Revision notes

Unit 5 Federalism in India: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Meaning and evolution of federalism, and the federal features of India

FeatureHow India shows it
Written ConstitutionMany governments (the textbook counts 28 state governments and one national government) need their powers stated in clear terms
Supremacy of the ConstitutionEvery government must follow its terms and procedures; no government can claim power above it
Distribution of powersThree lists (Union, State, Concurrent), unlike the single enumeration of the classical US federation
BicameralismParliament has two Houses; the Rajya Sabha represents the states and is regarded as the guardian of their rights
Rigid ConstitutionArticle 368 in Part XX lays down a special amendment procedure; federal provisions also need ratification by half the states
Supreme Court as umpireOriginal jurisdiction over disputes between the Union and states or between states; final interpreter of the Constitution

Federal features of the Indian Constitution

  • Written and supreme Constitution
    • Powers stated clearly
    • No government above it
  • Division of powers
    • Union List
    • State List
    • Concurrent List
  • Bicameral Parliament
    • Rajya Sabha for the states
  • Rigid amendment
    • Article 368
    • Half the states for federal matters
  • Independent judiciary
    • Supreme Court as umpire

Federalism = a constitutional division of powers between national and regional governments, each protected by a supreme, written, rigid Constitution and an independent umpire.

Key takeaways: federalism divides power between national and regional governments through a supreme, written constitution, and suits diverse societies by securing unity in diversity. The USA was the first modern federation; in India the idea grew from the Regulating Act of 1773 through the 1919 and 1935 Acts and the 1928 Nehru Report. India's federal features are a written, supreme Constitution, three lists, bicameralism, a rigid amendment procedure and the Supreme Court as umpire.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Unitary features: why India is called quasi-federal

India and the classical US federation

  • USA
    • Separate state constitutions
    • Dual citizenship
    • Equal Senate seats
    • Residuary powers with states
    • Dual courts
  • India
    • One Constitution
    • Single citizenship
    • Seats by population
    • Residuary powers with the Centre
    • Integrated judiciary

India: federal in form, unitary in spirit. Strong Centre through residuary powers, emergencies, Articles 3-4, Article 249, single citizenship, integrated courts and unified election and audit machinery.

Key takeaways: India departs from classical federalism through a single constitution and citizenship, partial flexibility, Parliament's power to reshape states (Articles 3 and 4), population-based Rajya Sabha seats and Article 249, a Union-heavy distribution of powers and revenue, emergency provisions (Part XVIII), an integrated judiciary, a single Election Commission and unified audit by the CAG. So it is called quasi-federal.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Centre-State relations: legislative, executive and financial

ListCount (as the textbook gives)Examples
List I: Union List100 subjectsDefence, foreign affairs, banking, currency
List II: State List59 itemsPublic order, police, public health, local government, agriculture, fisheries
List III: Concurrent List52 itemsCriminal law and procedure, civil procedure, marriage, education, forests
CategoryTextbook's example
Levied by the Union onlyCorporation tax, customs duty
Levied by the states onlySales tax
Levied by the Union, collected and kept by the statesStamp duties on bills of exchange; certain excise duties
Levied and collected by the Union, assigned to the states where leviedTaxes on sale of advertisements in newspapers
Levied and collected by the Union, shared with the states in a set proportionTax on income other than agricultural income

Three dimensions of Centre-State relations

  • Legislative
    • Territorial and subject distribution
    • Three lists, residuary to Centre
    • Exceptions: emergency, consent, treaties
  • Executive
    • Follows legislative power
    • Union directions
    • Mutual delegation
  • Financial
    • Tax and non-tax revenue
    • Grants-in-aid (Article 275)
    • Finance Commission (Article 280)

Parliament can enter the State List during a national emergency, at the request of two or more states, to implement treaties, under President's rule, and on a Rajya Sabha resolution (Article 249).

Key takeaways: Parliament legislates for all of India, even extra-territorially, and the states for their own territory; the three lists divide subjects, with the Union prevailing in conflicts and holding residuary power. Parliament may enter the State List in emergencies, on states' request, for treaties, under Article 356 and under Article 249. Executive power follows legislative power, with Union directions and mutual delegation. Revenue is shared in several ways (now through a divisible pool and GST), with grants under Article 275 and a Finance Commission every five years under Article 280.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Co-operative federalism and inter-state river water disputes

How an inter-state river dispute is settled

  1. Dispute arises States disagree over sharing water
  2. Negotiation First and preferred method
  3. Request to the Union If negotiations fail
  4. Tribunal set up Members nominated by the Chief Justice of India
  5. Award published In the Official Gazette; final and binding

River disputes: Article 262 + Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956 = negotiate first, then an ad hoc tribunal whose award is final, with courts excluded.

Key takeaways: Granville Austin called Indian federalism co-operative. The Inter-State Council (Article 263, set up in 1990 and chaired by the Prime Minister), the Zonal Councils (1956, chaired by the Home Minister), River Boards and NITI Aayog (2015) promote cooperation. Article 262 and the 1956 Act provide negotiation first, then a tribunal whose award is final. The Cauvery dispute moved from the 1924 agreement to the 2007 award and the 2018 Supreme Court verdict and authority.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Issues in Centre-State relations and the commissions that studied them

CommissionSet up by / yearKey points
First Administrative Reforms CommissionUnion, 1966 (chaired first by Morarji Desai, later K. Hanumanthaiya)20 reports, one with extensive suggestions on Centre-State relations; a Second ARC followed in 2005
Rajamannar CommitteeTamil Nadu Government; report 1971Members: Dr P. V. Rajamannar (retired Chief Justice of Madras High Court), Dr A. Lakshmanaswami Mudaliar, Dr P. Chandra Reddy
Sarkaria CommissionUnion, 1983; report 1988 with 247 recommendationsJustice R. S. Sarkaria with B. Sivaraman and Dr S. R. Sen
Punchhi CommissionUnion, 2007; report 2010Justice Madan Mohan Punchhi, former Chief Justice of India
Venkatachaliah Commission (NCRWC)Union, 2000National Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution, under Justice M. N. Venkatachaliah

Rajamannar and Sarkaria on key issues

  • Rajamannar (1971)
    • Residuary powers to states
    • Abolish All India Services
    • Delete Articles 256, 257, 339(2)
    • Article 356 as last resort
  • Sarkaria (1988)
    • Keep the Governor's office
    • Governors: eminent, non-partisan
    • Inter-State Council with permanent secretariat
    • Article 356 as last resort

Bommai (1994): Article 356 is exceptional, judicially reviewable, not for law and order; the Assembly survives until Parliament approves; a wrongly dismissed government can be restored.

Key takeaways: issues in Indian federalism include the Governor's role, education in the Concurrent List, reservation of state bills, the use of Article 356 and Union control of All India Services. The Rajamannar Committee (Tamil Nadu, 1971) sought wide state autonomy; the Sarkaria Commission (1983-88) proposed reforms within the existing framework; the Punchhi Commission (2007-10) and the NCRWC (2000) followed. The Bommai judgment (1994) made President's rule exceptional and reviewable by the courts.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery