- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Error analysis set 2: division by fractions, decimals and measurement
Practise the error-analysis routine on new patterns: dividing by a fraction, adding decimals, converting units and adding times, and learn the correct idea behind each repeated error.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The first lesson of this course taught a routine for reading a pupil's written work: compare right and wrong answers, state the pupil's rule, predict the next error and confirm by talking. This lesson gives a second practice set on topics that competitive exams like to use: division by a fraction, decimals, units of measurement and time. For each pattern you will see the pupil's rule, the missing idea and a quick test the pupil can use.
Patterns to recognise
| What the pupil writes | The pupil's rule | The missing idea |
|---|---|---|
| 6 / (1/2) = 3 | Divides by the denominator and ignores the fraction | Dividing by a number less than 1 gives a larger answer: there are 12 halves in 6 |
| 0.5 + 0.25 = 0.30 | Adds 5 and 25 as whole numbers | Add like places: 5 tenths + 2 tenths + 5 hundredths = 0.75 |
| 1 m squared = 100 cm squared | Uses the length conversion for area | A square metre is 100 cm by 100 cm, which is 10000 square cm |
| 2 h 45 min + 1 h 30 min = 3 h 75 min | Adds hours and minutes separately without regrouping | 60 minutes make 1 hour, not 100 |
| Area of a triangle with base 10 cm and height 6 cm = 60 square cm | Multiplies base and height | A triangle is half of a rectangle on the same base and height |
Notice that the last column again names an idea. Giving the pupil another rule to follow does not repair it; a model or a picture does.
Worked example 1: dividing by a fraction
A pupil writes 4 / (1/2) = 2, 3 / (1/3) = 1, 6 / (1/2) = 3, and 8 / 2 = 4 (a correct whole-number item). Compare: the whole-number item is right; the three fraction items are wrong. Rule: the pupil divides by the denominator only: 4 / 2 = 2, 3 / 3 = 1, 6 / 2 = 3. Correct answers: 4 / (1/2) = 8, because each whole has 2 halves and 4 x 2 = 8; 3 / (1/3) = 9; 6 / (1/2) = 12. Prediction: for 5 / (1/4) the pupil would write 5 / 4 and give 1 and a bit, whereas the answer is 20. Remedy: ask 'How many half-rupee coins make Rs 4?' Pupils count 8 and see that the answer is larger than 4, which contradicts their rule. An estimate also helps: dividing by less than 1 must give more than the starting number.
Worked example 2: adding times
A pupil writes 2 h 45 min + 1 h 30 min = 3 h 75 min, 1 h 50 min + 2 h 40 min = 3 h 90 min, and 1 h 10 min + 2 h 20 min = 3 h 30 min (correct). Compare: the right item has minutes below 60 in the answer; the others have 75 and 90. Rule: hours and minutes are added separately, and minutes are never changed into hours. Correct answers: 2 h 45 min + 1 h 30 min = 255 minutes = 4 h 15 min, and 1 h 50 min + 2 h 40 min = 270 minutes = 4 h 30 min. Prediction: for 3 h 45 min + 1 h 25 min the pupil would write 4 h 70 min, but the correct answer is 310 minutes, which is 5 h 10 min. Remedy: use a clock face or a number line marked in minutes and ask the pupil to jump to the next full hour first: from 3 h 45 min, 15 minutes reach 4 h, and the remaining 10 minutes of the 25 give 4 h 10 min; adding the 1 hour gives 5 h 10 min.
Quick checks pupils can use
- Estimate first: is the answer bigger or smaller than the numbers given?
- Line up the places in decimals, with the decimal points one under the other.
- Draw the unit: a square of 100 cm by 100 cm shows why a square metre is not 100 square cm.
- Check the base: time is in 60s, not 100s.
Name the pupil's rule, name the missing idea, predict the next error, then teach the idea with a model, not with a new rule.
Key takeaways
- Repeated errors with fractions, decimals, units and time come from sensible-looking rules used in the wrong place.
- Dividing by a fraction less than 1 gives a larger result; time works in base 60; area units need two conversions.
- Estimating and drawing are the best self-checks for pupils.
Check your understanding
-
1. A pupil writes 10 / (1/5) = 2. What is the pupil's rule, and what is the correct answer?
- Multiplies by the denominator; the answer is 2
- Divides by the denominator only; the answer is 50
- Subtracts the fraction from 10; the answer is 9.8
- Divides by the numerator; the answer is 10
Show answer
Answer: B. The pupil does 10 / 5 = 2. Correctly, there are 5 fifths in each whole, and 10 x 5 = 50.
-
2. A pupil writes 0.4 + 0.35 = 0.39. What is the correct answer?
- 0.39
- 0.739
- 0.075
- 0.75
Show answer
Answer: D. The pupil added 4 and 35 as whole numbers. In hundredths, 40 + 35 = 75, so 0.75.
-
3. How many square centimetres are there in 3 square metres?
- 30000
- 300
- 3000
- 300000
Show answer
Answer: A. One square metre is 100 cm x 100 cm = 10000 square cm, so 3 square metres are 30000 square cm.
-
4. A pupil writes 1 h 40 min + 1 h 35 min = 2 h 75 min. What is the correct answer?
- 2 h 75 min
- 3 h 5 min
- 3 h 15 min
- 2 h 15 min
Show answer
Answer: C. 100 + 95 = 195 minutes, which is 3 hours 15 minutes.
-
5. A pupil gives the area of a triangle of base 8 cm and height 5 cm as 40 square cm. Which idea is missing?
- Area is measured in cm, not in square cm units
- The base of a triangle must be longer than the height
- Area is found by adding the base and the height together
- A triangle is half of a rectangle with the same base and height
Show answer
Answer: D. The correct area is half of 8 x 5, which is 20 square cm.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.