- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Issues in Centre-State relations and the commissions that studied them
Explain the main issues in Indian federalism (Governor, education, reserved bills, Article 356, All India Services), the recommendations of the Administrative Reforms, Rajamannar, Sarkaria, Punchhi and Venkatachaliah commissions, and the S. R. Bommai judgment.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the main issues and demands in Centre-State relations.
- State the key recommendations of the Rajamannar Committee, the Sarkaria Commission and the Punchhi Commission.
- Describe the main points of the S. R. Bommai judgment on Article 356.
The balance between the Centre and the states has often been contested, and Tamil Nadu has been one of the strongest voices for state autonomy. The textbook calls C. N. Annadurai a champion of state rights. This lesson sets out the main issues, the commissions that studied them and the Supreme Court's response, presenting the arguments as the textbook describes them.
Main issues and demands
- Governor: critics see the office as an agent of the Centre that can be used to pressure state governments; the Rajamannar Committee was highly critical of it. Demands have included reducing the Governor's power to interfere with the state executive and legislature, not appointing politically active or partisan persons, and appointing Governors in consultation with the state government. The Governor's role becomes crucial, and often disputed, when a ruling party splits or an Assembly is hung.
- Education: the 42nd Amendment (1976) moved education from the State List to the Concurrent List, so the Union's law now prevails in a conflict. Many parties in states such as Tamil Nadu demand that it be returned to the State List.
- Reservation of state bills: the Governor may reserve a state bill for the President's consideration. The President may assent or withhold assent, and for a non-Money Bill may direct that it be reconsidered; even if the state legislature passes it again, the President is not obliged to assent. The provision was meant to protect national unity, but states have complained that it is used for political ends.
- Article 356: President's rule may be imposed on the Governor's report or otherwise. According to the textbook it has been used more than a hundred times, and states ruled by parties opposed to the Centre have complained of misuse; some demanded its abolition. Dr Ambedkar had expressed the hope that it would remain a dead letter, used rarely if ever.
- All India Services (Article 312): officers are recruited by the Union and serve in the states; states control postings and transfers, but only the Union can dismiss them, so states have sought changes.
Commissions on Centre-State relations
| Commission | Set up by / year | Key points |
|---|---|---|
| First Administrative Reforms Commission | Union, 1966 (chaired first by Morarji Desai, later K. Hanumanthaiya) | 20 reports, one with extensive suggestions on Centre-State relations; a Second ARC followed in 2005 |
| Rajamannar Committee | Tamil Nadu Government; report 1971 | Members: Dr P. V. Rajamannar (retired Chief Justice of Madras High Court), Dr A. Lakshmanaswami Mudaliar, Dr P. Chandra Reddy |
| Sarkaria Commission | Union, 1983; report 1988 with 247 recommendations | Justice R. S. Sarkaria with B. Sivaraman and Dr S. R. Sen |
| Punchhi Commission | Union, 2007; report 2010 | Justice Madan Mohan Punchhi, former Chief Justice of India |
| Venkatachaliah Commission (NCRWC) | Union, 2000 | National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution, under Justice M. N. Venkatachaliah |
Rajamannar Committee recommendations: (1) set up the Inter-State Council under Article 263, chaired by the Prime Minister with Chief Ministers as members, and make consultation with it compulsory on all major bills and decisions affecting states, except defence and foreign affairs; (2) delete Articles 256, 257 and 339(2), which let the Centre direct state governments; (3) transfer residuary powers of legislation and taxation to the states; (4) use Article 356 only as a last resort after a complete breakdown, not for a mere law-and-order problem; (5) abolish the All India Services, including the IAS; (6) greater financial devolution, changes in taxes such as corporation tax and customs, transfer of items from the Union and Concurrent Lists to the State List, and a permanent Finance Commission.
Sarkaria Commission recommendations: the Inter-State Council should have the functions in Article 263(b) and (c), not (a) (it should not inquire into disputes between states), with a permanent independent secretariat; Article 356 only as a last resort after exploring all alternatives; it rejected the demands to abolish the Governor's office or to require consultation with the state, but said Governors should be eminent persons, not politically active, and that a member of the Centre's ruling party should not be Governor of a state ruled by another party; and strict adherence to the three-language formula.
Punchhi Commission recommendations: Governors should have a fixed tenure and be removable only by an impeachment-like process; Articles 355 and 356 should allow localised emergency in a troubled district or area rather than the whole state; and the Union should be able to deploy central forces on its own in areas of communal violence, without the state's consent.
The S. R. Bommai judgment (1994)
In S. R. Bommai v Union of India, a case arising from the dismissal of the Karnataka government in 1989, the Supreme Court in 1994 limited the use of Article 356:
- Article 356 is an exceptional power, to be used only occasionally.
- It may be used only for a genuine constitutional breakdown, for example a hung Assembly where no party or coalition can form a majority, or a state government disregarding constitutional directions of the Union or actively assisting internal subversion.
- It may not be used for a mere law-and-order problem, or because the state's ruling party did badly in a Lok Sabha election.
- The Governor's report must be thorough and placed before Parliament.
- The state Assembly may not be dissolved until both Houses of Parliament approve the proclamation.
- The proclamation is subject to judicial review; if the grounds are unconstitutional, the court can set it aside and restore the dismissed government.
Rajamannar and Sarkaria on key issues
-
Rajamannar (1971)
- Residuary powers to states
- Abolish All India Services
- Delete Articles 256, 257, 339(2)
- Article 356 as last resort
-
Sarkaria (1988)
- Keep the Governor's office
- Governors: eminent, non-partisan
- Inter-State Council with permanent secretariat
- Article 356 as last resort
Bommai (1994): Article 356 is exceptional, judicially reviewable, not for law and order; the Assembly survives until Parliament approves; a wrongly dismissed government can be restored.
Worked example 1: is President's rule valid after Bommai?
(a) A state has riots in two districts and the Union proposes President's rule. (b) After an election no party or coalition can form a government. Working: (a) a law-and-order problem alone is not a constitutional breakdown, so President's rule would be open to challenge; the Punchhi Commission's idea of a localised emergency was aimed at such cases. (b) a hung Assembly with no possible government is a genuine breakdown, so President's rule can be justified, subject to judicial review.
Worked example 2: match the recommendation
(a) Abolish the IAS. (b) Governors should have a fixed tenure. (c) The Inter-State Council should not inquire into disputes between states. Working: (a) Rajamannar Committee; (b) Punchhi Commission; (c) Sarkaria Commission.
Key takeaways: issues in Indian federalism include the Governor's role, education in the Concurrent List, reservation of state bills, the use of Article 356 and Union control of All India Services. The Rajamannar Committee (Tamil Nadu, 1971) sought wide state autonomy; the Sarkaria Commission (1983-88) proposed reforms within the existing framework; the Punchhi Commission (2007-10) and the NCRWC (2000) followed. The Bommai judgment (1994) made President's rule exceptional and reviewable by the courts.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which body was set up by the Tamil Nadu Government to study Centre-State relations?
- The Sarkaria Commission
- The Punchhi Commission
- The Rajamannar Committee
- The Venkatachaliah Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. The Rajamannar Committee was set up by the Tamil Nadu Government and reported in 1971. The others were set up by the Union Government.
-
2. Which commission recommended the abolition of All India Services such as the IAS?
- The Rajamannar Committee
- The Sarkaria Commission
- The Punchhi Commission
- The First Administrative Reforms Commission
Show answer
Answer: A. The Rajamannar Committee recommended abolishing the All India Services, seeing them as against the spirit of federalism and state autonomy.
-
3. Which commission recommended fixed tenure for Governors and localised emergencies under Articles 355 and 356?
- The Sarkaria Commission
- The Rajamannar Committee
- The Venkatachaliah Commission
- The Punchhi Commission
Show answer
Answer: D. The Punchhi Commission (2007, report 2010) recommended fixed tenure and impeachment-like removal for Governors, and localised emergencies.
-
4. Which amendment moved education from the State List to the Concurrent List?
- The 44th Amendment
- The 42nd Amendment
- The 73rd Amendment
- The 86th Amendment
Show answer
Answer: B. The 42nd Amendment (1976) transferred education to the Concurrent List; many states, including Tamil Nadu, demand its return to the State List.
-
5. According to the Bommai judgment, which of these is a valid ground for President's rule?
- A mere law-and-order problem
- The state's ruling party losing heavily in a Lok Sabha election
- A hung Assembly where no party or coalition can form a government
- The Governor's personal dislike of the Chief Minister
Show answer
Answer: C. Bommai allows Article 356 only for a genuine constitutional breakdown, such as a hung Assembly with no possible government. Law and order or a poor Lok Sabha result are not grounds.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.