- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Word problems: reading, bar models and the keyword trap
Practise a step-by-step routine for word problems: rephrase, draw a bar model, choose the operation from the structure, estimate, solve and check, and avoid the keyword trap.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many pupils who calculate well fail word problems. The difficulty is rarely the arithmetic; it is turning words into mathematics. Competitive-exam questions on this topic ask what a pupil's wrong approach shows, or which strategy a teacher should teach. This lesson gives a routine, a diagram that works for many problems and a warning about a popular but weak strategy.
A routine for word problems
- Read the problem twice and say it in your own words.
- Picture it: draw a quick diagram or bar model, labelling the known and the unknown.
- Decide what the problem is about (joining, comparing, equal groups, sharing) and so which operation fits.
- Estimate the size of the answer.
- Solve carefully.
- Check against the story and write the answer with its unit.
The keyword trap
Some pupils are taught to look for keywords: 'altogether' means add, 'left' means subtract, 'more' means add. This works for easy problems and fails on others, because the same word can need different operations. The pupil is reacting to a word instead of reading the situation. Teach pupils to ask 'What is happening in the story?' rather than 'Which word do I see?'.
Bar models
A bar model draws each quantity as a bar whose length shows its size. In a part-whole problem, two short bars sit under one long bar for the total. In a comparison problem, two bars of different lengths are drawn one above the other and the difference is the gap. When one quantity is a multiple of another, the bars are divided into equal units. The picture shows which quantity is unknown and which operation finds it.
Worked example 1: the keyword trap
Problem: 'Ravi has 12 marbles. He has 5 more than Asha. How many marbles does Asha have?' Keyword approach: 'more' means add, so 12 + 5 = 17. Bar model: draw Ravi's bar of 12. Asha's bar is shorter by 5, because Ravi has more. The gap is 5. Operation: Asha's number is 12 - 5 = 7. Check: if Asha has 7, then Ravi has 7 + 5 = 12, as the story says. The word 'more' appears but the correct operation is subtraction, so the keyword rule fails here.
Worked example 2: a comparison with units
Problem: 'A shopkeeper sold 3 times as many notebooks on Monday as on Tuesday. In the two days together he sold 156 notebooks. How many were sold on Monday?' Bar model: let Tuesday be 1 unit. Monday is 3 units. Together they are 1 + 3 = 4 units. Working: 4 units = 156, so 1 unit = 156 / 4 = 39. Monday = 3 x 39 = 117. Check: Tuesday is 39, Monday is 117, and 117 + 39 = 156. Also 117 is 3 times 39. Answer: 117 notebooks. These numbers are made up for practice.
Worked example 3: interpreting a remainder
Problem: '250 eggs are packed in trays that hold 30 eggs each.' (a) How many trays are completely filled? (b) How many trays are needed to hold all the eggs? Working: 250 / 30 = 8 remainder 10, since 8 x 30 = 240 and 250 - 240 = 10. (a) 8 full trays. (b) The 10 leftover eggs need another tray, so 9 trays. The same division gives two different answers, and the story decides which.
| Type of problem | Typical picture | Common error |
|---|---|---|
| Joining or separating | Whole bar with two parts | Using the keyword, not the story |
| Comparison | Two bars, with a gap | Adding when the gap is subtracted |
| Equal groups | Bar of equal units | Forgetting to find one unit first |
| Division with a remainder | Groups with a few left over | Rounding the wrong way |
Read the story, not the keyword. Draw a bar model, estimate, solve and check the answer against the story.
Key takeaways
- Failure in word problems is usually a reading and modelling difficulty, not an arithmetic difficulty.
- Keywords are unreliable because the same word can fit different operations.
- Bar models show part-whole and comparison structures and help find the unit.
- The context decides how a remainder is used.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Meena has 15 stickers. She has 4 more than Kiran. How many does Kiran have?' What is the answer?
- 19
- 60
- 11
- 3
Show answer
Answer: C. Meena's number is 4 more than Kiran's, so Kiran has 15 - 4 = 11. The word 'more' does not mean add here.
-
2. Why is teaching pupils to circle keywords a weak strategy?
- The same word can need different operations
- Keywords never appear in word problems at all
- Pupils cannot remember so many keywords
- It slows down the reading of the numbers
Show answer
Answer: A. Pupils must understand the situation; a word alone can mislead, as in 'more' above.
-
3. Ages: Anil is 4 times as old as his son. Together they are 45 years. How old is the son?
- 36 years
- 11 years
- 15 years
- 9 years
Show answer
Answer: D. 5 units = 45, so 1 unit = 9. The son is 9 and Anil is 36. Check: 9 + 36 = 45.
-
4. 200 pupils go on a trip in buses that carry 45 each. How many buses are needed?
- 4
- 5
- 4.4
- 6
Show answer
Answer: B. 200 / 45 = 4 remainder 20. The 20 pupils left need another bus, so 5 buses.
-
5. What does a bar model mainly help a pupil to do?
- See the structure and which quantity is unknown
- Avoid reading the problem a second time
- Skip the checking step at the very end
- Guess the operation from a keyword in it
Show answer
Answer: A. A diagram shows how the quantities are related, which tells what to calculate.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.