• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Applying CPA and van Hiele to classroom situations

Identify CPA stages and van Hiele levels quickly in classroom scenarios and avoid the common traps in such questions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The foundation course introduced the concrete-pictorial-abstract (CPA) approach and the van Hiele levels. Exam-style questions rarely ask for definitions; they describe a pupil or a lesson and ask which stage or level it shows, or what the teacher should do next. This lesson gives a quick method for reading such scenarios and lists the traps that make wrong options look attractive.

Reading a van Hiele scenario quickly

Look at the pupil's words. The kind of reason the pupil gives tells the level, not the topic or the class.

Clue-to-level guide
Clue in the pupil's wordsLevel
'It looks like a door', judged by overall shapeVisualisation
Lists properties: 'four equal sides, four right angles'Analysis
Relates properties and classes: 'every square is a rectangle because...'Informal deduction
Writes proofs from definitions, axioms and theoremsFormal deduction
Compares different axiom systemsRigour

Reading a CPA scenario quickly

Ask what the pupil is working with. Real objects that can be handled (sticks, beads, bottle caps, algebra tiles, folded paper) are concrete. Drawings, tally marks, diagrams, arrays of dots and number lines drawn on paper are pictorial. Numerals, operation signs and equations alone are abstract.

Common traps

  • 'Van Hiele levels depend on age.' False: progress depends mainly on teaching and experience, so a Class 8 pupil may still be at visualisation.
  • 'Levels can be skipped.' False: they are sequential.
  • 'Concrete materials are only for small children.' False: older pupils also benefit from objects and models when an idea is new.
  • 'Handling objects is enough.' False: without discussion and a link to pictures and symbols, manipulatives become play.
  • Teaching above the pupil's level leads to memorisation without understanding, because the teacher's language does not match the pupil's thinking.

A useful habit when answering such questions is to ask two things in order. First, where is the pupil now, judged only from the evidence in the scenario? Second, what is the next small step? The best option usually moves the pupil one level or one stage forward, using an activity that fits the current level, such as sorting and describing shapes for a pupil at visualisation, or comparing property lists for a pupil at analysis. Options that jump straight to formal proof, or that keep the pupil repeating what is already secure, are usually wrong.

Worked example 1

A Class 6 pupil writes: 'A rectangle has four right angles and opposite sides equal. A square cannot be a rectangle, because a square has all four sides equal.' Reading the clue: the pupil lists properties correctly, so the pupil is beyond visualisation. But the pupil does not yet see that a square has every property of a rectangle, so a square is a special rectangle. Relating classes in this way belongs to informal deduction. Level: analysis. Next step: ask the pupil to tick, for a square, each property in the rectangle list. All are ticked, which leads to the statement 'every square is a rectangle'. This moves the pupil toward informal deduction.

Worked example 2

A Class 7 pupil cannot remember whether (a + b)² equals a² + b². CPA for an older pupil: with algebra tiles or paper cut-outs (concrete), the pupil builds a square of side a + b and finds it is made of one a × a square, one b × b square and two a × b rectangles. Next, the pupil draws the same square divided into four parts (pictorial). Finally, the pupil writes (a + b)² = a² + 2ab + b² (abstract). Check with numbers: a = 3, b = 2 gives (3 + 2)² = 25, and 9 + 12 + 4 = 25, while a² + b² = 13 is wrong. Applying it: (x + 3)² = x² + 6x + 9. The example shows that CPA is a tool for any new abstract idea, not only for primary arithmetic.

Level comes from the pupil's kind of reasoning, not age or class. Stage comes from what the pupil works with: objects, pictures, or symbols.

Key takeaways

To name a van Hiele level, read the reason the pupil gives: appearance, listed properties, relations between properties and classes, proof, or comparison of systems. To name a CPA stage, see whether the pupil works with objects, pictures or symbols. Reject options that tie levels to age, allow skipping, restrict concrete work to young children, or treat handling objects as enough without talk.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A pupil says: 'All squares are rectangles, because a square has four right angles and its opposite sides are equal.' Which van Hiele level does this show?

    1. Visualisation
    2. Informal deduction
    3. Analysis
    4. Rigour
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The pupil relates two classes of shapes through their properties, which is informal deduction.

  2. 2. Which statement about van Hiele levels is correct?

    1. Every pupil reaches formal deduction by about age twelve
    2. A bright pupil can skip the analysis level
    3. Progress depends mainly on teaching and experience, so pupils of the same age can be at different levels
    4. The levels are reached in any order
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The levels are sequential and depend mainly on instruction and experience rather than age.

  3. 3. A pupil draws a number line in a notebook and jumps along it to add 8 and 5. Which CPA stage is this?

    1. Concrete
    2. Abstract
    3. Pictorial
    4. Formal deduction
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A drawn number line is a representation on paper, which is the pictorial stage.

  4. 4. A teacher teaches Class 8 using proofs from axioms, but the pupils can only describe shapes by listing properties. What is the most likely result?

    1. Pupils jump directly to formal deduction
    2. Pupils fall back to the visualisation level permanently
    3. The pupils' level makes no difference to learning
    4. Pupils memorise the proofs without understanding, because teaching is above their level
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Teaching pitched at a level above the pupils' thinking is not understood and tends to produce rote learning.

  5. 5. Using the area model of a square with side x + 3, what is (x + 3)²?

    1. x² + 9
    2. x² + 3x + 9
    3. x² + 6x + 6
    4. x² + 6x + 9
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The square splits into x², two rectangles of 3x each, and a 3 × 3 square: x² + 3x + 3x + 9 = x² + 6x + 9.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery