- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Advantages of the modern table, hydrogen and the noble gases
List the advantages of the modern periodic table over Mendeleev's, explain why hydrogen's position is debated, and describe the noble gases.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the main advantages of the long-form table.
- Explain how atomic number resolves Mendeleev's misfits and the isotope problem.
- Give reasons for and against placing hydrogen with the alkali metals.
- Explain why group 18 elements are called noble, inert or rare gases.
The modern table did not throw away Mendeleev's work; it rebuilt it on a firmer foundation. This lesson looks at what was gained, and at two parts of the table that still need special comment: hydrogen at the top left and the noble gases at the far right.
Advantages of the modern periodic table
- It is based on a more fundamental property, the atomic number.
- An element's position links clearly to its electronic configuration.
- Each period ends logically: shells fill up step by step until a noble gas configuration is reached.
- All isotopes of an element share one position, which is justified because they have the same atomic number.
- Pairs that seemed misplaced in Mendeleev's table (Co/Ni, Te/I) are now in the right order by atomic number.
- Each group is independent; the idea of subgroups A and B is dropped.
- Transition elements sit in the middle, between the reactive metals on the left and the non-metals on the right, matching their in-between properties.
- Metals and non-metals are clearly separated, with non-metals in the upper right.
- The placing of lanthanides and actinides at the bottom is explained.
- It is easier to remember and reproduce.
Worked example 1: the cobalt-nickel puzzle solved
Question: Cobalt (atomic mass 58.93, Z = 27) and nickel (58.71, Z = 28). Which comes first in the modern table and why? Working: the modern table uses atomic number, so cobalt (27) comes before nickel (28) - exactly where Mendeleev had put it on chemical grounds. No exception is needed any more.
The position of hydrogen
Hydrogen is the lightest, smallest and first element, with the simplest configuration of all: one electron (1s¹). It behaves partly like the alkali metals and partly like the halogens, so its place is unique. In the modern table it is placed at the top of group 1, but its position is still debated.
Is hydrogen like the alkali metals or the halogens?
-
Like alkali metals (group 1)
- One electron in its outer shell
- Can lose it to form H⁺, as Na forms Na⁺
-
Like halogens (group 17)
- Needs one electron to fill its shell
- Can gain one to form the hydride ion H⁻, as Cl forms Cl⁻
-
Unlike either
- A gas, while alkali metals are solids
- A non-metal, unlike the alkali metals
The noble gases
Helium, neon, argon, krypton, xenon and radon form group 18. They exist as single atoms (monoatomic gases) and hardly react with other substances, because their outer shells are completely filled. Hence they are called inert gases or noble gases. Because they occur in the air only in very small amounts, they are also called rare gases.
Worked example 2: why neon does not react
Question: Write the configurations of neon (Z = 10) and argon (Z = 18) and explain their lack of reactivity. Working: neon 2, 8; argon 2, 8, 8. Each has a full outer shell of 8 electrons, so it has no tendency to lose, gain or share electrons - valency 0. Helium (2) has a full K shell, which can hold only 2.
Hydrogen: one electron, so it can form H⁺ (like alkali metals) or H⁻ (like halogens) - a unique position. Noble gases: full outer shells, monoatomic, very unreactive.
Key takeaways: the modern table places elements by atomic number, which gives isotopes one place, fixes reversed pairs, drops subgroups and links position to configuration. Hydrogen resembles both alkali metals and halogens and sits at the top of group 1. Group 18 noble gases are monoatomic and unreactive because their shells are full.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why do all isotopes of an element occupy a single place in the modern periodic table?
- They have the same mass number
- They have the same number of neutrons
- They have the same atomic number
- They are all radioactive
Show answer
Answer: C. The modern table is based on atomic number, and isotopes of an element share the same atomic number, so one place is justified.
-
2. Hydrogen resembles the halogens because it can
- lose an electron to form H⁺
- gain an electron to form H⁻
- conduct electricity as a solid
- form a monoatomic gas
Show answer
Answer: B. Halogens gain one electron to form negative ions such as Cl⁻; hydrogen can likewise gain one electron to form the hydride ion H⁻. Losing an electron is how it resembles alkali metals.
-
3. Where are non-metals mainly found in the modern periodic table?
- Lower left
- In groups 1 and 2
- In the f-block
- Upper right
Show answer
Answer: D. The modern table places non-metals in the upper right corner, clearly separated from the metals on the left and in the middle.
-
4. Noble gases are unreactive because they
- have completely filled outer shells
- are very heavy
- have no electrons
- are liquids
Show answer
Answer: A. A full outer shell (2 for helium, 8 for the rest) is stable, so these atoms have no tendency to gain, lose or share electrons.
-
5. Which is NOT an advantage of the modern periodic table?
- Isotopes need only one place
- Co and Ni are in the correct order
- Atomic masses always increase strictly across every row
- Subgroups A and B are no longer needed
Show answer
Answer: C. The modern table is ordered by atomic number, not mass; a few pairs (like tellurium and iodine) still have masses in reverse order. The other three are genuine advantages.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.