- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Scaffolding scenarios: what counts and what does not
Judge whether a teacher's help counts as scaffolding, apply the more-help-when-stuck rule, identify the More Knowledgeable Other, and avoid the common scaffolding traps.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Scaffolding questions usually describe a teacher or parent helping a child and ask which description fits. The trick is to know the features that make help count as scaffolding, so you can rule out options that only look helpful.
Four features of genuine scaffolding
- It is in the ZPD: the learner could not do the task alone but can with this help.
- The learner does the work: the helper supports; the learner performs.
- It is adjusted: more help when the learner is stuck, less when the learner is succeeding.
- It fades: support is reduced and finally handed over.
The third feature is worth practising. Good scaffolding is contingent: the helper watches the learner and responds. If a hint does not work, the helper offers a more specific hint or shows a step. If the learner manages a step easily, the helper pulls back. Help that is the same whatever the learner does is not well-adjusted scaffolding.
What is not scaffolding
- Doing the task for the child.
- Giving the answer straight away every time.
- Help that never reduces as skill grows.
- Leaving the child completely alone on a task beyond the ZPD.
- Rewards or marks on their own, with no guidance on how to do the task.
Worked example 1: which description is scaffolding?
A child is learning to tie shoelaces. (i) The father ties them every morning. (ii) The father ties one loop while the child watches, then guides the child's hands on the second loop, then only says the steps aloud, then watches. (iii) The father tells the child to work it out alone. (iv) The father gives a sweet whenever the shoes are tied, whoever tied them. Working: (i) does the task for the child. (iii) gives no help on a task beyond the child's independent level. (iv) is a reward with no guidance. (ii) supports, keeps the child doing the work, and fades from modelling to guidance to words to watching. Answer: (ii).
Worked example 2: adjusting the help
A pupil is stuck on 'Find 25% of 240'. The teacher asks, 'What fraction is 25%?' The pupil says one quarter but still cannot continue. What is the best next move? Working: the first hint was not enough, so contingent scaffolding gives a more specific hint, not the full answer and not silence: 'How do you find a quarter of a number?' The pupil divides by 4: 240 / 4 = 60. Answer: 60, reached by the pupil, with help increased one step only when needed.
Worked example 3: who is the MKO?
In a mixed group, Kabir (Class 8) cannot draw a bar graph on the computer. Zoya (Class 6) has done it many times and guides him. Working: the MKO is whoever knows more about this task, so Zoya is the MKO, though she is younger. Age, rank and title do not decide the MKO.
Scaffolding in a group works the same way. A teacher moving between groups gives a hint to one group that is stuck, asks a probing question of a group that is nearly there, and simply watches a group that is succeeding. The amount of help differs from group to group because the need differs. That variety is a sign of good scaffolding, not of unfairness.
Two fact traps
First, the term scaffolding was introduced by Wood, Bruner and Ross, not by Vygotsky; an option crediting Vygotsky with the word is wrong. Second, the label More Knowledgeable Other is the one textbooks use; an option saying the MKO must be an adult or a trained teacher is wrong.
Scaffolding: the learner does the work, the help fits the need (more when stuck, less when succeeding), and the help fades.
Key takeaways
Test any described help against four features: in the ZPD, learner does the work, adjusted to the need, fading. Doing the task, giving answers, never reducing help and pure rewards are not scaffolding. When a hint fails, make the next hint more specific rather than giving the answer. Next, the role of language and private speech.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is the best example of scaffolding?
- A teacher writes all the answers on the board for copying
- A teacher models one sum, solves the next together with the pupil, then lets the pupil try alone with occasional hints
- A teacher gives a hard sum and says nothing
- A teacher awards a star for every page filled, without checking the work
Show answer
Answer: B. Modelling, joint work and then independent work with hints is supportive and fading. The others do the work, give no help, or reward without guidance.
-
2. A pupil cannot answer after a general hint. Under contingent scaffolding, what should the teacher do next?
- Give a more specific hint
- Give the full answer at once
- Stop helping completely
- Move to a much harder question
Show answer
Answer: A. Contingent scaffolding increases help one step when the learner is stuck, and decreases it when the learner succeeds.
-
3. Which statement is a trap about scaffolding?
- Vygotsky himself introduced the word 'scaffolding'
- Scaffolding is reduced as skill grows
- Scaffolding supports work in the ZPD
- A peer can provide scaffolding
Show answer
Answer: A. The term was introduced by Wood, Bruner and Ross. The other three statements are correct.
-
4. A teacher keeps giving the same full step-by-step help every day, long after pupils can do the task alone. What is missing?
- Any form of help
- A task in the ZPD at the start
- Fading of support
- A More Knowledgeable Other
Show answer
Answer: C. Scaffolding should be withdrawn as skill grows. Help that never reduces keeps learners dependent.
-
5. To find 20% of 350, a pupil is helped with the hint 'What is 10% of 350?' She says 35. What is 20% of 350?
- 35
- 175
- 700
- 70
Show answer
Answer: D. 10% of 350 is 35, so 20% is 2 x 35 = 70. The hint broke the task into a step the pupil could do.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.