• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Play and concept questions: what Vygotsky said and what he did not

Answer statement and scenario questions on Vygotsky's views of play and of everyday and scientific concepts, and avoid the traps in which play, rules or concepts are described in a non-Vygotskian way.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Play and concepts are two of the less famous parts of Vygotsky's theory, and examiners use them for questions where most candidates are unsure. The questions are easy if you know four short points on play and three on concepts, and they are tricky only because the wrong options sound natural. This lesson lists the points and then practises the traps.

Seven points

  • Play creates a zone of proximal development: in play the child acts ahead of everyday behaviour.
  • Pretend play uses an imaginary situation, and every imaginary situation contains rules.
  • Using an object as something else (a stick as a horse) separates meaning from the object and leads towards abstract thought.
  • Play helps self-regulation, because the child must keep to the rules of the role.
  • Everyday concepts come from experience and grow upwards.
  • Scientific concepts come from teaching in a system and grow downwards.
  • The two kinds of concept support each other.

Play: ZPD, imaginary situation, rules, meaning apart from the object, self-regulation. Concepts: everyday grow up, scientific come down, and they help each other.

Worked example 1: pick the Vygotskian statement

Which statement fits Vygotsky? (a) Play is mainly a way of using up energy. (b) Play has no rules, which is why it is free. (c) In imaginary play children follow rules and act ahead of their usual level. (d) Play should stop when school begins because it has nothing to teach. Working: (a), (b) and (d) deny the developmental value of play or the role of rules. Only (c) matches. The word to notice in (b) is 'no rules': Vygotsky's key point is that rules are always present, even when hidden.

Worked example 2: a scenario about play

A four-year-old holds a banana to her ear and says 'Hello, Nani!'. Working: she uses an object to stand for a telephone. The meaning (telephone) is separated from the object (banana) and guides her action. This is an example of the imaginary situation and object substitution, which Vygotsky linked to the growth of abstract thought. It does not show confusion about what a banana is.

Worked example 3: Piaget and Vygotsky on play

A question asks which thinker saw play mainly as the child's way of practising and assimilating what is already known, with stages such as practice play, symbolic play and games with rules. That is Piaget. The thinker who said play creates a zone of proximal development and has hidden rules is Vygotsky. The safe approach is to look for the keyword: ZPD or self-regulation signals Vygotsky, assimilation signals Piaget.

Worked example 4: a concept scenario

A Class 3 pupil uses the word 'plant' correctly for trees, grass and flowers but cannot say what makes something a plant. Her teacher shows pictures, explains that plants make their own food using sunlight, and then asks the class to sort leaves, stones and insects. Working: the pupil begins with an everyday concept of 'plant' (from experience, without a definition). The teacher introduces the scientific concept (a definition within a system of ideas) and links it to the pupil's experience. This matches Vygotsky's view that the two kinds of concept meet and strengthen each other.

Traps

  • 'Play has no rules' or 'play is free of rules': false for Vygotsky.
  • 'Everyday concepts are wrong and must be removed': false; they give scientific concepts their meaning.
  • 'Scientific concepts need no experience': false; without experience they remain empty definitions.
  • Mixing the thinkers: assimilation and stages of play point to Piaget.

Key takeaways: for Vygotsky, play has hidden rules, builds self-regulation and creates a ZPD; pretend objects separate meaning from the object. Everyday concepts grow upwards and scientific concepts come downwards, and each strengthens the other. Check the keyword to identify the thinker.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which statement about play fits Vygotsky?

    1. Play has no rules, and that makes it free
    2. Play is mainly a way to use up spare energy
    3. Imaginary play has rules and lifts the child's level
    4. Play must end once formal schooling begins
    Show answer

    Answer: C. For Vygotsky every imaginary situation has rules, and play creates a ZPD in which the child acts ahead of usual behaviour.

  2. 2. A child talks into a banana as if it were a telephone. What does this show?

    1. Meaning has begun to separate from the object
    2. The child cannot recognise a real banana
    3. The child is repeating an adult's phrase
    4. The child has outgrown all pretend play
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Using one object to stand for another shows that the child is acting on a meaning, not only on what is seen.

  3. 3. Which keyword points to Vygotsky, not Piaget, in a question on play?

    1. Assimilation of familiar actions
    2. Practice play with objects
    3. Preoperational thinking
    4. Zone of proximal development
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The idea that play creates a ZPD is Vygotsky's. Assimilation and the stages of play belong to Piaget.

  4. 4. Which concept would Vygotsky call a scientific concept?

    1. Knowing a particular tree in the garden
    2. The idea of a plant defined in school science
    3. Knowing that the sun feels warm
    4. Recognising the family dog
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Scientific concepts are learnt through teaching and defined within a system of ideas. The others come from daily experience.

  5. 5. How does Vygotsky relate everyday and scientific concepts?

    1. Each supports and strengthens the other
    2. Everyday concepts must be erased before teaching
    3. Scientific concepts develop without any experience
    4. The two never influence each other at all
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Experience gives scientific concepts their meaning, and scientific concepts make everyday ones conscious and deliberate.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery