- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Internalization and the two planes: sequence and 'which comes first' questions
Answer ordering questions on the social plane before the individual plane, on the sequence of social, private and inner speech, and on how internalization differs from simple copying, without reversing the order.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A whole group of exam questions asks 'which comes first?' or asks you to put steps in order. In Vygotsky's theory the order matters, and the usual wrong options reverse it. If you hold three fixed orders in your head, most of these questions take seconds. This lesson fixes the orders and practises the traps.
Three orders to remember
| Topic | Vygotsky's order | What a trap option says |
|---|---|---|
| Where a higher function appears | First between people (social, interpsychological), then inside the child (individual, intrapsychological) | First inside the child, then shared |
| Kinds of speech | Social speech, then private speech, then inner speech | Inner speech first, then spoken |
| Help in a task | Adult does it or leads, then they do it together, then the child does it alone with the adult watching, then fully alone | The child starts alone and the adult joins at the end |
Outside first, inside later: social plane, then individual plane. Social speech, then private speech, then inner speech.
Internalization is the process by which the shared activity becomes the child's own. It is not a copy: Vygotsky stressed that the activity is transformed as it moves inward. The child does not just store what the adult did; the child rebuilds it in a form that works inside the head, often shorter and quieter. Repeating a method without understanding it is imitation, not internalization.
Worked example 1: order the steps
Arrange these steps in the order Vygotsky's theory predicts, for a child learning to count coins. (a) The child counts silently and tells the total. (b) The mother counts aloud while the child watches. (c) The child counts aloud while the mother checks. Working: the shared activity comes first (b), then the child speaks it aloud with support (c), and finally it is silent and independent (a). The order is b, c, a.
Worked example 2: a statement check
Statement: 'A higher mental function appears first inside the child and is then shared with others.' Working: this reverses the order. Vygotsky said that each higher function appears twice, first on the social plane and later on the individual plane. The statement is false.
Worked example 3: the Piaget reversal
Compare the two thinkers on speech. Piaget described egocentric speech, which is high in young children and declines as they become less egocentric and more social. Vygotsky described private speech which grows out of social speech and turns into inner speech, a thinking tool. The two sequences run in opposite directions: Piaget's goes from self-centred to social, Vygotsky's goes from social to self-directed. A question that says 'speech begins as private and later becomes social' describes Piaget, not Vygotsky.
Worked example 4: is it internalization?
Two pupils are shown a method for long division aloud. Anil later does the same sums silently in his head, in a shortened form that he describes in his own words. Binod learns the steps as a chant and repeats it without knowing what each step means. Working: Anil has internalized the method, since he has rebuilt it in his own form. Binod has memorised it, and the activity has not been transformed. A teacher aiming at internalization asks pupils to explain the steps.
Traps
- Reversing the planes: 'individual first, social later' is wrong.
- Saying private speech is 'silent': private speech is spoken aloud; the silent form is inner speech.
- Treating internalization as copying: it involves transformation.
- Using Piaget's order (egocentric to social) for Vygotsky.
Key takeaways: the social plane comes first and the individual plane second. Speech runs social, private, inner. Help runs from the adult doing it, to doing it together, to the child alone. Internalization transforms the activity. Piaget's order of speech is the opposite of Vygotsky's.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to Vygotsky, where does a higher mental function appear first?
- Inside the child, on the individual plane
- Between people, on the social plane
- In the child's genes before birth
- In silent inner speech only
Show answer
Answer: B. Each higher function appears first on the social (interpsychological) plane and later on the individual (intrapsychological) plane.
-
2. Which is the correct order of speech in Vygotsky's theory?
- Inner speech, then private speech, then social speech
- Private speech, then social speech, then inner speech
- Social speech, then inner speech, then private speech
- Social speech, then private speech, then inner speech
Show answer
Answer: D. Speech starts as social, becomes spoken self-talk (private speech) and finally silent inner speech.
-
3. Which description fits internalization?
- Rebuilding a shared activity in the child's own form
- Copying the adult's words exactly
- Doing the task only when the adult is present
- Learning facts by repeated chanting
Show answer
Answer: A. Internalization transforms a shared activity into the child's own way of thinking; it is not simple copying.
-
4. Which statement describes Piaget's view of speech rather than Vygotsky's?
- Private speech turns into silent inner speech
- Speech helps the child plan and control action
- Egocentric speech fades as the child becomes social
- Social speech comes before private speech
Show answer
Answer: C. Piaget saw egocentric speech as fading with growth. Vygotsky saw private speech as useful and turning into inner speech.
-
5. A mother counts coins aloud, the child joins in, and later the child counts silently alone. What is this sequence an example of?
- Accommodation of an existing schema
- Operant shaping of a response
- Decline of egocentric speech
- Internalization of a shared activity
Show answer
Answer: D. A shared activity that becomes the child's own silent skill is internalization, moving from the social plane to the individual plane.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.