- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Piaget and Vygotsky: how language and thought are linked
Contrast Piaget's view that language follows thought with Vygotsky's view of social, private and inner speech, and apply both to the classroom.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Skinner and Chomsky asked how children learn language. Two other great psychologists, Jean Piaget and Lev Vygotsky, asked a related question: how is language linked with thinking? Does a child need to think first in order to speak, or does speaking help a child to think? Their answers lead to different classroom habits, so this question matters to every teacher.
Piaget: language follows thought
Piaget studied how children's thinking develops through stages. For him, thinking comes first and language follows. A child can use a word properly only when she understands the idea behind it. For example, a child may say the words 'more' and 'less' but use them correctly only once she can actually compare amounts. In Piaget's view, language is a way of expressing thinking that is already there; it does not by itself create new thinking.
Piaget also noticed that young children often talk without really addressing anyone, or talk 'at' each other without listening, each following his own line. He called this egocentric speech: speech that does not take the listener's point of view into account. He saw it as a sign of the young child's self-centred thinking, and expected it to fade as the child became more social.
Vygotsky: language shapes thought
Vygotsky gave language a much bigger role. For him, language begins as a social tool, used to communicate with others. Then the child starts to use it on himself, talking aloud to plan and guide his own actions; this is private speech. Gradually private speech goes silent and becomes inner speech, the voice we think with. So, in Vygotsky's view, language does not just express thought; it becomes one of the main tools of thought.
Piaget: thought first, language follows; self-talk is egocentric speech that fades. Vygotsky: social speech, then private speech, then inner speech; language becomes a tool for thinking.
Worked example 1: one behaviour, two explanations
Five-year-old Tanvi, building a tower of blocks alone, says aloud, 'Big one at the bottom... now the small one... careful.' How would each psychologist describe this? Step 1: Piaget: she is not addressing anyone, so this is egocentric speech, a sign of young thinking that will fade. Step 2: Vygotsky: she is guiding her own actions with words, so this is private speech, a useful tool that will later turn into silent inner speech. Answer: egocentric speech for Piaget, private speech for Vygotsky.
When does private speech increase?
Vygotsky observed that children use more private speech when a task becomes difficult, just as adults sometimes talk themselves through a tricky job. This fits his idea that it is a thinking tool: we reach for it when we need it most.
Learning through talk
Because language starts as social, Vygotsky stressed learning through conversation with someone more skilled, a parent, teacher or more able classmate. Talking a problem through with such a person lets a child do more than she could alone, and the words used together later become her own tools for thinking.
Worked example 2: choosing a teaching method
A teacher wants children to understand why some objects float. Which approach fits Vygotsky? Step 1: Vygotsky values language as a thinking tool. Step 2: he stresses talk with others, especially more able partners. Step 3: so the teacher lets pairs test objects and explain their guesses to each other, with the teacher joining in with questions. Answer: guided group talk, not silent individual work.
Comparing the two
| Point | Piaget | Vygotsky |
|---|---|---|
| Which comes first? | Thought; language follows | Language and thought develop together and join |
| Talking to oneself | Egocentric speech, fades | Private speech, becomes inner speech |
| Role of others | Less central | Central: learning through talk |
Key takeaways: Piaget held that language follows thought and saw self-talk as egocentric speech that fades; Vygotsky held that speech moves from social to private to inner speech and becomes a tool of thinking; private speech grows when tasks get hard; Vygotsky's view supports group talk and guidance from more skilled partners.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Thought develops first, and language follows it.' Whose view is this?
- Lev Vygotsky
- B. F. Skinner
- Noam Chomsky
- Jean Piaget
Show answer
Answer: D. Piaget held that language reflects the child's thinking: a child can use words properly only for ideas already understood.
-
2. In Vygotsky's theory, speech develops in which order?
- Social speech, private speech, inner speech
- Inner speech, private speech, social speech
- Private speech, social speech, inner speech
- Social speech, inner speech, private speech
Show answer
Answer: A. Language begins as talk with others (social), is then used aloud to guide oneself (private), and finally goes silent as thought (inner).
-
3. While doing a puzzle alone, a child mutters, 'This piece goes here... no, turn it round.' Vygotsky would call this:
- Social speech
- Babbling
- Private speech
- Telegraphic speech
Show answer
Answer: C. Talking aloud to oneself to guide one's own action is what Vygotsky called private speech.
-
4. How did Vygotsky view a child's private speech?
- As a sign of immaturity that simply disappears
- As babbling that has no meaning
- As a habit that teachers should stop at once
- As a tool for guiding one's own thinking, which later becomes inner speech
Show answer
Answer: D. Vygotsky saw private speech as useful self-guidance that gradually turns into silent inner speech. The view that it is a sign of egocentrism that fades is closer to Piaget.
-
5. Which classroom practice follows most directly from Vygotsky's view of language?
- Silent individual work only, with no talking allowed
- Waiting until the child's thinking develops before using any language
- Group discussion and talking problems through with more able peers or the teacher
- Rewarding every correct word with a sweet
Show answer
Answer: C. For Vygotsky, language is first social and becomes a tool for thinking, so talking with others helps children think. Silent work alone removes that tool; rewarding words is behaviourist.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.