- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Beyond stimulus and response: Tolman's latent learning and Hull's drive
Explain latent learning and cognitive maps (Tolman) and drive reduction (Hull), and see why these ideas went beyond simple stimulus-response learning.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Pavlov, Thorndike and Skinner explained learning through stimuli, responses and their consequences. Two other psychologists, Edward Tolman and Clark Hull, also worked with animals in the behaviourist tradition but asked deeper questions. Tolman asked whether learning needs a reward at all. Hull asked what makes an animal act in the first place. Their ideas often appear in teaching-aptitude papers, usually as one-line matching items, so each needs a clear picture.
Tolman: rats and mazes
Tolman studied rats finding their way through mazes. He noticed that the rats seemed to learn the layout of the maze even when nobody was rewarding them. His best-known experiment, carried out with a colleague, used three groups of rats in the same maze each day. Group one always found food at the end. Group two never found food. Group three found no food for the first ten days, and from the eleventh day food was placed at the end. Group one improved steadily and group two stayed poor. But group three, on the day after the food first appeared, suddenly made as few mistakes as group one. The rats of group three had clearly been learning the maze all along; they just had no reason to show it until a reward appeared.
Tolman called this latent learning: learning that takes place without obvious reinforcement and shows itself only later, when there is a reason to use it. He also said that the rats had built a cognitive map, a mental picture of the layout of the maze, rather than a chain of left-and-right habits. Because the rats could take a new route when the old one was blocked, he argued that they had learned where things are, not only what movements to make.
Tolman: latent learning = learning without visible reward, shown later when there is a reason; cognitive map = a mental picture of the layout. Learning is not always the same as performance.
Hull: drive reduction
Clark Hull tried to build a precise theory of why behaviour happens. He proposed that organisms have biological needs such as hunger, thirst or the need to avoid pain, and these create a drive, an inner push to act. Behaviour that lowers the drive (eating when hungry) is reinforced, so the connection between the stimulus and the response grows stronger. His idea is called drive reduction theory: reinforcement is the reduction of a drive. Hull's thinking is behaviourist, but unlike Skinner he used inner variables such as drive and habit strength in his explanations.
| Psychologist | Key idea | Key term |
|---|---|---|
| Tolman | Learning can happen without reward and show later | Latent learning, cognitive map |
| Hull | Behaviour is driven by needs, and reinforcement reduces the drive | Drive reduction |
| Skinner | Behaviour is shaped by its consequences | Operant conditioning |
| Thorndike | Responses followed by satisfaction are strengthened | Law of effect |
Worked example 1: latent learning in a child
Neha is driven to school by her uncle every day for a year and never walks it. One day the car breaks down, and she has to walk. She finds the way without a mistake, even taking a shorter lane. Which idea explains this? Step 1: nobody rewarded her for learning the route. Step 2: she learned it anyway, as a passenger. Step 3: the learning showed itself only when she needed it, and she could even choose a new route. Answer: latent learning, supported by a cognitive map of the area. A purely stimulus-response account would find it hard to explain the shorter lane.
Worked example 2: spot the drive
A student who has not eaten since morning works quickly through a worksheet because the teacher has promised a snack break after it. Explain in Hull's terms. Step 1: the student is hungry, which is a biological need producing a drive. Step 2: finishing the worksheet leads to food. Step 3: eating reduces the drive, which strengthens the behaviour of finishing work quickly. Answer: drive reduction. Note that a child who is not hungry would not be moved by a snack, which fits Hull's point that the drive is what starts the behaviour.
What teachers can take from this
- Children may know more than they show; do not assume that silence or poor performance means no learning.
- Give children chances to explore new surroundings, since they build mental maps even when nothing is marked.
- Basic needs such as hunger and tiredness affect what pupils will do, so a child who is hungry is poorly placed to learn.
Key takeaways: Tolman showed latent learning and cognitive maps, which means learning and performance are different things; Hull linked behaviour to drives and said reinforcement is drive reduction; both belong to the behaviourist tradition but widened it beyond simple stimulus-response chains.
Check your understanding
-
1. Rats that were not rewarded for ten days suddenly ran the maze with few errors once food appeared. This showed:
- Operant extinction
- Latent learning
- Classical conditioning
- Insight by sudden restructuring
Show answer
Answer: B. The rats had learned the maze without reward and showed it when reward appeared. That is latent learning, associated with Tolman.
-
2. A 'cognitive map' in Tolman's theory is:
- A chart of the reinforcement schedule
- A list of the drives in an animal
- A map of the brain's electrical activity
- A mental picture of the layout of the surroundings
Show answer
Answer: D. A cognitive map is the learner's mental picture of where things are. It helped Tolman argue that rats learn more than movement habits.
-
3. Which psychologist proposed drive reduction theory?
- Clark Hull
- Edward Tolman
- Albert Bandura
- Wolfgang Kohler
Show answer
Answer: A. Drive reduction is Hull's theory: behaviour is energised by needs and reinforcement is the reduction of the drive.
-
4. A child who has travelled many times as a passenger finds the way when she must walk alone. This is best explained by:
- Extinction of a conditioned response
- Negative reinforcement by removing a drive
- Latent learning and a cognitive map
- Stimulus generalisation of a conditioned fear
Show answer
Answer: C. No reward was involved, and the learning showed up later when needed. That is latent learning, with a cognitive map of the route.
-
5. Tolman's findings suggest that, for a teacher:
- Children learn only when they are rewarded at once
- Cognitive maps are formed only by adult learners
- Learning and performance are always the same thing
- Poor performance does not always mean nothing was learned
Show answer
Answer: D. Latent learning shows that learning can be hidden until there is a reason to perform. Learning and performance are different.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.