- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Meaning and evolution of federalism, and the federal features of India
Explain what federalism means and why it suits a diverse country, trace how federalism developed in the world and in India from 1773 to the Constitution, and describe the federal features of the Indian Constitution.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define federalism and explain why it suits a diverse society.
- Trace the evolution of federalism in the world and in India.
- Explain the six federal features of the Indian Constitution.
Unit 5 of the Tamil Nadu textbook turns to one of the most debated questions in Indian politics: how power is shared between the Union and the states. Tamil Nadu has played a prominent part in this debate, so it is worth understanding the ideas carefully.
What federalism means
Federalism is a political system in which the Constitution distributes and guarantees powers between a national government and several regional governments. Its basic attribute is that the state or regional governments are created and protected by the Constitution, not by the central government's will. The textbook pictures the Constitution as the parent and the Centre and the states as siblings: both draw their powers from the same source.
Where regions differ in ethnicity, language or religion, federalism is the ideal form of government. Democratic federalism is the best instrument for unity in diversity: the states keep their linguistic, religious or cultural identity without weakening the unity of the nation. Because the division of powers is written in the Constitution, the Constitution becomes the supreme authority. A. V. Dicey described a federal state as a political arrangement meant to reconcile national unity with the maintenance of states' rights.
Evolution of federalism
- In the world: the United States became the first modern federation. British colonies in Canada and Australia, on receiving self-government, also became federations; trilingual Switzerland is federal; and the European Union is a federation-like union formed voluntarily.
- Regulating Act, 1773: the textbook traces the beginnings of Indian federalism to this Act, which brought the three Presidencies of Madras, Calcutta and Bombay under one authority.
- The national movement recognised the plural character of colonial India.
- Government of India Act, 1919: introduced partial autonomy (dyarchy) in the provinces.
- Nehru Committee Report, 1928: favoured a federal structure with substantial powers for the states; the textbook treats it as the first demand for federalism in India.
- Government of India Act, 1935: granted provincial autonomy and proposed dyarchy at the Centre within an all-India federation.
- Constitution of India: its Seventh Schedule contains the three lists that divide powers between the Centre and the states.
Federal features of the Indian Constitution
| Feature | How India shows it |
|---|---|
| Written Constitution | Many governments (the textbook counts 28 state governments and one national government) need their powers stated in clear terms |
| Supremacy of the Constitution | Every government must follow its terms and procedures; no government can claim power above it |
| Distribution of powers | Three lists (Union, State, Concurrent), unlike the single enumeration of the classical US federation |
| Bicameralism | Parliament has two Houses; the Rajya Sabha represents the states and is regarded as the guardian of their rights |
| Rigid Constitution | Article 368 in Part XX lays down a special amendment procedure; federal provisions also need ratification by half the states |
| Supreme Court as umpire | Original jurisdiction over disputes between the Union and states or between states; final interpreter of the Constitution |
For example, if a dispute arises between Tamil Nadu and the Union Government, or between Tamil Nadu and another state, only the Supreme Court can decide it in its original jurisdiction.
Federal features of the Indian Constitution
-
Written and supreme Constitution
- Powers stated clearly
- No government above it
-
Division of powers
- Union List
- State List
- Concurrent List
-
Bicameral Parliament
- Rajya Sabha for the states
-
Rigid amendment
- Article 368
- Half the states for federal matters
-
Independent judiciary
- Supreme Court as umpire
Federalism = a constitutional division of powers between national and regional governments, each protected by a supreme, written, rigid Constitution and an independent umpire.
Worked example 1: federal or not?
A made-up country's central parliament can abolish any province's government by an ordinary law, and there is no written constitution. Analysis: this is not federal. Regional governments exist only at the centre's pleasure; there is no written, supreme constitution protecting them and no court to umpire. In a true federation the regional governments are created and protected by the constitution itself.
Worked example 2: why rigidity protects states
Suppose Parliament wished to move 'police' from the State List to the Union List. Working: this changes the Seventh Schedule, a federal provision, so it needs a special majority in each House and ratification by half the state legislatures. The states therefore have a say before their powers are reduced. This is why the textbook links rigidity with protecting states' rights.
Key takeaways: federalism divides power between national and regional governments through a supreme, written constitution, and suits diverse societies by securing unity in diversity. The USA was the first modern federation; in India the idea grew from the Regulating Act of 1773 through the 1919 and 1935 Acts and the 1928 Nehru Report. India's federal features are a written, supreme Constitution, three lists, bicameralism, a rigid amendment procedure and the Supreme Court as umpire.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which country had the first federal constitution in the modern world?
- The United Kingdom
- India
- The United States
- Australia
Show answer
Answer: C. The United States became the first modern federation. Canada and Australia adopted federal forms later; the United Kingdom is unitary.
-
2. According to the textbook, which report first demanded federalism for India?
- The Nehru Report of 1928
- The Mountbatten Plan
- The Cabinet Mission Plan
- The Sarkaria Report
Show answer
Answer: A. The Nehru Committee Report of 1928 favoured a federal structure with more powers for the states.
-
3. Which Act introduced dyarchy (partial autonomy) in the provinces?
- The Regulating Act of 1773
- The Government of India Act of 1935
- The Indian Independence Act of 1947
- The Government of India Act of 1919
Show answer
Answer: D. The 1919 Act introduced dyarchy in the provinces. The 1935 Act granted provincial autonomy and proposed dyarchy at the Centre.
-
4. Which body acts as the umpire of India's federal system?
- The Parliament
- The Supreme Court
- The President
- The Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: B. The Supreme Court has original jurisdiction over disputes between the Union and the states and among states, and is the final interpreter of the Constitution.
-
5. In which Part of the Constitution is Article 368, the amendment procedure, found?
- Part III
- Part IV
- Part XX
- Part XVIII
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 368 is in Part XX. Part III has Fundamental Rights, Part IV the Directive Principles and Part XVIII the emergency provisions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.