- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Early attempts: Dobereiner's triads and Newlands' octaves
Explain why chemists needed to classify elements, apply Dobereiner's law of triads and Newlands' law of octaves, and state the limitations of each.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why a classification of elements was needed.
- Check a Dobereiner triad by averaging atomic masses.
- Use Newlands' law of octaves to find elements with similar properties.
- List the limitations of both early methods.
A library with thousands of books thrown on the floor is useless; arranged by subject, it becomes easy to use. Chemists faced the same problem with elements. According to the Tamil Nadu textbook, only 31 elements were known in 1800, 63 by 1865, and today 118 have been discovered. As information about them piled up, scientists looked for patterns that would let them study elements in groups rather than one at a time.
Dobereiner's triads (1817)
The German chemist Johann Wolfgang Dobereiner grouped some similar elements in sets of three called triads. He noticed that when the three are arranged in increasing order of atomic mass, the atomic mass of the middle element is nearly the average of the other two. This is Dobereiner's law of triads.
| Triad | Atomic masses | Average of first and third | Middle element |
|---|---|---|---|
| Li, Na, K | 6.9, 23, 39.1 | (6.9 + 39.1) ÷ 2 = 23.0 | Na = 23 |
| Cl, Br, I | 35.5, 79.9, 126.9 | (35.5 + 126.9) ÷ 2 = 81.2 | Br = 79.9 |
| Ca, Sr, Ba | 40.1, 87.6, 137.3 | (40.1 + 137.3) ÷ 2 = 88.7 | Sr = 87.6 |
Worked example 1: testing a triad
Question: Show that chlorine, bromine and iodine form a Dobereiner triad. Working: average of Cl and I = (35.5 + 126.9) ÷ 2 = 162.4 ÷ 2 = 81.2. Bromine's atomic mass is 79.9, which is close to 81.2. The three are also alike chemically (all are reactive non-metals called halogens), so they form a triad.
Limitations: Dobereiner could find only three triads among the elements known at the time, so most elements could not be classified this way; and the rule did not work for elements of very low or very high atomic mass.
Newlands' law of octaves (1866)
The English chemist John Newlands arranged the 56 elements then known in increasing order of atomic mass. He found that every eighth element had properties similar to the first, just as in music the eighth note repeats the first. In the Indian scale - sa, re, ga, ma, pa, dha, ni, sa - the eighth note is sa again. He called this the law of octaves.
Worked example 2: counting octaves
Question: In Newlands' order H, Li, Be, B, C, N, O, F, Na, Mg, Al, Si, P, S, Cl, K, Ca, which element is like lithium, and which is like magnesium? Working: counting lithium as 1, the eighth element is sodium (Li, Be, B, C, N, O, F, Na) - and both are soft, reactive metals. Counting magnesium as 1: Mg, Al, Si, P, S, Cl, K, Ca - calcium is the eighth, and magnesium and calcium are indeed alike.
Limitations of the law of octaves:
- It worked only up to calcium; beyond that the pattern broke down.
- Sometimes two elements were squeezed into one slot, such as cobalt and nickel.
- Some very different elements were put together - cobalt, nickel, palladium, platinum and iridium appeared in the same row as the halogens.
- The table had room for only 56 elements and left no space for elements still to be discovered.
- When the noble gases (neon, argon ...) were discovered later, fitting them in made the ninth element, not the eighth, resemble the first - neon falls between fluorine and sodium.
Two early classifications
-
Dobereiner's triads (1817)
- Groups of three similar elements
- Middle mass ≈ average of the other two
- Only three triads found
-
Newlands' octaves (1866)
- All 56 known elements in order of mass
- Every eighth element similar
- Worked only up to calcium
Dobereiner: middle atomic mass ≈ average of the other two in a triad. Newlands: every eighth element resembles the first (up to calcium).
Key takeaways: chemists needed a system as the number of known elements grew. Dobereiner's triads and Newlands' octaves both used atomic mass and found real patterns, but each worked only for a limited set of elements. Their failures pointed the way to Mendeleev's table.
Check your understanding
-
1. Lithium (6.9), sodium (23) and potassium (39.1) form a Dobereiner triad because
- they are all gases
- the mass of sodium is nearly the average of lithium and potassium
- they have the same atomic mass
- they were discovered in the same year
Show answer
Answer: B. (6.9 + 39.1) ÷ 2 = 46 ÷ 2 = 23, which equals sodium's atomic mass. They are also chemically similar soft metals.
-
2. In the triad calcium (40.1), strontium and barium (137.3), the expected atomic mass of strontium is about
- 97.2
- 40.1
- 177.4
- 88.7
Show answer
Answer: D. Average = (40.1 + 137.3) ÷ 2 = 177.4 ÷ 2 = 88.7. Strontium's actual atomic mass, 87.6, is close to this.
-
3. Newlands compared his arrangement of elements with
- the notes of a musical octave
- the colours of a rainbow
- the days of the week
- the planets of the solar system
Show answer
Answer: A. He noticed that every eighth element resembled the first, as the eighth note of a musical scale repeats the first, and called it the law of octaves.
-
4. Up to which element did Newlands' law of octaves work?
- Hydrogen
- Iron
- Calcium
- Uranium
Show answer
Answer: C. The law of octaves held only for lighter elements up to calcium; beyond calcium the pattern failed.
-
5. Which is a limitation of Dobereiner's triads?
- It placed noble gases wrongly
- It used atomic numbers instead of masses
- Only three triads could be found among the known elements
- It had too many groups
Show answer
Answer: C. Dobereiner found only three triads, so most elements could not be classified. Atomic numbers were not known in his time.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.