- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Thorndike: trial and error and the three laws of learning
Describe Thorndike's puzzle-box experiment, explain trial-and-error learning and apply the laws of readiness, exercise and effect in a classroom.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Pavlov's dogs learned to connect two stimuli without doing anything. Many things we learn, however, involve trying actions and keeping the ones that work. Edward Lee Thorndike, an American psychologist, studied this kind of learning and is often called a founder of educational psychology. His ideas lead directly to Skinner's work in the next lesson.
The cat in the puzzle box
Thorndike placed a hungry cat in a box with a door that opened when the cat worked a simple device, such as pulling a loop or pressing a lever. Food was kept outside where the cat could see it. At first the cat moved about randomly: scratching, biting, pushing. By chance it worked the device and the door opened, so it reached the food. Thorndike put the cat back again and again. Slowly the useless movements dropped away, and the time the cat took to escape became shorter, until it could open the door almost at once.
Thorndike called this trial-and-error learning: the learner tries many responses, wrong ones fade, and the successful one is kept. Because he explained learning as a connection, or bond, between a situation (stimulus) and a response, his theory is also called connectionism. The time taken fell gradually, not suddenly, which he took as evidence that learning builds up step by step.
The three main laws
| Law | Simple meaning | Classroom example |
|---|---|---|
| Law of readiness | Learning goes well when the learner is ready and willing; being forced when not ready is annoying | Arouse interest and check basic skills before starting a new topic |
| Law of exercise | Connections become stronger with use (practice) and weaker with disuse | Regular practice and revision of tables and spellings |
| Law of effect | A response followed by a satisfying result is strengthened; one followed by an annoying result is weakened | Praise for good work makes the student more likely to repeat it |
The law of effect is the most important for exams. It says that consequences shape learning: what leads to satisfaction tends to be repeated. Skinner later built his idea of reinforcement on this law. The law of exercise has two parts, use and disuse, which is why forgetting increases when we stop practising. The law of readiness reminds teachers that motivation and preparation matter before teaching begins.
Worked example 1: which law?
(a) A teacher starts a lesson on fractions by asking students to share a roti equally, so they become curious. (b) Students revise multiplication tables every morning for a month. (c) A student who received a smile and a 'well done' for a neat diagram draws neatly again. Working: (a) prepares and motivates learners, the law of readiness; (b) strengthens a connection through repeated use, the law of exercise; (c) a satisfying result strengthens a response, the law of effect.
Worked example 2: reading the learning curve
Suppose a cat takes these times to escape on its first six trials: 160, 140, 115, 90, 60 and 30 seconds. Working: the time falls steadily from trial to trial, by 20, 25, 25, 30 and 30 seconds. There is no single sudden drop. This gradual improvement is what trial-and-error learning predicts, and it contrasts with insight learning (lesson 4), where the solution can appear suddenly.
Thorndike: learning is trial and error that builds stimulus-response bonds. Readiness = be prepared and willing; exercise = practice strengthens, disuse weakens; effect = satisfying results stamp a response in.
What it means for teachers
Give learners chances to try, make mistakes and try again; prepare them before a new topic; plan regular practice and revision; and follow good work with satisfying results such as praise or a sense of success. Avoid making learning a source of annoyance, since that weakens it.
Key takeaways: Thorndike used hungry cats in puzzle boxes; learning was gradual trial and error; his three laws are readiness, exercise and effect; and the law of effect is the root of reinforcement.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which animal did Thorndike use in his puzzle-box experiments?
- Dog
- Chimpanzee
- Pigeon
- Cat
Show answer
Answer: D. Thorndike placed hungry cats in puzzle boxes. Dogs are linked with Pavlov, chimpanzees with Kohler, and pigeons with Skinner.
-
2. Thorndike's theory of learning is also known as:
- Connectionism (trial and error)
- Insight learning
- Observational learning
- Classical conditioning
Show answer
Answer: A. He explained learning as stimulus-response connections built by trial and error, so the theory is called connectionism.
-
3. 'A response followed by a satisfying result is more likely to be repeated.' This is the law of:
- Readiness
- Exercise
- Effect
- Disuse
Show answer
Answer: C. The law of effect says satisfying consequences strengthen a response and annoying ones weaken it.
-
4. A student forgets the formulas he has not used for a long time. Which part of Thorndike's laws explains this?
- The law of exercise (disuse weakens connections)
- The law of effect
- The law of readiness
- Spontaneous recovery
Show answer
Answer: A. The law of exercise has two parts: use strengthens a connection and disuse weakens it, so unpractised material is forgotten.
-
5. A teacher shows an interesting short video to arouse curiosity before starting a new chapter. This applies the law of:
- Effect
- Exercise
- Extinction
- Readiness
Show answer
Answer: D. Preparing and motivating learners before learning begins applies the law of readiness.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.