; (c) the CAG audits state accounts; (d) Union-state disputes go to the Supreme Court. Working: (a) federal; (b) unitary (Articles 3 and 4); (c) unitary (unified audit); (d) federal (independent umpire).
Worked example 2: is India federal?
Question: a student must argue whether India is federal. Model reasoning: India has the essential federal features: a written, supreme Constitution, a division of powers in three lists, a bicameral Parliament and an independent Supreme Court. But it also has a strong Centre: one constitution and citizenship, residuary powers with the Union, Parliament's power over state boundaries and emergency powers. The fair conclusion is that India is quasi-federal, a federation with a strong unitary bias, able to act as a unitary state in an emergency.
Key takeaways: India departs from classical federalism through a single constitution and citizenship, partial flexibility, Parliament's power to reshape states (Articles 3 and 4), population-based Rajya Sabha seats and Article 249, a Union-heavy distribution of powers and revenue, emergency provisions (Part XVIII), an integrated judiciary, a single Election Commission and unified audit by the CAG. So it is called quasi-federal.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under which Articles can Parliament create new states and change their boundaries or names?
- Articles 249 and 250
- Articles 3 and 4
- Articles 352 and 356
- Articles 262 and 263
Show answer
Answer: B. Articles 3 and 4 let Parliament reorganise states by an ordinary law, on the President's recommendation. This shows states have no guaranteed right to existence.
-
2. Which body audits the accounts of both the Union and the state governments?
- The Finance Commission
- The Election Commission
- The Comptroller and Auditor-General
- The NITI Aayog
Show answer
Answer: C. The Comptroller and Auditor-General (Article 148) audits Union and state accounts: a unified audit system.
-
3. Which feature of the Indian Constitution is unitary rather than federal?
- Single citizenship
- Written Constitution
- Bicameral Parliament
- Supreme Court as umpire
Show answer
Answer: A. Single citizenship is a unitary feature. A written constitution, bicameralism and an independent umpire are federal features.
-
4. State Election Commissions conduct elections to:
- Parliament
- State Legislative Assemblies
- The office of President
- Panchayats and urban local bodies
Show answer
Answer: D. Under the 73rd and 74th Amendments, State Election Commissions conduct local body elections. The Election Commission of India conducts elections to Parliament and the state legislatures.
-
5. Where do residuary powers lie in India, and where in the USA?
- With the states in India and the Centre in the USA
- With the Centre in India and the states in the USA
- With the Centre in both
- With the states in both
Show answer
Answer: B. In India residuary powers belong to the Union, a unitary feature; in the USA they belong to the states.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.