- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Error analysis of children's written work
Read a set of a pupil's answers, find the rule behind repeated errors, predict the next error and name the misconception.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation course separated slips from misconceptions. This lesson turns that idea into a working skill: reading a page of a pupil's work the way a doctor reads symptoms. Pedagogy questions in competitive exams often show a pupil's answers and ask what the error is, what it reveals, or what the teacher should do next. The method below answers all three in a few steps, and it is the same method a teacher uses in a real classroom.
A routine for error analysis
- Collect several answers, not one. A single wrong answer may be a slip; the same kind of error across items is evidence of a rule.
- Compare right and wrong answers. Ask what the wrong ones have in common that the right ones lack (for example, regrouping is needed only in the wrong ones).
- Write down the pupil's rule in words, as if the pupil were following it faithfully.
- Test the rule by predicting the pupil's answer to a new item. If the prediction matches, the diagnosis is strong.
- Talk with the pupil. Asking 'How did you get this?' confirms the rule and shows whether the pupil's reasoning is partly sound.
Most systematic errors are not random carelessness. They are sensible-looking rules that the pupil has built from incomplete understanding, often by over-applying something that worked earlier. That is why they repeat, and why simply marking them wrong rarely removes them.
Common error patterns
| Topic | What the pupil does | Underlying idea missing |
|---|---|---|
| Writing numbers | Writes 'three hundred and five' as 3005 | Place value: the 5 belongs in the ones place of 305 |
| Addition | Writes the whole column sum: 47 + 38 = 715 | Regrouping ten ones as one ten |
| Subtraction across zero | Cannot exchange in 304 - 158 | A hundred can be exchanged for ten tens |
| Multiplication | Does not shift the second partial product | The tens digit of the multiplier stands for tens |
| Division | Leaves out the zero in a quotient: 612 ÷ 6 = 12 | Each place in the quotient must be filled |
| Decimals | Thinks 0.25 > 0.5 because 25 > 5 | Decimal places are tenths, hundredths, not whole numbers |
Notice that the third column always names an idea, not a procedure. Remedy aims at the idea. A pupil who writes 715 for 47 + 38 does not need to be told 'carry the one' again; the pupil needs to see why ten ones become one ten.
Worked example 1
A Class 3 pupil writes: 47 + 38 = 715, 63 + 29 = 812, 54 + 12 = 66. Step 1, compare: the third answer is right and needs no regrouping; the first two are wrong and both need regrouping. Step 2, find the rule: in 47 + 38 the pupil adds 7 + 8 = 15 and writes 15 in full, then adds 4 + 3 = 7 and writes 7 in front, giving 715. In 63 + 29 the pupil writes 3 + 9 = 12, then 6 + 2 = 8, giving 812. The rule is 'add each column and write the whole result'. Step 3, predict: for 38 + 45 the pupil should write 8 + 5 = 13 and 3 + 4 = 7, so 713 (the correct answer is 83). Diagnosis: a misconception about regrouping, not a slip. The correct answers are 85 and 92. Next step: return to bundles of ten sticks so the pupil physically exchanges ten loose sticks for one bundle.
Worked example 2
A Class 5 pupil writes: 612 ÷ 6 = 12, 824 ÷ 4 = 26, 936 ÷ 3 = 312. Compare: the third is right; in the first two, one step of the division has a dividend smaller than the divisor (1 ÷ 6 and 2 ÷ 4). Rule: when a step cannot be divided, the pupil skips it instead of writing 0 in the quotient. Correct answers: 612 ÷ 6 = 102 (6 hundreds ÷ 6 = 1 hundred, 1 ten ÷ 6 = 0 tens, 12 ones ÷ 6 = 2), and 824 ÷ 4 = 206. Quick check the pupil can use: estimation. 612 ÷ 6 must be about 600 ÷ 6 = 100, so 12 is far too small. Teaching pupils to estimate first is one of the best defences against this error.
Do not stop at 'wrong'. Collect several answers, state the pupil's rule, predict the next error, and confirm by asking the pupil to explain.
Key takeaways
Errors that repeat follow a rule the pupil believes. Find the rule by comparing right and wrong answers, test it by prediction, and confirm it in conversation. Each error pattern points to a missing idea, such as regrouping, place value or the meaning of decimal places, and that idea, not the procedure, is what the teacher re-teaches. Estimation is a useful self-check for pupils. The next lesson shows how to plan remedial teaching once the error is diagnosed.
Check your understanding
-
1. A pupil works 34 × 12 as 34 × 2 = 68, 34 × 1 = 34, then 68 + 34 = 102. What is the error?
- The pupil does not know the multiplication facts
- The pupil added instead of multiplying throughout
- It is a one-off slip, so no pattern exists
- The second partial product is not shifted: 34 × 1 ten is 340, so the answer is 408
Show answer
Answer: D. 34 × 12 = 34 × 2 + 34 × 10 = 68 + 340 = 408. The pupil treated the tens digit 1 as ones, which is a place-value error in the algorithm, not a fact error.
-
2. A pupil says 0.125 is greater than 0.3 'because 125 is more than 3'. Which misconception is this?
- Believing multiplication always makes a number bigger
- Not knowing the multiplication tables
- Treating the digits after the decimal point as a whole number ('longer is larger')
- Adding the denominators of fractions
Show answer
Answer: C. 0.3 is 3 tenths = 300 thousandths, which is more than 125 thousandths. The pupil compared 125 and 3 as whole numbers.
-
3. A pupil writes whole column sums without regrouping (47 + 38 = 715). What will the pupil most likely write for 58 + 67?
- 125
- 1115
- 115
- 1215
Show answer
Answer: B. Following the pupil's rule: 8 + 7 = 15 is written in full, then 5 + 6 = 11 is written in front, giving 1115. The correct sum is 125.
-
4. Why should a teacher look at several items before deciding that a pupil has a misconception?
- Because one wrong answer always means the pupil cannot learn the topic
- Because marks must be averaged before any diagnosis
- A single error may be a slip; the same error across items shows a consistent wrong rule
- Because pupils never make the same error twice
Show answer
Answer: C. Diagnosis needs a pattern. One wrong answer cannot tell a slip from a misconception; repeated errors of the same kind can.
-
5. A pupil writes 408 ÷ 4 = 12. What is the error and the correct quotient?
- The pupil divides the wrong digits; the answer is 112
- The pupil leaves out the zero in the quotient; the answer is 102
- The pupil made a tables slip; the answer is 120
- The pupil leaves out the zero; the answer is 120
Show answer
Answer: B. 4 hundreds ÷ 4 = 1 hundred, 0 tens ÷ 4 = 0 tens, 8 ones ÷ 4 = 2 ones, so 102. Check: 102 × 4 = 408. The pupil skipped the 0 in the tens place.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.