• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Chomsky's view: an inborn ability for grammar

Explain Chomsky's language acquisition device and innate grammar, the evidence for it, and how it differs from Skinner's behaviourist view.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

In the last lesson behaviourism struggled to explain two things: children produce sentences they have never heard, and they make rule-based errors like 'goed'. The linguist Noam Chomsky offered a very different explanation. He argued that human beings are born ready for language, much as birds are born ready to fly. This lesson explains his idea and compares it with Skinner's.

The language acquisition device

Chomsky proposed that every child is born with a mental ability he called the language acquisition device, or LAD. It is not a part of the body that can be seen, but a built-in readiness to discover the grammar of whatever language the child hears. Because of the LAD, a child does not need to be taught grammar rules; the child works them out from everyday speech.

Innate grammar and universal principles

Chomsky also argued that all human languages, however different they sound, share some deep basic principles, which he called universal grammar. For example, every language has ways to form sentences, to ask questions and to talk about who did what to whom. The child is born with these general principles and uses the language heard around him to fill in the details of his own language, Hindi, Tamil, English or any other.

Chomsky: children are born with a language acquisition device (LAD), an inborn readiness for grammar. Hearing a language sets it working; the child discovers the rules rather than copying sentences.

The evidence Chomsky pointed to

  • Speed: children master very complex grammar in a few years, much faster than imitation alone could explain.
  • Creativity: children make up sentences they have never heard.
  • Rule-based errors: mistakes like 'goed' show rules being applied, not words being copied.
  • The same stages everywhere: children in very different language communities pass through similar stages in the same order.
  • Imperfect input: the speech children hear is full of half-sentences and slips, yet they still arrive at the correct grammar.

Worked example 1: which theory does it support?

Observation: 'A child who has never heard the sentence "The elephant ate my umbrella" can say it and understand it.' Does this support Skinner or Chomsky? Step 1: the sentence was never heard, so it cannot be imitated. Step 2: it was never rewarded before, so reinforcement cannot explain it. Step 3: producing new sentences from rules fits the idea of an inborn grammar ability. Answer: Chomsky.

What the environment still does

A common mistake is to think Chomsky said the environment does not matter. It does: a child who hears no language will not learn one, and a child learns the particular language that is spoken around him. In Chomsky's view, the environment provides the material and switches the device on, but the ability to find grammar inside that material is inborn.

Chomsky's view also has limits. It concentrates on grammar and says less about how children learn to use language with people: taking turns, asking politely, telling a story. Many psychologists therefore add that conversation with caring adults matters a great deal, an idea you will meet again with Vygotsky in the next lesson. For a teacher, the practical message from Chomsky is simple: trust children's natural ability, surround them with rich language, and do not expect grammar to arrive through rules and drill.

Skinner and Chomsky side by side

Two views of language learning
QuestionSkinnerChomsky
Where does language come from?The environmentAn inborn ability, triggered by the environment
How is it learned?Imitation, reinforcement, shapingDiscovering rules with the LAD
What does 'goed' show?Hard to explainRule learning, as expected
Role of the childFairly passiveActive rule-finder

Worked example 2: a teacher's response

A five-year-old says, 'Me and him goed to the shop.' What would a teacher guided by Chomsky do? Step 1: see the error as a sign that the child is applying a rule. Step 2: avoid scolding, which does not speed up rule learning. Step 3: model the correct form naturally: 'Oh, you and he went to the shop?' Answer: accept the error as part of learning and provide a rich, correct model.

Key takeaways: Chomsky proposed an inborn language acquisition device and universal grammar; evidence includes speed, creativity, rule-based errors and similar stages everywhere; the environment provides the language and starts the device, but grammar learning is innate; Skinner stresses imitation and reinforcement, Chomsky the child's inborn ability.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Chomsky's theory, 'LAD' stands for:

    1. Learning And Development
    2. Listening Ability Development
    3. Language Acquisition Device
    4. Language And Drill
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Chomsky proposed an inborn Language Acquisition Device that equips every child to learn the grammar of the language around them.

  2. 2. According to Noam Chomsky, children are born with:

    1. A complete vocabulary of their mother tongue
    2. No language ability at all, only the ability to copy
    3. The ability to read and write
    4. An inborn readiness to learn grammar
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Chomsky argued that children are born with an innate capacity for grammar. Words must still be learned from the language around them.

  3. 3. Which observation supports Chomsky's view?

    1. Children speak with the accent of their parents
    2. Children learn more words when adults talk to them often
    3. Children like to be praised for speaking
    4. Children in very different language communities go through similar stages in the same order
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Similar stages everywhere suggest a shared, inborn programme. The other three are more easily explained by the environment and reinforcement.

  4. 4. According to Chomsky, what does a child need from the environment?

    1. Exposure to a language, which sets the inborn device working
    2. Reward for every correct sentence
    3. Formal grammar lessons before speaking
    4. Nothing; language develops without hearing any
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Chomsky did not say the environment is unimportant: the child must hear a language. But the grammar-learning ability itself is inborn, so careful reward and formal lessons are not what drive it.

  5. 5. Which pairing is correct?

    1. Skinner: innate language acquisition device; Chomsky: imitation and reinforcement
    2. Skinner: private speech; Chomsky: egocentric speech
    3. Skinner: language follows thought; Chomsky: social speech
    4. Skinner: imitation and reinforcement; Chomsky: innate language acquisition device
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Skinner was the behaviourist who stressed imitation and reinforcement. Chomsky proposed the inborn LAD.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery