• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Private speech and language questions: avoiding the Piaget swap

Answer questions on private speech, inner speech, language and thought and cultural tools, and avoid swapping Vygotsky's views with Piaget's.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questions on language are where Vygotsky and Piaget are most often swapped. Both noticed that young children talk to themselves; they explained it very differently. If you fix the contrast firmly, a whole family of questions becomes quick marks.

One behaviour, two explanations

Self-talk compared
PointPiagetVygotsky
Name for self-talkEgocentric speechPrivate speech
What it showsThe child cannot yet take others' viewpointThe child is guiding his or her own actions
What happens to itFades away as egocentrism declinesTurns inward and becomes inner speech
Teacher's responseExpect it to disappearAllow it; it supports thinking

Language and thought

Vygotsky held that thought and speech have different roots. Before they join, a baby shows thought without words and speech sounds without thought. In early childhood the two lines meet, and from then on language becomes a tool for thinking. Books give slightly different ages for this meeting, so exams usually test the idea, not an exact age. The direction of influence also matters: for Vygotsky, language shapes and organises thought; it is not just a label stuck on finished ideas.

Cultural tools: physical and psychological

Vygotsky distinguished tools that act on the outside world (a plough, a hammer) from tools that act on the mind: language, signs, number systems, writing, maps, diagrams, mnemonics. The second group are often called psychological or symbolic tools. Exams may ask you to pick the psychological tool from a list; choose the one made of symbols.

Worked example 1: interpret the self-talk

During a hard jigsaw, Aman, aged five, says aloud, 'Blue piece... no, turn it round... there.' His teacher must explain this in Vygotsky's terms. Working: the talk is directed at himself and guides his actions, and it appears during a hard task. In Vygotsky's terms this is private speech serving self-regulation, which is expected to increase with difficulty. Calling it 'egocentric speech showing he cannot see others' viewpoints' would be Piaget's explanation. Answer: private speech for self-regulation.

Worked example 2: what should the teacher do?

A Class 1 teacher is annoyed that children whisper to themselves while doing sums and wants to ban it. Which advice fits Vygotsky? (i) Ban it; it disturbs others. (ii) Allow quiet self-talk, since it helps children guide their work, and expect it to fade into inner speech. (iii) Report it as a learning difficulty. (iv) Punish the children who whisper most. Working: Vygotsky saw private speech as a useful tool of thinking that naturally becomes inner speech. Answer: (ii).

Worked example 3: pick the psychological tool

Which is a psychological tool in Vygotsky's sense: a sickle, a bucket, the alphabet, a chair? Working: the sickle, bucket and chair act on the physical world. The alphabet is a system of signs that changes how we remember and think. Answer: the alphabet.

A last point that exams like: inner speech does not mean the end of language in thinking. Adults still think in words, silently, when they plan a day or work through a problem. Adults may also return to whispering aloud when a task becomes very hard, such as following unfamiliar directions. This fits Vygotsky's view that speech is a tool of self-regulation that never disappears; it simply moves inside.

Same self-talk, two readings: Piaget says egocentric and fading; Vygotsky says private, self-regulating, more on hard tasks, and turning into inner speech.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

Keep the self-talk table fixed in memory and check which thinker an option is describing. For Vygotsky, thought and language start apart and then join; language then organises thought. Psychological tools are systems of signs and symbols. Allowing private speech is the Vygotskian classroom response. The final teaching lesson applies the theory to classroom methods.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A child talks aloud to himself while solving a difficult puzzle. Which interpretation is Vygotsky's?

    1. He is showing egocentrism and cannot take others' viewpoint
    2. He is using private speech to guide his own actions
    3. He is trying to disturb the class
    4. He has a speech defect
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Vygotsky saw such talk as self-regulating private speech. The egocentrism interpretation is Piaget's.

  2. 2. According to Vygotsky, what eventually happens to private speech?

    1. It simply disappears with no trace
    2. It turns inward and becomes inner speech
    3. It turns into egocentric speech
    4. It becomes louder throughout adulthood
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Private speech goes underground and becomes silent inner speech, used in adult thinking.

  3. 3. Which is a psychological (symbolic) tool?

    1. A spade
    2. A cooking pot
    3. A map
    4. A table
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A map is a system of symbols for thinking about space. The others are physical tools or furniture.

  4. 4. A teacher notices pupils mutter more on hard sums than on easy ones. This matches:

    1. Vygotsky's view that private speech increases with task difficulty
    2. Piaget's view that self-talk shows egocentrism
    3. The behaviourist view that talk is reinforced
    4. None of these thinkers
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Vygotsky linked increased private speech to harder tasks that require more self-regulation.

  5. 5. Assertion: Vygotsky advised that private speech in young children should be allowed. Reason: He saw private speech as egocentric speech that serves no purpose.

    1. The Assertion is true, but the Reason is false
    2. Both the Assertion and the Reason are true, and the Reason correctly explains the Assertion
    3. Both the Assertion and the Reason are true, but the Reason does not explain the Assertion
    4. The Assertion is false, but the Reason is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Assertion fits Vygotsky, who valued private speech. The Reason is false: calling it purposeless egocentric speech is Piaget's view, not Vygotsky's.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery