- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Bruner and Ausubel: discovery, spiral curriculum and meaningful learning
Describe Bruner's three modes of representation, discovery learning and spiral curriculum, and Ausubel's meaningful learning and advance organisers, with worked classroom examples.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Behaviourists described learning from the outside. Cognitive psychologists ask what happens inside the learner's mind: how information is organised, stored and linked to what is already known. Two influential cognitive thinkers for teachers are Jerome Bruner and David Ausubel. They agree that learning should be meaningful but differ on how teaching should begin. This lesson explains each idea, then compares the two.
Bruner: three ways of representing the world
Bruner suggested that a person can represent knowledge in three ways, and that learners often move through them in this order for a new topic. The enactive mode is knowing through action: a child understands balancing by actually riding a seesaw. The iconic mode is knowing through images and pictures: a diagram of a seesaw. The symbolic mode is knowing through language and symbols: the words or a formula that describe balance. Bruner argued that any subject can be taught in an honest form to children of any age if the mode is suited to them, and that a good lesson often moves from action to image to symbol.
Discovery learning and the spiral curriculum
Bruner favoured discovery learning, in which the teacher arranges materials and questions so that pupils find the principle themselves. The teacher guides; she does not leave the pupils alone. He also proposed the spiral curriculum: important ideas are met again and again, each time at a deeper level, like a spiral. Fractions may be met first with paper folding, later with number lines, and later still with algebraic rules.
Ausubel: meaningful learning and advance organisers
David Ausubel stressed that the most important thing in learning is what the learner already knows. Meaningful learning happens when new material is linked to ideas already in the mind, as opposed to rote learning, where facts are memorised without connection. Ausubel did not think that discovery was always needed. He supported reception learning, in which the teacher presents the material in an organised form and the learner makes sense of it by relating it to what she knows. To prepare the mind, he suggested an advance organiser: a short introduction given before the lesson that is more general and abstract than the lesson itself and shows how the new material fits what the learner already knows, for example a quick overview chart of the parts of a plant before the details are taught.
| Point | Bruner | Ausubel |
|---|---|---|
| Best way to begin | Let learners discover the principle with guidance | Present the organised material, preceded by an advance organiser |
| Key terms | Enactive, iconic, symbolic; spiral curriculum | Meaningful learning, rote learning, advance organiser |
| View of exposition | Not enough on its own | Good teaching by explanation can be meaningful |
Bruner: enactive - iconic - symbolic; discover; spiral curriculum. Ausubel: link new to old; reception learning; advance organiser first.
Worked example 1: which mode?
A teacher teaches 'half' in three steps. (i) Children fold paper strips into two equal parts. (ii) They look at a picture of a circle divided into two equal parts. (iii) They write 1/2 and read it aloud. Step 1: folding is learning through action, so enactive. Step 2: pictures are images, so iconic. Step 3: the fraction is a symbol, so symbolic. Answer: enactive, iconic, symbolic, which is the order Bruner suggested for a new idea.
Worked example 2: Bruner or Ausubel?
A science teacher begins a chapter on the human heart by showing a one-page chart that labels the four main parts of the circulatory system and says how they work together, then teaches each part in turn. Which idea is this? Step 1: the chart comes before the detailed lessons. Step 2: it is general and shows how the new learning fits into a larger picture. Step 3: that is the definition of an advance organiser. Answer: Ausubel's advance organiser. If instead the teacher gave pupils tubes and a pump and asked them to find out how liquid can be moved around a closed loop, that would be discovery learning in Bruner's style.
Comparing meaningful and rote learning
A pupil who memorises that 'the area of a rectangle is length times breadth' without knowing why will fail if the shape is slightly changed. A pupil who has covered a rectangle with unit squares and counted them has linked the formula with experience. The second is meaningful learning, remembered longer and used more flexibly.
Key takeaways: Bruner's modes are enactive, iconic and symbolic; he favoured guided discovery and the spiral curriculum; Ausubel stressed linking new material with existing knowledge, defended well-organised reception learning and introduced the advance organiser; meaningful learning beats rote learning for understanding and transfer.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is the correct order of Bruner's modes of representation for a new idea?
- Symbolic, iconic, enactive
- Iconic, symbolic, enactive
- Enactive, iconic, symbolic
- Enactive, symbolic, iconic
Show answer
Answer: C. Bruner suggested moving from action (enactive) to images (iconic) to words and symbols (symbolic).
-
2. Revisiting the same topic in later classes at increasing depth is called:
- The spiral curriculum
- Latent learning
- Rote learning
- An advance organiser
Show answer
Answer: A. Bruner's spiral curriculum returns to key ideas again and again at a higher level.
-
3. An introductory chart given before a lesson to show how new material fits what pupils already know is:
- A reinforcement schedule
- A cognitive map of a maze
- A primary law of learning
- An advance organiser
Show answer
Answer: D. Ausubel's advance organiser is general introductory material presented before the lesson to link the new to the old.
-
4. Which statement best matches Ausubel?
- All learning must be by discovery
- Meaningful learning links new information to existing knowledge
- Memorising without understanding is the best method
- Learning depends only on rewards for correct answers
Show answer
Answer: B. Ausubel's central idea is meaningful learning, in which new material is anchored to what the learner already knows.
-
5. Pupils fold paper to find halves before they draw or write fractions. This is the:
- Enactive stage
- Iconic stage
- Symbolic stage
- Latent stage
Show answer
Answer: A. Learning through physical action is Bruner's enactive mode. Drawing would be iconic and writing 1/2 would be symbolic.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.