• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Growth of word meaning: vocabulary, overextension and underextension

Trace how children's vocabulary and word meanings grow, tell overextension from underextension, and separate receptive from expressive vocabulary, with worked examples.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Learning the meaning of words is slow, careful work. A child has to find out which things a word names and which it does not. Along the way children make charming mistakes that tell a teacher what they currently believe a word means. This lesson looks at how vocabulary grows and at two classic mistakes of meaning, overextension and underextension.

Two vocabularies in one child

A child's receptive vocabulary is all the words she understands when she hears or reads them. Her expressive vocabulary is the words she actually uses when speaking or writing. The first is almost always larger than the second. A three-year-old may understand 'Put the spoon in the bowl' but still say 'spoon bowl'. This is why a teacher should not judge a quiet child's understanding only from what she says.

Overextension: the word is stretched too far

In overextension the child uses a word for more things than adults do. A child who has learned 'doggy' may call a cow, a horse and a goat 'doggy' because they have four legs and a tail. Another child may say 'moon' for a round clock or an orange. The child is not being silly: she has noticed a shared feature (shape, size, movement) and is using the few words she has to cover many things. Overextension is most common in the second year, and it fades as the vocabulary grows and the child learns the words 'cow' and 'horse'.

Underextension: the word is held too narrowly

In underextension the child uses a word for fewer things than adults do. A child who thinks 'cup' means only her own blue cup, and not the steel cup at her grandmother's house, has underextended the word. Another child may think 'dog' refers only to the family's dog. Underextension is quieter than overextension, because nobody hears a wrong word; the child simply fails to use the word where it should apply. It also fades as the child meets more examples.

Overextension = a word covers MORE than it should (cow called 'doggy'). Underextension = a word covers LESS than it should ('cup' means only my cup).

How new words are learned

  • Children often learn a new word after hearing it only a few times in a clear situation, which is sometimes called fast mapping; later they refine its meaning.
  • Pointing, naming and shared attention to the same object help a child connect word and thing.
  • Stories, picture books and conversation add new words faster than isolated lists.
  • Children learn words best when they hear them in many different contexts, because each context shows a little more of the meaning.

Worked example 1: overextension or underextension?

Decide for each case. (a) Meera calls every man she sees 'Papa'. (b) Imran says 'bird' only for the pigeon on his balcony and not for a crow. (c) Sana calls a tomato and a cricket ball 'ball'. Step 1: (a) 'Papa' is used for more people than one father, so overextension. Step 2: (b) 'bird' is used for fewer creatures than it covers, so underextension. Step 3: (c) 'ball' is stretched to a round tomato, so overextension. Answer: overextension, underextension, overextension.

Worked example 2: planning a response

A teacher notices that a five-year-old calls a lorry, a bus and a van all 'car'. What should she do? Step 1: identify the pattern: 'car' is used too widely, so overextension. Step 2: the child already knows the core idea of a road vehicle, so there is no need to scold. Step 3: introduce the missing words in context: take the pupils to the school gate to look at a bus and a lorry, say 'That is a bus; it carries many people; that is a lorry; it carries goods', and let the pupils sort picture cards under each word. Answer: give clear examples and contrasts so that the child can narrow the word on her own.

Receptive or expressive?

A girl follows the instruction 'Bring the red pencil from the table' correctly but, when shown a pencil, will only say 'that'. Her understanding of 'red', 'pencil' and 'table' is shown by what she does, so the receptive vocabulary includes these words. Her expressive vocabulary does not yet include 'pencil'. The teacher should keep modelling the word ('Yes, a pencil') and give chances to say it rather than assuming she does not know it.

Key takeaways: receptive vocabulary (understood) is usually larger than expressive vocabulary (used); overextension stretches a word too far and underextension holds it too narrowly; both fade as children meet more examples; teachers help by naming things in context, using contrasts and giving many chances to use new words.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The words a child understands when she hears them, even if she cannot yet say them, make up her:

    1. Expressive vocabulary
    2. Telegraphic vocabulary
    3. Private vocabulary
    4. Receptive vocabulary
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Understanding words is receptive; using them is expressive. Children usually understand more than they say.

  2. 2. A toddler calls a cow, a goat and a horse 'doggy'. This is an example of:

    1. Underextension
    2. Overextension
    3. Babbling
    4. Recasting
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The word 'doggy' is used for more animals than adults use it for, which is overextension.

  3. 3. A child thinks the word 'cup' means only her own blue cup. This is:

    1. Overextension
    2. A holophrase
    3. Underextension
    4. Egocentric speech
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The word is held too narrowly, covering fewer objects than it should. That is underextension.

  4. 4. Which teaching response best helps a child who calls a bus and a lorry 'car'?

    1. Show real examples and contrasts and name each vehicle in context
    2. Tell her she is wrong and make her repeat the word 'bus' ten times
    3. Wait without comment until she is eight years old
    4. Ban the word 'car' from the classroom for a month
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Clear examples and contrasts in meaningful settings let the child narrow the word herself. Scolding and drill do not show what the words mean.

  5. 5. Which statement about vocabulary is usually true for young children?

    1. They use more words than they understand
    2. They understand exactly as many words as they use
    3. They understand more words than they use
    4. They cannot understand any word they cannot say
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Receptive vocabulary is normally larger than expressive vocabulary, so a quiet child may understand a great deal.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery