• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mendeleev's periodic table: features, predictions and limitations

State Mendeleev's periodic law, describe the features of his table, explain how he corrected atomic masses and predicted eka-silicon (germanium), and list the limitations of his table.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State Mendeleev's periodic law.
  • Describe the groups, subgroups and periods of his table.
  • Explain how gaps let him predict new elements such as eka-silicon.
  • List the limitations of his table.

In 1869 the Russian chemist Dmitri Mendeleev studied the elements known at the time and noticed that elements with similar properties recur at regular intervals when the elements are arranged in order of atomic mass. He turned this observation into a law and a table that, for the first time, organised all the known elements.

Mendeleev's periodic law: the physical and chemical properties of elements are periodic functions of their atomic masses.

Features of Mendeleev's table

  • It has eight vertical columns called groups and seven horizontal rows called periods. Because its periods are short, it is called the short form of the periodic table.
  • Each group is divided into two subgroups, A and B, and elements in a group have similar properties - for example, the formulae of their oxides and hydrides follow a pattern across the groups.
  • Where an element did not fit, Mendeleev suspected its atomic mass had been measured wrongly and corrected it. Beryllium's mass was then taken as 14; he reassessed it as 9 and moved beryllium to its proper place.
  • He left gaps for elements not yet discovered and predicted their properties.

Predicting new elements

Mendeleev named the missing elements below aluminium and silicon eka-aluminium and eka-silicon ('eka' means 'one' in Sanskrit, that is, one place further down). When germanium was discovered in 1886, during his lifetime, its properties matched his predictions for eka-silicon remarkably well.

As given in the Tamil Nadu textbook
PropertyPredicted for eka-silicon (1871)Found for germanium (1886)
Atomic massAbout 7272.59
Specific gravity5.55.47
ColourDark greyDark grey
Formula of oxideEsO₂GeO₂
Formula of chlorideEsCl₄GeCl₄

Worked example 1: predicting a property

Question: Silicon (above) has atomic mass about 28 and tin (below) about 119. Using Dobereiner-style averaging, what mass might you expect for the element between them? Working: (28 + 119) ÷ 2 = 147 ÷ 2 = 73.5. Mendeleev's prediction for eka-silicon was about 72, and germanium's actual mass is 72.6 - close to this estimate. Using neighbours in the table to predict unknown properties is exactly what Mendeleev did.

Limitations of Mendeleev's table

  • Elements with very different properties were placed together: hard metals such as copper and silver sat in the same group as soft metals such as sodium and potassium.
  • Hydrogen had no proper place: a non-metal was placed with metals like lithium, sodium and potassium.
  • The order of increasing atomic mass was not followed strictly: cobalt (58.93) was placed before nickel (58.71), and tellurium (127.6) before iodine (126.9), to keep similar elements together.
  • There was no place for isotopes: since isotopes of an element have different masses, a table based on mass should have put them in different places.

Worked example 2: the tellurium-iodine problem

Question: Tellurium's atomic mass is 127.6 and iodine's 126.9. Why did Mendeleev put tellurium first? Working: by mass, iodine should come first. But iodine behaves like chlorine and bromine, and tellurium like sulphur and selenium. Mendeleev trusted the properties and placed iodine with the halogens, after tellurium. This 'misfit' was explained only later, when tables were based on atomic number (Te = 52, I = 53).

Mendeleev's table: strengths and weaknesses

  • Strengths
    • First full classification
    • Corrected wrong atomic masses
    • Left gaps and predicted new elements
    • Germanium proved him right
  • Weaknesses
    • No proper place for hydrogen
    • Mass order broken (Co/Ni, Te/I)
    • No place for isotopes
    • Unlike metals in the same group

Key takeaways: Mendeleev's law said properties are periodic functions of atomic mass. His short-form table had 8 groups (with A and B subgroups) and 7 periods. His bold predictions - such as eka-silicon, later found as germanium - made the table famous, but problems with hydrogen, isotopes and reversed pairs remained.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Mendeleev arranged elements in order of their

    1. atomic masses
    2. atomic numbers
    3. densities
    4. dates of discovery
    Show answer

    Answer: A. His periodic law said properties are periodic functions of atomic masses. Atomic numbers came into use only after Moseley's work in 1913.

  2. 2. Which element did Mendeleev call eka-silicon?

    1. Gallium
    2. Carbon
    3. Tin
    4. Germanium
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Eka-silicon was the predicted element below silicon. Germanium, discovered in 1886, matched its predicted properties.

  3. 3. How many groups and periods did Mendeleev's table have?

    1. 18 groups, 7 periods
    2. 8 groups, 7 periods
    3. 7 groups, 8 periods
    4. 8 groups, 18 periods
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Mendeleev's short-form table had eight vertical groups and seven horizontal periods. The modern long form has 18 groups.

  4. 4. Mendeleev corrected the atomic mass of beryllium from 14 to

    1. 9
    2. 7
    3. 12
    4. 24
    Show answer

    Answer: A. He judged that beryllium's mass had been measured wrongly as 14 and reassessed it as 9, which let him place it correctly.

  5. 5. Which is a limitation of Mendeleev's table?

    1. It left gaps for undiscovered elements
    2. It grouped elements with similar properties
    3. It could not give isotopes a place
    4. It corrected wrong atomic masses
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Isotopes of an element have different masses, so a mass-based table could not explain why they share one place. The other options are strengths of the table.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery