Revision notes

Pedagogy of Mathematics: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Error analysis of children's written work

Error patterns and what they reveal
TopicWhat the pupil doesUnderlying idea missing
Writing numbersWrites 'three hundred and five' as 3005Place value: the 5 belongs in the ones place of 305
AdditionWrites the whole column sum: 47 + 38 = 715Regrouping ten ones as one ten
Subtraction across zeroCannot exchange in 304 - 158A hundred can be exchanged for ten tens
MultiplicationDoes not shift the second partial productThe tens digit of the multiplier stands for tens
DivisionLeaves out the zero in a quotient: 612 ÷ 6 = 12Each place in the quotient must be filled
DecimalsThinks 0.25 > 0.5 because 25 > 5Decimal places are tenths, hundredths, not whole numbers

Do not stop at 'wrong'. Collect several answers, state the pupil's rule, predict the next error, and confirm by asking the pupil to explain.

Errors that repeat follow a rule the pupil believes. Find the rule by comparing right and wrong answers, test it by prediction, and confirm it in conversation. Each error pattern points to a missing idea, such as regrouping, place value or the meaning of decimal places, and that idea, not the procedure, is what the teacher re-teaches. Estimation is a useful self-check for pupils. The next lesson shows how to plan remedial teaching once the error is diagnosed.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Remedial teaching: diagnose, re-teach, re-check

A diagnostic subtraction test
Item typeExampleRavi's score
No regrouping586 - 2434 / 4
Regrouping once572 - 2484 / 4
Regrouping across zero304 - 1580 / 4

Remedial teaching = diagnose the specific gap, teach it differently, then re-check with new items. Same lesson, same way, louder is not remediation.

Remedial teaching starts from diagnosis and targets one specific gap. Diagnostic tests group items by sub-skill so the pattern of scores locates the difficulty. The re-teaching uses a new approach, often going back to concrete materials or pictures, and the cycle ends with re-assessment on fresh items. Groups are flexible and feedback is supportive.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Applying CPA and van Hiele to classroom situations

Clue-to-level guide
Clue in the pupil's wordsLevel
'It looks like a door', judged by overall shapeVisualisation
Lists properties: 'four equal sides, four right angles'Analysis
Relates properties and classes: 'every square is a rectangle because...'Informal deduction
Writes proofs from definitions, axioms and theoremsFormal deduction
Compares different axiom systemsRigour

Level comes from the pupil's kind of reasoning, not age or class. Stage comes from what the pupil works with: objects, pictures, or symbols.

To name a van Hiele level, read the reason the pupil gives: appearance, listed properties, relations between properties and classes, proof, or comparison of systems. To name a CPA stage, see whether the pupil works with objects, pictures or symbols. Reject options that tie levels to age, allow skipping, restrict concrete work to young children, or treat handling objects as enough without talk.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Teaching methods in practice: induction, deduction, analysis, synthesis and Polya

Clue-to-method guide
What happens in classMethod
Pupils try many cases, notice a pattern, state a ruleInductive
Teacher states a rule or formula; pupils apply itDeductive
Reasoning starts from what is to be proved and asks 'what would make this true?'Analytic
Reasoning starts from what is given and moves step by step to the resultSynthetic

Induce to discover, deduce to justify and apply. Analyse to find a proof, synthesise to write it. Always look back: does the answer fit every condition?

Name a method from what is done in class: cases to rule is inductive, rule to cases is deductive, unknown backwards is analytic, known forwards is synthetic. Good teaching combines them. Polya's steps give pupils a plan, and working backwards is a strong strategy when the final result is known. Train the 'look back' habit.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Assessment and maths anxiety in practice

Raises anxietyReduces anxiety
Timed tests with scores read aloudLow-stakes practice with private feedback
Only one 'right' method acceptedSeveral methods discussed and valued
Mistakes treated as failureMistakes discussed as information
Comparing pupils publiclyPraising effort and strategy, comparing with one's own past work

Ask for the reason, not only the answer. Credit method and understanding separately. Treat mistakes as information and keep the stakes low while pupils learn.

Open items and requests for explanation reveal understanding; closed items check it quickly. Assessment is formative when it changes the next step of teaching. Rubrics give fair credit and show exactly what to teach next. Anxiety is reduced by low-stakes practice, valuing several methods, and treating errors as information rather than failure.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Error analysis set 2: division by fractions, decimals and measurement

Five error patterns and the idea each one lacks
What the pupil writesThe pupil's ruleThe missing idea
6 / (1/2) = 3Divides by the denominator and ignores the fractionDividing by a number less than 1 gives a larger answer: there are 12 halves in 6
0.5 + 0.25 = 0.30Adds 5 and 25 as whole numbersAdd like places: 5 tenths + 2 tenths + 5 hundredths = 0.75
1 m squared = 100 cm squaredUses the length conversion for areaA square metre is 100 cm by 100 cm, which is 10000 square cm
2 h 45 min + 1 h 30 min = 3 h 75 minAdds hours and minutes separately without regrouping60 minutes make 1 hour, not 100
Area of a triangle with base 10 cm and height 6 cm = 60 square cmMultiplies base and heightA triangle is half of a rectangle on the same base and height

Name the pupil's rule, name the missing idea, predict the next error, then teach the idea with a model, not with a new rule.

  • Repeated errors with fractions, decimals, units and time come from sensible-looking rules used in the wrong place.
  • Dividing by a fraction less than 1 gives a larger result; time works in base 60; area units need two conversions.
  • Estimating and drawing are the best self-checks for pupils.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

Word problems: reading, bar models and the keyword trap

Type of problemTypical pictureCommon error
Joining or separatingWhole bar with two partsUsing the keyword, not the story
ComparisonTwo bars, with a gapAdding when the gap is subtracted
Equal groupsBar of equal unitsForgetting to find one unit first
Division with a remainderGroups with a few left overRounding the wrong way

Read the story, not the keyword. Draw a bar model, estimate, solve and check the answer against the story.

  • Failure in word problems is usually a reading and modelling difficulty, not an arithmetic difficulty.
  • Keywords are unreliable because the same word can fit different operations.
  • Bar models show part-whole and comparison structures and help find the unit.
  • The context decides how a remainder is used.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Objectives and lesson-plan questions: spotting good and poor plans

A common sequence of lesson-plan steps
PartWhat the teacher doesWhat pupils do
ObjectivesStates specific, observable outcomesNot shown to pupils in detail
Previous knowledgeChecks prerequisite ideas with quick questionsAnswer and recall
Introduction (motivation)Links the topic to a real situation or a puzzleBecome interested and curious
Presentation (development)Guides pupils to the new idea with examples and materialsObserve, try, discuss, discover
Practice and applicationSets graded tasks and moves around the classSolve problems, alone and in pairs
EvaluationAsks short questions or a quick quizShow what they understand
AssignmentGives follow-up work linked to the objectivesPractise at home

A good plan has specific objectives, checks what pupils already know, keeps pupils active, moves from concrete to abstract and ends with evaluation, all within the time.

  • The usual order is objectives, previous knowledge, introduction, presentation, practice, evaluation and assignment.
  • Herbartian steps are preparation, presentation, comparison, generalisation and application.
  • A weak plan lacks objectives, pupil activity, concrete work or evaluation.
  • Add up the minutes to check that the plan fits the period.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

Item analysis and test statistics: facility value and simple calculations

StatisticFormulaReading the result
Facility valueNumber correct / number attemptingNear 1: easy; near 0: hard
Discrimination index(U - L) / nPositive: separates; zero: does not; negative: check the item
Class meanSum of scores / number of pupilsAverage performance of the class

Facility value tells how easy an item was; the discrimination index tells whether it separates strong from weak pupils. A negative D is a warning.

  • Facility value is the proportion correct; discrimination is (U - L) / n.
  • A negative discrimination index means the item should be checked.
  • A blueprint spreads marks across topics and objectives before the test is written.
  • Validity asks whether the test measures what it should; reliability asks whether results are consistent.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery