• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Transfer of learning and the humanistic view of Carl Rogers

Explain positive, negative and zero transfer, Thorndike's identical elements and Judd's generalisation, then Rogers' student-centred, humanistic view of learning.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Schools teach skills and facts in the hope that pupils will use them elsewhere: in a later class, in another subject, in everyday life. Whether this happens is the question of transfer. A different question is the emotional climate in which learning happens. The humanistic psychologist Carl Rogers answered it by asking teachers to treat pupils as whole persons. This lesson covers both ideas, because both are common in examinations.

Transfer of learning

Transfer of learning is the effect of earlier learning on later learning. It is positive when earlier learning helps the new task: a pupil who can add finds multiplication easier to understand. It is negative when earlier learning gets in the way: a person who has learned to drive on the left finds it hard to drive on the right. It is zero when earlier learning has no effect on the new one: learning Sanskrit verb forms has no effect on learning to ride a bicycle.

TypeEffect of the earlier learningExample
PositiveHelpsKnowing the alphabet helps in learning to use a dictionary
NegativeHindersAn old spelling habit causes errors in a new spelling pattern
ZeroNo effectLearning to swim has no effect on learning grammar

Theories of transfer

  • Formal discipline: the old view that the mind is like a muscle and that hard subjects such as Latin or mathematics train it for everything else. Research did not support strong claims of this kind.
  • Identical elements (Thorndike): transfer occurs to the extent that two tasks share identical elements, such as similar content or similar methods. The more two tasks overlap, the greater the transfer.
  • Generalisation (Judd): transfer occurs when the learner understands a general principle and applies it to a new situation. In Judd's well-known experiment, boys who had been taught the principle of light refraction did better when the depth of a target underwater was changed than boys who had only practised.

Transfer is the effect of old learning on new learning: positive helps, negative hinders, zero does nothing. Thorndike: identical elements. Judd: understood principles.

Rogers: learning centred on the person

Carl Rogers belonged to the humanistic school of psychology, which stresses personal growth, choice and feelings. For Rogers, the best learning is significant learning: learning that involves the whole person and is relevant to the learner's own purposes, not mere memorising. The teacher's role is that of a facilitator who creates a climate of trust rather than a source of facts who forces them in. Rogers stressed three qualities in a facilitator: genuineness (being honest and real), unconditional positive regard (accepting the pupil as a worthwhile person, even when disapproving of a particular act) and empathy (trying to understand the pupil's point of view).

Worked example 1: which type of transfer?

Identify each. (a) A pupil who learnt to ride a bicycle finds it easier to learn to ride a scooter. (b) A pupil who learnt that 'x' means 'multiply' in arithmetic is confused when x stands for an unknown number in algebra. (c) A pupil's knowledge of cricket rules has no effect on her learning of fractions. Step 1: (a) earlier learning helps, so positive transfer. Step 2: (b) the earlier meaning of 'x' gets in the way, so negative transfer. Step 3: (c) no effect, so zero transfer. Answer: positive, negative, zero.

Worked example 2: Thorndike or Judd?

A teacher says: 'I will teach the idea that heated air rises, not just the experiment, and then give problems on chimneys, balloons and sea breezes.' Which view of transfer fits? Step 1: she teaches a general principle first. Step 2: she asks pupils to apply it to new, different situations. Step 3: this is Judd's emphasis on generalisation. If instead she made practice tasks very similar to the test tasks so as to share as many elements as possible, that would match Thorndike's identical elements. Answer: Judd's generalisation.

Helping transfer happen

  • Teach principles along with examples, not examples alone.
  • Use many varied examples from different settings.
  • Point out links between topics and subjects openly.
  • Give learners chances to apply ideas to new problems.

Key takeaways: transfer can be positive, negative or zero; formal discipline is largely rejected; Thorndike stressed identical elements and Judd stressed understanding of general principles; Rogers' humanistic view stresses significant learning, the teacher as facilitator, genuineness, unconditional positive regard and empathy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. An earlier learned skill that makes a later task harder is an example of:

    1. Negative transfer
    2. Positive transfer
    3. Zero transfer
    4. Latent learning
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Earlier learning that hinders new learning is negative transfer.

  2. 2. Transfer depends on the number of identical elements shared by two tasks. This is the view of:

    1. Wolfgang Kohler
    2. David Ausubel
    3. Edward Thorndike
    4. Albert Bandura
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The identical elements theory belongs to Thorndike. Judd emphasised generalisation of principles.

  3. 3. Boys who had been taught the principle of light refraction did better when the depth of the target changed. This supports:

    1. Formal discipline
    2. Judd's generalisation
    3. The identical elements theory
    4. Tolman's cognitive map
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Understanding the underlying principle helped transfer to a new situation, which is Judd's view.

  4. 4. Which quality is NOT part of Rogers' description of a good facilitator?

    1. Empathy with the pupil's point of view
    2. Genuineness in dealing with pupils
    3. Unconditional positive regard for pupils
    4. Controlling pupils through fear of punishment
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Rogers stressed genuineness, empathy and unconditional positive regard. Fear of punishment has no place in his view.

  5. 5. Learning to swim has no effect on learning grammar. This is:

    1. Positive transfer
    2. Zero transfer
    3. Negative transfer
    4. Lateral extinction
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Earlier learning with no effect on later learning is zero transfer.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery